Work

Insiders and outsiders in Mexican archaeology (1890-1930)

Year: 2003
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation narrates the history of archaeological practices in Mexico \nduring the period from the 1890s to the late 1920s. Though this work examines \nMexican archaeology, its focus is in the interactions between North American and \nMexican archaeologies. More than describing those interactions, I look and \ntheorize the nature of these relationships. I divided this dissertation in three \nsections; each of them takes a different lens to illustrate interactions. The first \nsection looks at two explorations during the last decade of the nineteenth century: \nCarl Lumholtz’s expeditions to Northern Mexico and the Loubat expedition in \nSouthern Mexico. Those two expeditions aimed to collect anthropological and \narchaeological items, but established different relations with Mexico. Section two \nexamines the International School of American Archaeology and Ethnology, \nfounded in Mexico City in 1910. I examine the school as an institution with a \nmultinational character and where issues of nationalism, internationalism and \nscience were visible. The last section in this dissertation examines more \nspecifically the work of Zelia Nuttall, a North American woman archaeologist \nwho settled in Mexico in the early years of the twentieth century. The experience \nof this woman enables me to examine issues of gender and professionalization in \narchaeology at the turn of the twentieth century. The three levels of interactions I \nexamine in this dissertation illustrate how the idea of insiders and outsiders was \nprevalent in the functioning of archaeology in Mexico. In addition, it also shows \nthat nation and gender permeated the archaeologies of Mexico and the United \nStates. In the case of expeditions, the United States viewed Mexico as a \nfemenized space that needed the entrance of science to study its ruins. But at the \nsame time, the Mexican state used those outside expeditions for its internal \npurposes, to reinforce a sense of national patrimony. The International School on \nthe other hand is an example of how nationalism was a factor that hindered the \nnotion of an international, a-political archaeology. Finally, Zelia Nuttall’s \nexperience illustrates how women were considered outsiders to archaeology’s \npractice despite the fact that they participated in central aspects of this profession.
Author: Carmen Romero Ruiz
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1653040726
Cites: 104
Cited by: 4
Related to: 8