DSM ‐5 substance use disorder: how conceptual missteps weakened the foundations of the addictive disorders field
Year: 2015
Type: editorial
Abstract: DSM-5 substance use disorder: how conceptual missteps weakened the foundations of the addictive disorders field DSM-5, following the recommendations of its substance-related disorders workgroup, radically reformulated the diagnostic criteria for substance use disorder (SUD).The changes have generated considerable controversy and concern, and are here reviewed and evaluated. DSM-IV dependence and abuseDSM-IV included two substance use disorders, substance dependence and substance abuse.Dependence attempted directly to capture the concept of addiction as a psychiatric disorder, understood as impaired-control use.(The label addiction itself was narrowly rejected in earlier DSM revisions due to its purportedly pejorative nature.)Dependence diagnosis required any three or more of seven possible symptoms indicating impairedcontrol substance use, including two physiological dependence symptoms (tolerance, withdrawal) and five behavioural symptoms (giving up activities, continuing use despite harmful physical or psychological effects, trying to stop but cannot, taking larger amounts than intended, spending much time obtaining and taking the substance).Abuse diagnosis represented problematic use and required any one or more of four possible substance-related symptoms, including hazardous use (most commonly, driving while intoxicated), interpersonal problems (e.g., arguing with spouse), failure to fulfill role obligations at work, school, or home, and legal problems.'Abuse' has long been a questionable disorder category.The 'dependence syndrome' model of addiction as impaired control over use (1, 2) is generally accepted as the most plausible conceptual justification for understanding addiction as a true psychiatric disorder rather than as moral weakness, social deviance, or rational choice.Since DSM-III-R, DSM diagnostic criteria for substance use disorders have been based on this model.Consistent with the model, the original intention was
Source: Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica
DOI: 10.1111/acps.12446
Author: J. C. Wakefield
Institution: New York University
Language: English
Subfield: Epidemiology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1657187716
