Naturalizing as an error-type in Biology
Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: . Biologists make mistakes--but they can also find them and remedy them. I survey a series of cases where idealizations and assumptions about normality have shaped common erroneous biological concepts: male and female; developmental abnormalities; competition in evolution; and laws of nature. Such scientific interpretations of nature can have profound social consequences. Identifying such recurring errors thematically, however, can guide analysis that improves the reliability of scientific claims. Here, I profile naturalizing as one such error type and map the prospective solutions. What seems more natural than boy and girl, man and woman, male and female? That, indeed, I think is a problem. And I want to probe it, along with some other cases, to profile a thematic category of errors found especially in biology. By profiling and characterizing these errors —or this error-type — I hope to support more effective regulation of error in science. This contributes to a larger endeavor — Error Analytics — for improving scientific practice through more active, philosophically informed analysis of potential error. Understanding error types can foster greater awareness, discourse and education about methods for minimizing, alleviating or compensating for such errors.
Source: Filosofia e História da Biologia
Author: Douglas Allchin
Institution: University of Minnesota
Language: Portuguese
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W167877967
