Work

How to do things with rules: A primer of interpretation

Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: The fourth edition of this excellent introductory law text is still impressive in its sophisticated fusion of doctrine and theory, reflection and practice.It is unlike many books presently available which share its general aims, stated by Twining and Miers as being to 'provide a relatively systematic introduction to one aspect of rule-handling: interpretation and application'.'In fact, the book achieves far more than that, introducing important legal techniques in a broad and critical context.It is soundly advised by educational theory and it takes the idea of fusing theory with an area as practical as rule interpretation seriously.2It does not follow the present fashion of learning skills in the context of a specific area of law; rather, the skills of rule interpretation and application are the focus of the book?Writing for an audience composed mainly of novices to the law is not easy.This is particularly so when one is attempting to introduce difficult theoretical concepts in a way that makes sensible their relation to legal doctrine.How to Do Things with Rules succeeds admirably in this task.It is a substantial, comprehensive, extremely well designed and written book which provides an excellent introduction to the theories and processes of manipulating legal rules and institutions.My main general criticism of the book concerns the way in which the authors appear to draw an equation between 'law' and 'rules'.,It is unfortunate that they have done so without indicating how they understand the relation between law and rules, and why they chose to focus on that aspect of lawness.In the context of discussing Dworkin's contribution to the debate on interpretation, the authors do refer to the distinction which others have drawn between rules and 'other forms of normative prescription', including principles.'However, the difference between rules and other prescriptions, and the significance of the difference, is not clearly explained.Indeed, the reader is asked to explain the difference well before there is any explanation forthcoming in the text.,I would expect this to confuse those who are not conversant with the debate.It risks creating or perpetuating a particular apprehension about the nature of the legal enterprise, which is not necessary.
Author: Mary Keyes
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W168096265
FWCI: 4.595
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10