Work

Sacred stories of classroom, school, county, and state: Navigating professional knowledge landscapes in the face of mandated reading initiatives

Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: The purpose of this study was to examine the nature of collaboration among \nmembers of a first grade team as they participated in a state mandated reading initiative. The second purpose was to examine how top-down mandates of state reading initiatives \nand collaboration among team members translated into “secret stories” of classroom \ninstruction for the three focus teachers. The study also considered my role as the campus \nreading coach, as I attempted to facilitate the translation of the reading initiative to meet \nthe diverse needs of the team members, while navigating issues of power among the \ncampus administration and the first grade team. Qualitative research methods were used \nto document and describe (a) the interactions and collaboration of the first grade team \nduring grade level reading meetings; (b) the formation of micro-groups due to power \nissues; (c) literacy practices of the three focus teachers and; (d) the secret stories of members of the first grade team as they navigated the troubled landscape of the second \nyear of the reading initiative. The first grade meetings were observed and documented for \nfive months, as teachers completed the reading initiative modules and attempted to \ntranslate those practices in order to complement their existing classroom practices. Each \nof the three focus first grade teachers was interviewed and recorded during classroom \ninstruction. Interviews with students were also conducted in order to gain the perspective \nof literacy practices from a child’s point of view. Data for the study included field notes \nfrom observations, student and teacher interviews, digital images of student work and \nclassroom texts, and digital video and audio recordings of interviews and classroom \ninstruction. The findings of the study indicate that teachers translated staff development \npractices in accordance with their existing beliefs and tended to gravitate toward and \ncollaborate with those who shared common pedagogical beliefs. The role of the reading \ncoach was best served when the coaching protocols were transparent to all team \nmembers. The study revealed the inevitability of conflict in an atmosphere of \ncollaboration as well as the notion that teachers are the true curriculum makers regardless \nof the initiative.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1737569912
FWCI: 1.022
Cites: 82
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10