Work

Developing statistical inquiry: prospective secondary mathematics and science teachers' investigations of equity and fairness through analysis of accountability data

Year: 2004
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Concerns about equity in the ways that schools are using the data from the \nresults of their students’ state-mandated exams (Confrey & Makar, in press) prompted \nthis mixed-method study, based on the model of Design Research (Cobb et al., 2003). \nThe study was conducted to provide insight into the ways that understanding of the \nstatistical concepts of variation and distribution, developed in the context of learning \nabout equity and assessment, can allow prospective teachers to broaden their \nunderstanding of equity and gain experience with conducting an inquiry of an illstructured \nproblem through the use of data generated by high-stakes tests to investigate \nequity and fairness in the accountability system. The study took place in an innovative \none-semester course for preservice teachers designed to support and develop \nunderstanding of equity and fairness in accountability through data-based statistical \ninquiry (Confrey, Makar, and Kazak, 2004). The prospective teachers’ investigations \nwere conducted using Fathom Dynamic Statistics (Finzer, 2001), a learning software \nbuilt for novice data analysts which emphasizes visualization and building inferential \nthinking through highlighting relationships between multiple variable displays. Semistructured \ninvestigations during the course led up to a three-week self-designed inquiry \nproject in which the prospective teachers used data to investigate an area of interest to \nthem about equity in accountability, communicating their findings both orally and as a \nwritten paper. \nResults from the study provide insight into prospective teachers’ experiences of \nconducting inquiry of ill-structured problems and their struggle with articulating beliefs \nof equity. The study also reports how statistical concepts documented in structured \nsettings showed that the subjects developed rich conceptions of variation and \ndistribution, but that the application of these concepts as evidence in their inquiry of an \nill-structured problem was more challenging for them. No correlation was found \nbetween the level of statistical evidence in the structured and open-ended inquiry \nsettings, however there was a significant correlation between prospective teachers \ndegree of engagement with their topic of inquiry and the depth of statistical evidence \nthey used, particularly for minority students. Implications and suggestions for \nimproving the preparation of teachers in the areas of statistical reasoning, inquiry, \nequity, and interpreting assessment data are provided.
Author: Katie Makar
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1746092875
Cites: 149
Cited by: 19
Related to: 10