Work

An investigation into the role of public participation in achieving social justice: a case study of EIAs undertaken (under old and new regulations) in South Durban

Year: 2010
Type: dissertation
Abstract: ABSTRACT \nPost-apartheid South Africa has included the concepts of environmental and social justice in it’s \nenvironmental policy agenda so as to address the injustices of the past. Environmental assessment \ntools like the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) have been adopted to address \nenvironmental impacts. Participation is an important process of an EIA, which seeks to include \nthe marginalized in environmental decision-making. With the scaling down of the EIA process in \n2006, recent debates have highlighted the implications for effective and informed public \nparticipation. Further highlighted in these debates are a number of handicaps with regard to the \npractice of effective and influential public participation in EIAs. Firstly, there has been no further \nguidance on the process as compared to the 1997 EIA regulations. Secondly, the public are not \nprovided the opportunity to play a role in project design, resulting in participation being a mere \nformality. Thirdly, the public are not included after the completion of the EIA hence the public \ndo not have a say on compliance to environmental management plans. This study has argued \nbased on evidence from four EIAs in South Durban that there is no effective and influential role \nplayed by the public participation process as there was little to no representivity of the actual \n‘public’ at public meetings in EIAs in South Durban. This is highlighted by the fact that contrary \nto what is stipulated in the 2006 EIA regulations; public participation is seen and implemented as \na rigid one size fits all process especially in the South Durban region. Public meetings were the \nonly technique used other than those prescribed by the regulations in three out of the four EIAs. \nTo an extent the public participation process of EIAs under the 2006 regulations has fallen back a \nnotch in including the voices of the actual ‘public’ as conservative methods of participation are \nbeing used as compared to those EIAs under the 1997 regulations. However, this has less to do \nwith the actual techniques used but more to do with the objective of the participation process \nitself. The local context of South Durban has also played a vital role in hindering participation \nwith environmental and community organizations in South Durban dominating public meetings \nand distancing the actual ‘public’ from influencing the decision-making process. The extent and \nquality of participation in the 2006 regulations shows a shift away from an environmental justice \napproach as the views of the actual ‘public’ and their representivity in influencing the decisionmaking \nprocess was not achieved. Therefore, more emphasis needs to be placed on participatory \ndemocratic methods of participation as compared to the current representative democratic \nstructures used in the environmental decision-making process in South Africa.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W175207624
Cites: 33
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10