WikiLeaks| Digital Prometheus: WikiLeaks, the State–Network Dichotomy, and the Antinomies of Academic Reason
Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: This article analyzes two major threads of academic discussions on the WikiLeaks phenomenon and its influence on international and communication studies, which cause a refuelling and reframing of both the questions and the solutions offered by academics and practitioners in these fields.The research examines a sample of the academic literature produced in 2010-2012, in order to trace how WikiLeaks reframed age-old academic debates: In international relations and politics, the major debate is between transparency and secrecy/security.In media and communication studies the major debate is openness versus control.Perspectives are further divided, not only by discipline but also ideologically by the author's position on the state-network dichotomy.In turn, different academic disciplines can be themselves mapped in terms of their relative closeness to the statist or network side of the controversy.Recently, we witnessed the diffuse affects and subject-positions mobilized by WikiLeaks through the "Revolutionary Virtual"-the field of construction in which zones of affect are selected and actualized International Journal of Communication 8 (2014) Digital Prometheus 2705 (Karatzogianni, 2012).As a creation of new zones or assemblages of affect, the WikiLeaks phenomenon can be seen as an event and, like all events, it is controversial.The study of WikiLeaks' academic reception is thus a study of the reverberation of an Event through the social field.WikiLeaks can be viewed through the figure of Prometheus-the archetypal Internet troll of Greek mythology.Milan (2013) uses the metaphor to tell the stories of groups and individuals who seek to break government and media corporate monopolies: "who like the mythological Prometheus, 'steal the fire'… a metaphor for technology and communication infrastructure . . .Stealing means 'reclaiming and reappropriating' these communications infrastructures to set up autonomous means of communication" (p.1).Prometheus is a trickster figure.Tricksters in mythology are typically on the side of creativity and chance and, crucially, aligned with the rebel who defies and escapes the order of Fate: "the hero-for example, Prometheus-challenges fate with dignified courage, fights it with varying fortunes, and is not left by the legend without hope of one day bringing a new law to men" (Benjamin, 1995, p. 294).WikiLeaks here stands for exactly such a gesture: Within the world of neoliberalism, the fatalistic advancement of global capital, and of the State as the bearer of Fate (ibid.), has been interrupted by a technological "progress" long forecast by the fatalists, but detourned decisively from their fatalistic narrative of progression.Instead, this Promethean flame is an uncontrollable force of networked power, which seems chaotic from within the statist order of Fate.Methodologically, we analyze the ideology in academic scholarship by mapping along two axes of the intellectual controversy, which arise in the academic literature immediately after the Collateral Damage video in July 2010.We used Google Scholar to capture academic scholarship and opinion from the summer of 2010 to December 2012, with an original sample of 40 articles, which then extended to snowball sampling stemming from the original sample.Of these, we chose to focus only on the two disciplines.Moreover, we chose that specific timeframe for sampling and did not include the years 2013-2014, an effect of the journal review timeline process, and further, it would take the scope of the study to another level altogether, considering the academic literature involving several subfields.Unfortunately, this means we left out the most significant academic contribution in relation to the WikiLeaks phenomenon thus far by Brevini, Hintz, and McCurdy (2013) and other important works from 2013-2014, which could be examined in future studies.Thus, the work, reflexive of its limitations, presents a broad meta-analysis of the debates surrounding academic scholarship within a specific timeframe, and does not pose itself as an overall meta-analysis of all fields affected by the WikiLeaks phenomenon to this day.Further, a whole section on whistleblowing and legal scholarship as well as several scholars referenced in the extended version of this article are omitted here due to space limitations.Nevertheless, the working paper has been made available (see Robinson & Karatzogianni, 2012).We found that in international relations (IR) and related disciplines, including diplomacy studies, the main focus is on transparency versus secrecy: the ethics of whistleblowing versus national security, the impact of leaks on the "war on terror" and American foreign policy, and so on.In disciplines more closely aligned to the social such as culture, media, communication studies, and sociology, the major debate is between openness versus control.Issues include the relationship between WikiLeaks and the hacker ethic, the constraint of overwhelming state power, the emergence of a global digital public sphere, the changing relationships between old and new media, and the emergence of shifts in social relationships
Authors: Athina Karatzogianni, Andrew Robinson
Institution: University of Leicester
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W1778625726
