Work

Federalism as Fairness

Year: 2011
Type: article
Abstract: U NTIL recently, contemporary political philosophy had not devoted much attention to federalism.Theories of federalism were mainly developed from the perspectives of political science and law, and remained largely empirical in nature. 1 Yet, in the past decade, some first normative political approaches have started to appear. 2 Interestingly, this recent interest in federalism has by and large 3 coincided with-and can perhaps be seen as the result of-the emergence of a politico-theoretical interest in multinational states and in the issue of minority rights for national groups who live in such states.Many of the theorists in this recent field of normative federalism for multinational states-perhaps with Will Kymlicka as their main representative-have focused on federalism's ability to provide self-government to sub-state national groups, such as the Catalans, the Flemish and the Québécois.National identities are believed by them to have a profound significance in people's lives and federal systems offer the possibility of protecting these national identities and of giving them abilities for self-government.I believe that there is much to say in favor of such a conception of multinational federalism.National cultures matter to people and federalism enables people to maintain their own national culture.Yet it seems to me that there is a tendency in many of these new theories of multinational federalism to assume the view that federalism is essentially and merely a mechanism to provide sub-state nations with self-government.I wish to argue that, although it is partially valid, as a full-fledged theory of federalism this view has several shortcomings.Firstly, theorizing federalism
Institution: KU Leuven
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1782319176
FWCI: 8.185
Cites: 35
Cited by: 76
Related to: 10