Competing Arbitrary and Non-Arbitrary Stimulus Relationsin Adults, Normally Developing Children and Children witha Diagnosis of Autism
Year: 2010
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The current thesis sought to extend the work of Stewart, Barnes-Holmes,\nRoche, and Smeets (2002) who reported that competing non-arbitrary stimulus\nrelations disrupted equivalence-consistent responding in adult humans. Chapter 1\nprovides a review of research into stimulus equivalence, derived relational\nresponding, and notes that the Colour-Test condition presented in the Stewart et al.\n(2002) study shared many features of tests traditionally used to measure executive\nfunction (EF). An introduction is also provided to cognitive theories of EF.\nThe study presented in Chapter 2 provides support for Stewart et al. (2002)\nand reports that participants who were trained with black stimuli but tested with\ncoloured stimuli showed lower levels of equivalence-consistent responding relative to\nother groups. Results also showed that while training with coloured stimuli is\neffective in undermining colour as a source of non-arbitrary stimulus control,\nexemplar training with black stimuli is shown not to be effective in undermining nonarbitrary\nstimulus control across stimulus sets. However, when exemplar training is\ncombined with colour training participants produced the highest levels of\nequivalence-consistent responding\nChapter 3 reports a study in which normally developing young children were\npresented with a table top match-to-sample training and testing procedure modified to\nmake it appropriate to the abilities of this younger population. The modifications\nrequired participants to demonstrate criterion levels of equivalence with familiar\nstimuli and with novel stimuli coloured black prior to the introduction of a competing\ncolour relation. All participants readily demonstrated equivalence-consistent\nresponding with black stimuli and, critically, maintained equivalence when a\ncompeting colour relation was introduced.\nChapter 4 presents two studies using a participant population of young\nchildren diagnosed with autism. Study 1 employed a reduced training and testing\nprocedure but the participant failed to demonstrate equivalence class formation in any\ntest condition. However, when six participants diagnosed with autism were\nsubsequently exposed to the full training and testing procedures in Study 2, all six\nparticipants demonstrate equivalence-class formation with black stimuli. Critically,\nfive of the six participants failed to maintain equivalence when a competing colour\nrelation was introduced during testing, showing clear disruption from the competing\ncolour relation.\nChapter 5 presents a number of studies that sought to determine if training\nwith coloured stimuli would remediate the disruption of equivalence observed for the\nfive participants who completed Study 2 reported in Chapter 4. Study 1 demonstrated\nthat colour training was effective in undermining non-arbitrary stimulus control\nwithin the same stimulus set for all participants. Subsequent studies showed that all\nparticipants maintained equivalence-consistent responding in the presence of\ncompeting colour relations across new sets of novel stimuli.\nChapter 6 then describes two studies that sought to determine if undermining\ncolour as a source of non-arbitrary stimulus control would also facilitate participants\nin maintaining equivalence in the presence of other sources of competing nonarbitrary\nstimulus control. Study 1 showed that participants successfully maintained\nequivalence-consistent responding when a competing shape relation was introduced\nand Study 2 showed that two participants also maintained equivalence when both\nshape and colour relations were simultaneously introduced during testing.\nThe studies presented in Chapter 7 employed two experimentally naïve\nparticipants and demonstrated that competing shape relations disrupted equivalence\nclass formation when introduced during testing. Subsequent studies showed that shape\ntraining was effective in undermining shape as a source of non-arbitrary stimulus\ncontrol and participants maintained equivalence when a competing colour relation\nwas subsequently introduced.\nChapter 8 provides a summary of the findings in the current research\nprogramme and considers a number of methodological and conceptual issues arising\nfrom the studies, identifying possible weaknesses and questions that could be targeted\nin future research. The relationship between the current research and the cognitive\nconcept of EF is also considered and clarified. Finally, it is concluded that further\nresearch into competing non-arbitrary stimulus control over derived relational\nresponding may be important in understanding and treating deficits associated with\nautism.
Author: Neil Kenny
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: Irish Research Council
OpenAlex ID: W1788117512
