An analysis and evaluation of alternative means of consumer redress other than redress through ordinary judicial proceedings
Year: 2007
Type: report
Abstract: This document constitutes the final report in the framework of the research project: "An analysis and evaluation of alternative means of consumer redress other than redress through ordinary judicial proceedings, in the twenty-five Member States of the European Union, as well as in Australia, Canada and the United States of America".The study was commissioned by the European Commission, DG Sanco, in November 2005, with the final report due to be completed and submitted on 15 November 2006.The whole research -consisting of more than seven hundred pages of national reports, a comparative report of more than four hundred pages, including an executive summary as well as a pan-European online survey of consumer satisfaction -has been conducted in a record period of less than 12 months.The report is not a definitive report on "alternative dispute resolution" (ADR).There are various limitations -including methodological limitations, the inevitable lack of completeness, the limits of the end-user and incentives-based approach which was adopted, and the policy implications of certain of our observations -that may render it subject to criticism from different viewpoints.The authors believe that such academic criticism should be welcomed.The report is aimed at identifying a framework of analysis and assessment, in order to offer the European Commission a critical synthesis of what methods of alternative dispute resolution exist.If this study is taken seriously, it must lead to follow-up research and discussion.Member States are experimenting with collective actions.However, in Member States where there is no such collective action available , or in Member States where the experiments may not have the desired effect, consumers may have no means to obtain redress. ACTIONS FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF Findings Of The Report -More Uniformity Due To The Injunction's DirectiveThe report defines an injunction as "a cease and desist order, issued by a court or other public body, whereby a court or a body orders a party to stop a certain practice".As a result of the Injunctions Directive, this field is the most uniform of the four kinds of legal mechanisms analyzed in the report.The Injunctions Directive entitles the Member States to empower "qualified entities" to take injunctive actions against traders in another Member State of the EU in order to protect the collective interests of consumers in the case of infringements of provisions of the directives listed in its Annex.The Injunctions Directive leaves it to the autonomy of the Member States to provide for procedural rules applicable to actions for injunctions.In effect, injunction procedures follow the rules applicable to ordinary court proceedings in the vast majority of the Member States.This is the case both in relation to the competence of the courts and the progress of court proceedings.The major remedy for injunction procedures is a n order requiring the cessation or prohibition of infringements harmful to the collective interests of consumers ("a cease and desist order").Apart from Sweden, where legal possibilities exist to claim damages in injunction procedures, in all other Member States damages can only be claimed in separate court proceedings.By contrast to the Injunctions Directive as implemented in the majority of the EU Member States, the regulation of injunctive procedures in the USA, Canada and Australia usually also allows damages to be claimed in the injunction procedures.Moreover, individual consumers are allowed to initiate injunction procedures (which is only possible in few EU Member States).In the United States, the legal regime of injunction procedures is principally the same as for collective actions aiming at the protection of a series of individual interests ("class actions"). Critical AssessmentThe report shows that the mechanism of the Directive reveals certain shortcomings.First, the scope of an injunction is limited to the territory of one Member State; the order is not pan-European.Second, businesses can defy the enforcement of injunctions by changing only certain aspects of their violation.Only if a new infringement is, in its core, identical to the first one, can the
Source: Lirias
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1817158373
