Vuorovaikutuskaavion käytön vaikutus voimakäsitteen oppimiseen lukion mekaniikan opetusjaksoilla
Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Previous studies have shown that after physics instruction many students have various difficulties in understanding the concept of force and Newton’s laws. One proposed solution has been to teach the concept of force as a result of interaction. The purpose of this study is to find out if the interaction diagram, a visual representation of objects and the interactions between them, could help students in understanding Newton’s third law, identifying forces and constructing the correct free body diagram. The study was conducted with five different teaching groups in five upper secondary schools in Western and Eastern Finland. Two teaching and learning sequences on interaction and force as well as on Newton’s laws were designed for the national compulsory course in physics (Physics 1) and for the optional course in mechanics (Physics 4). Three of the schools were transfer schools (Physics 1, N = 75; Physics 4, N = 49, aged 16 – 17); that is, the teachers implemented the teaching as designed but did not participate in planning the research. Two teachers from the control schools (Physics 1, N = 58; Physics 4, N = 31, aged 16 – 17) implemented the teaching and learning sequences according to their own design together with the textbook. The same textbook introducing the use of the interaction diagram was used in all the schools. The teaching design emphasized the use of the interaction diagram, and Newton’s third law was taught before Newton’s other laws. The test questions used to measure the students’ learning were compiled for various physical situations and states of motion. The questions on Newton’s third law were adapted from tests used in previous studies, whereas the exercises on the interaction diagram and the free body diagram for the same physical situation were mainly compiled by the researcher. The test results indicate that the transfer students were able to construct better interaction diagrams than the control students. They also had better mastery of Newton’s third law than the control students in both teaching and learning sequences. The transfer students were also able to better identify forces and construct correct free body diagrams, where the vector sum of forces corresponded with the state of motion in a given situation, as compared to the control students. The study found a connection between the use of interaction diagrams and the ability to construct a free body diagram, and the connection was stronger in the transfer schools than in the control schools. Similarly, an association was found between the improved use of interaction diagrams and a better mastery of Newton’s third law. The results lead to the conclusion that the use of the interaction diagram in teaching the concept of force helps students to learn Newton’s third law as well as to learn how to identify forces and to construct the correct free body diagram.
Author: Asko Mäkynen
Institution: University of Jyväskylä
Language: Finnish
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1817722070
