Studies on ontological and methodological foundations of critical realism in the social sciences
Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: 2 (nid.)Finnish summary Diss.This study analyses and evaluates the ontological and methodological foundations of the critical realist tradition in the social sciences.It is argued that the Kantian transcendental arguments used by Roy Bhaskar and some other critical realists in the justification of the critical realist ontology are problematic.The study indicates that critical realists fail to demonstrate how it is possible to acquire knowledge of the structure of reality, which is thought to exist independently of human knowledge and/or activities, by means of using a priori forms of argumentation.The concepts of causal power, emergence and social structure, which are all fundamental to critical realist social ontology, are also examined and evaluated.It is argued that these concepts are used ambiguously in Bhaskar's early works and that their uses in the context of social ontology contain certain problematic presuppositions.In addition to critical evaluation of certain critical realist arguments and positions, this work seeks to develop scientifically realist and emergent materialist alternatives to the arguments and doctrines criticized.It is contended that a naturalistic method of argumentation in the context of ontology avoids the problems associated with the employment of Kantian transcendental arguments by critical realists.Furthermore, the nontranscendental and moderately non-essentalist interpretation of the concept of causal power is outlined and contrasted with Bhaskar's essentialist and transcendental version of this concept.It is also argued that causal relations may not be open to single ontological definition.A systemic interpretation of the concepts of social system and social structure, which is largely based on Mario Bunge's works, is provided as an alternative to the critical realist "depthrelational" social ontology.It is argued that a combination of Bunge's systemic social ontology and William Wimsatt's gradual notion of emergence provides a promising alternative to Bhaskar's ambiguous concept of social emergence.
Author: Tuukka Kaidesoja
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1845640056
