Work

A nation's nature : framing the public discussion of genetically modified crops in Britain

Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Two key cultural concepts, 'nation’ and ‘nature’, have shaped the British debate on \ngenetic modification (GM). The thesis uses focus groups, semi-structured interviews \nand newspaper analysis to explore how the concepts of nation and nature are used at \ndifferent moments during the process of communication. It examines media influence \nwithin the GM debate and also considers other resources that audiences draw upon \nwhen talking about GM. \nThe study found that, although most focus group participants reproduced dominant \nmedia frames, they were not just passive consumers of the media. They creatively \nsynthesised a wide range of cultural resources in support of those frames. The thesis, \nhowever, concludes that it is not accurate to describe such activity as 'resistance'. The study found that the media provide crucial discursive resources for the \nconstruction of identity. This has a significant effect on how people understand \nthemselves, the modes of action they consider appropriate, who they trust and how \nthey understand social difference. The thesis concludes that nationality is still a key \nway in which people make sense of the world but that Britain is principally depicted as \na nation of consumers rather than citizens. \nGM is predominantly depicted as unnatural. The research indicates that framing risk \ndebates around nature premises physiological as opposed to social risks. Both nature \nand nation are 'categories of certainty'; they have been used within the Western world \nto structure how people understand themselves and the world around them. The focus \non these categories puts ideas of security and fear at the centre of the GM debate. Frames promoted by environmental NGOs dominated the coverage. The study \nconsiders their implications and argues NGOs should not be exclusively concerned \nwith making 'pragmatic', politically expedient demands that do not challenge the basis \nof inequality. Rather, they should be contributing to a political project which envisages \nnew ways of organising society.
Author: Emma Hughes
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1872063264
Cites: 25
Cited by: 1
Related to: 9