Work

Tales From the Tail: What Do We Really Know About Sperm Motility?

Year: 2003
Type: review
Abstract: Male factor infertility is a significant problem in humans and domestic animals (Lunenfeld and Insler, 1993). In humans, it is estimated that 20% of couples are infertile and that, in 50% of these cases, the infertility can be attributed, at least in part, to the male partner (World Health Organization, 1990). Similarly, in animals, it is likely that infertility in the male is at least as common as in the female. Economic losses due to reproductive inefficiency in male animals can be substantial, particularly when infertility affects a genetically superior individual (Roberts, 1986). Although some instances of male factor infertility can be explained by readily identifiable pathologies of the reproductive tract or deficiencies in reproductive hormones, many others remain idiopathic. Common problems in subfertile and infertile human and animal patients include low sperm numbers, low numbers of morphologically normal sperm, and low numbers of motile sperm (Linford et al, 1976; Boyle et al, 1992; Pickett, 1992; Wallace, 1992). Although the correlations between sperm numbers and fertility as well as sperm morphology and fertility are not always strong, it is generally accepted that immotile or poorly motile sperm are incapable of fertilization without extensive laboratory assistance. Yet in spite of the importance of sperm motility to reproduction, reduced sperm motility remains only a clinical sign of infertility, and we actually understand very little about the signaling pathways and molecular mechanisms that control the assembly and function of the normal mammalian sperm flagellum. Modern assisted reproductive techniques such as intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) now allow us to minimize and even bypass the requirement for sperm motility in male fertility. However, the success of these techniques only increases our need to better understand the genes and proteins that are not functioning normally in these subfertile populations of sperm. Without this knowledge, we may inadvertently pass on genetic defects to future generations. A more complete understanding of the molecular processes that go into the creation of a motile sperm will enable us to address the issue of reduced motility and associated subfertility more effectively in the clinic. Eventually, poor sperm motility might be able to be treated or even cured through genetic therapy rather than simply being bypassed by ICSI. Viewed from a different angle, knowledge of the molecules that are required to assemble a functional flagellum may allow us to eventually intentionally disrupt the normal function of crucial, sperm-specific proteins, which could result in the development of a safe, effective male contraceptive. The purpose of the present article is to review the current understanding of the molecular mechanisms that contribute to normal mammalian flagellar function and sperm motility. Much of the information summarized here was gained through the study of model systems, including mice, rats, hamsters, and other species. However, the ultrastructure of mammalian sperm is highly conserved, and it is likely that many of the genes, proteins, and protein functions identified in laboratory animal species also are conserved in humans and domestic animals. Nonetheless, this may not always be the case, and I have attempted to point out those incidences in which functionally relevant species differences have been identified. Most mammalian sperm display two types of physiological motility: activated motility, as is seen in freshly ejaculated sperm, and hyperactivated motility, as is seen in most sperm recovered from the site of fertilization (Katz and Yanagimachi, 1980; Suarez and Osman, 1987). The flagellum of an activated sperm generates a symmetrical, lower amplitude waveform that drives the sperm in a relatively straight line. In contrast, once sperm from most species become hyperactivated, the flagellar beat becomes asymmetrical and higher amplitude, which results in circular or figure-eight trajectories (Yanagimachi, 1970, 1994; Ishijima et al, 2002). Current evidence suggests that the role of activated motility is to aid in propelling the sperm through the female reproductive tract to the oviduct, whereas the role of hyperactivated motility is to help sperm detach from the oviductal epithelium, reach the site of fertilization, and penetrate the cumulus and zona pellucida of the oocyte (Suarez et al, 1991; Stauss et al, 1995; Ho and Suarez, 2001). There is good evidence that both activated and hyperactivated motility are important for normal fertility. In the case of activated motility, immotile sperm generally are unable to reach the uterotubal junction. This has been clearly demonstrated in rats (Gaddum-Rosse, 1981). Additionally, in a number of species, including humans, there is strong clinical evidence suggesting that decreases in activated sperm motility decrease male fertility. Hyperactivated motility has been shown to enhance the ability of a sperm to reach the site of fertilization and to penetrate the egg vestments. In rodents, and probably in other species as well, hyperactivated motility is also correlated with the ability of a sperm to fertilize an oocyte in vitro (Fraser and Quinn, 1981; Boatman and Robbins, 1991). The majority of the present review will discuss the molecular mechanisms involved with the regulation of activated sperm motility (also referred to as "sperm motility" or "motility"). Items that are specifically relevant to hyperactivated sperm motility will be pointed out throughout the text. One of the earlier approaches to studying the mechanisms involved in sperm motility was to study the ultrastructure of the sperm tail. As a result, although our understanding of the molecular components of the sperm flagellum is incomplete, the flagellar ultrastructure has been well characterized and provides a starting point from which to study the function of the individual protein components of the tail. The ultrastructure of the mammalian flagellum is highly conserved and is composed of a number of cytoskeletal elements whose proper assembly is critical for sperm motility. The flagellum is structurally divided into four major parts: the connecting piece, the midpiece, the principal piece, and the end piece (Figure 1; Fawcett, 1975). The connecting piece is the portion of the flagellum that attaches to the implantation fossa of the nucleus in the sperm head. From the remnant of the centriole at this point, the axoneme extends throughout the length of the flagellum. The axoneme is a cytoskeletal structure composed of a ring of 9 microtubule doublets surrounding a central pair. Inner and outer dynein arms project from each of the outer 9 doublets, and these arms are responsible for generating the motive force of the flagellum. Additionally, 9 radial spokes, each of which originates from 1 of the 9 outer microtubular doublet pairs, project inward toward the central pair in a helical fashion. The midpiece also begins at the connecting piece and is characterized by the presence of 9 outer dense fibers (ODFs) that lie outside each of the 9 outer axonemal microtubule doublets and by a sheath of mitochondria that encloses the ODFs and the axoneme. The midpiece terminates about one-fourth of the way down the sperm flagellum at the annulus, which marks the beginning of the principal piece. . Schematic representation of a mammalian sperm and the ultrastructure of the flagellum. (A) Mammalian sperm flagella are structurally divided into 4 areas: the connecting piece, midpiece, principal piece, and end piece. The end of the midpiece and start of the principal piece are demarcated by the annulus. (B) Schematic cross-section through a representative segment of the midpiece showing the plasma membrane (PM) and mitochondrial sheath (MS) surrounding the 9 outer dense fibers (ODFs). Within the ODFs are the components of the axoneme: the 9 outer microtubule doublets of the axoneme (OMDA) with associated dynein arms (DA) and radial spokes (RS) and the central pair of microtubule doublets (CP). In an actual sperm, several projections are present on the CP. These are not shown in this figure. (C) Schematic cross-section through a representative segment of the principal piece showing the PM surrounding 7 ODFs. ODFs 3 and 8 have been replaced by the two longitudinal columns of the fibrous sheath (LC). The two columns are connected by transverse ribs (TR). The axonemal components are unchanged. (D) Schematic cross-section through a representative segment of the end piece. The ODFs and FS tapered at the termination of the principal piece and are no longer present in the end piece, thus leaving only the PM to surround the axoneme. At this point, the mitochondrial sheath (MS) ends and the ODFs associated with outer axonemal doublets 3 and 8 are replaced by the 2 longitudinal columns of the fibrous sheath (FS). The columns of the FS run the length of the principal piece and are stabilized by circumferential ribs. The presence of the FS and of only 7 (rather than 9) ODFs surrounding the axoneme define the principal piece. The principal piece makes up approximately two-thirds of the length of the flagellum. Near the distal end of the principal piece, the FS and the ODFs taper and then terminate. The short remaining region of the flagellum, which contains only the axoneme surrounded by the plasma membrane, is the end piece. The presence and structure of the axoneme are highly conserved in all ciliated and flagellated eukaryotic cells. However, only mammalian sperm flagella contain all three additional accessory structures: the MS, ODFs, and FS. Eukaryotic axonemal assembly and function has been studied most extensively in the unicellular green algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. In this species, more than 200 axonemal and axoneme-associated proteins have been identified. Out of these 200 proteins, more than 25 loci have been identified by mutations that affect the assembly of the axoneme, and more than 52 loci have been identified by mutations that result in altered motility (Luck et al, 1977; Dutcher, 1995). These mutations involve structural, motor, targeting, and stabilizing proteins, to name a few (Luck et al, 1977; Dutcher, 1995; Yagi and Kamiya, 1995; Piperno et al, 1996; Smith and Lefebvre, 1996). In mammals, as in Chlamydomonas, the axoneme extends throughout the flagellum and generates the flagellar motive force. The axoneme is a complex structure that is composed of a highly stable, characteristic 9 + 2 array of microtubules and associated proteins (Fawcett, 1975; Clermont et al, 1990). Although the α and β tubulins are by far the most prominent proteins in the axoneme, it is likely that mammals possess at least as many axonemal and axoneme-associated proteins as does Chlamydomonas (Luck et al, 1977). In spite of their relevance to sperm motility, few of these mammalian proteins have been well characterized. Dyneins are the "motor" proteins located in the arms of the outer microtubular doublets and are members of a multigene family of proteins (Porter and Johnson, 1989; Holzbaur and Vallee, 1994; Milisav, 1998). Activation of the axonemal dynein ATPase causes the sliding of adjacent outer doublet microtubules, which results in flagellar bending (Gibbons and Rowe, 1965; Tash and Means, 1982). In Chlamydomonas, the central pair of microtubules, together with radial spokes emanating from the outer 9 microtubule doublets, transmit regulatory signals to the dynein arms (Porter and Sale, 2000). Additionally, the central pair and radial spokes regulate the size and shape of axonemal bending in a calcium-dependent fashion (Wargo and Smith, 2003). The high degree of structural conservation between Chlamydomonas and mammalian axonemes makes it likely that a very similar regulatory mechanism is also present in mammals. Axonemes are not unique to sperm cells; rather, they are found in all flagellated and ciliated cells, from Chlamydomonas flagella to the inner-ear hair cells of mammals. Thus, disorders of the axoneme in mammals can result in such varied phenotypes as infertility, deafness, blindness, chronic respiratory disease, or some combination of these problems. Sperm mitochondria are located only in the MS of the midpiece and produce adenosine triphosphate (ATP) for the cell through aerobic respiration. Although these functions are similar to those of somatic mitochondria, sperm mitochondria have been associated with several unique proteins or protein isoforms that are not found in the mitochondria of somatic cells. In mice, these include sperm-specific isoforms of lactate dehydrogenase and hexokinase (Burgos et al, 1995; Travis et al, 1998). The sperm axonemal dyneins have a high requirement for ATP as an energy source for flagellar motility. Because sperm mitochondria are restricted to the midpiece of the flagellum, the ATP generated by these mitochondria would need to travel some distance to supply the needs of the axonemal dyneins located in the more distal segments of the flagellum. It has long been suspected that this distance is too great and that ATP originating in the midpiece could not diffuse adequately to meet these needs in a timely fashion (Storey and Kayne, 1975). On the basis of these observations, it has been suggested that either other regions of the sperm flagellum must be able to produce ATP to supply the more distal parts of the tail or that there must be some mechanism by which ATP can be shuttled from the MS to the rest of the flagellum. Also of interest, it has been shown that species-specific differences in the metabolic capabilities of mitochondria exist. This results in variations in the ability of sperm from different species to metabolize different substrates (Storey and Kayne, 1980). It is possible that this variation has evolved as a result of species-specific differences in the substrate composition of oviductal fluids of the female. Historically, it has been suggested that the role of the ODFs is to provide passive elasticity to the motile flagellum (Fawcett, 1975). More recently, several ODF proteins have been isolated and characterized in a variety of species, including humans (Gastmann et al, 1993; Morales et al, 1994; Hoyer-Fender et al, 1995; Kim et al, 1995; Burmester and Hoyt-Fender, 1996, 1998; Kierszenbaum et al, 1996; Tres and Kierszenbaum, 1996; Brohmann et al, 1997; Shao et al, 1997; Schalles et al, 1998; Zarsky et al, 2003). Some of these have proved to be keratin-like intermediate filament proteins (eg, Sak57), which thus supports the idea that the ODFs provide structural support to the flagellum. Currently, there are no reports on targeted mutations in any of the ODF-specific genes. In part because of this, the functions of ODFs in sperm motility (other than the putative structural role) remain largely speculative. The FS is another sperm cytoskeletal structure that traditionally was thought to play a mechanical role in sperm motility by providing a rigid support for the flagellum and determining its planar beat (Fawcett, 1975; Lindemann et al, 1992). Outer microtubule doublets 3 and 8 are the only doublets in direct proximity to the FS (the other doublets are separated from the FS by the persistence of the ODFs in the principal piece). It has been suggested that, by supporting outer doublets 3 and 8 and the central pair of microtubules, the FS creates an "I-beam"-like structure along which the other microtubules can slide. In support of this hypothesis, and in support of the hypothesis that doublets 3 and 8 directly participate in FS sliding, it has been shown in mice that, in demembranated sperm in which axonemal sliding is activated with ATP, the FS slides proximally toward the connecting piece while doublets 1, 2, 4–7, and 9 (but not 3 and 8) are asynchronously extruded distally. Also of note, this FS sliding is cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP)-dependent, which suggests that cAMP-dependent kinase, protein kinase A (PK-A), is involved (Si and Okuno, 1993, 1995). The role of the FS as a supporting structure for the flagellum is likely to be real; however, more recent evidence demonstrates an additional, more active role for the FS in sperm motility. In a wide variety of mammalian species, including humans, a growing number of proteins involved in motility signaling pathways and metabolism have been localized to the FS (Carrera et al, 1994; Bradley et al, 1996; Westhoff and Kamp, 1997; Bunch et al, 1998; Miki and Eddy, 1998; Mori et al, 1998; Travis et al, 1998; Turner et al, 1998, 1999; Nakamura et al, 1999; Fujita et al, 2000; Carr et al, 2001). On the basis of increasing evidence that multiple members of both motility and metabolism-related pathways localize to the FS, it is likely that this accessory structure serves as a scaffold and organizing center for multiple signaling and metabolic cascades that are critical for normal flagellar function (Turner et al, 1999; Miki et al, 2002; Eddy et al, 2003). Other FS proteins, including, for example, a mu-class glutathione-s-transferase, have also been identified and raise the possibility that another function of the FS is to protect sperm from oxidative stress that could interfere with sperm motility or cause DNA damage (Fulcher et al, 1995). Early microscopic studies have provided extensive information on the morphological development of mammalian flagellar components. The flagellum can first be seen projecting from the surface of a round spermatid during early spermiogenesis. The axoneme is the first flagellar structure to appear; it originates from the distal centriole located at the caudal pole of the nucleus and elongates in a proximal to distal direction (Fawcett and Phillips, 1969). During midspermiogenesis, the ODFs develop in close association with the 9 outer doublets of the axoneme (Fawcett and Phillips, 1969). They originate as thin, electron-dense filaments in the most proximal portion of the future midpiece and then elongate in a distal to proximal direction and increase in thickness (Irons and Clermont, 1982; Oko and Clermont, 1989; Clermont et al, 1990). They persist throughout the midpiece and the principal piece, tapering gradually and eventually terminating distally at the end piece (Fawcett, 1965). The formation of the FS occurs throughout most of spermiogenesis, but, unlike the axoneme and the ODFs, the FS is assembled distally to proximally along the length of the flagellum (Irons and Clermont, 1982; Oko and Clermont, 1989; Clermont et al, 1990). Thin longitudinal columns, connected to outer doublets 3 and 8 of the axoneme, appear at the distal end of the flagellum. The columns increase in diameter, elongate proximally along the axoneme, and only later become connected by circumferential transverse ribs. This unusual distal to proximal assembly of the FS implies that there must be some mechanism by which FS proteins are shuttled down the length of the developing flagellum in an assembly-incompetent form before they are be pieced together distally to proximally into the FS (Johnson et al, 1997). The midpiece also develops during spermiogenesis, originating when the annulus, a ring-shaped structure that at the connecting piece, distally to meet the most proximal of the FS. The MS in the midpiece when mitochondria assemble in a helical the proximal flagellum, the annulus. The mitochondria and eventually to form two that the outside of the ODFs The flagellar waveform is by the of the axonemal dynein arms the microtubule of the axonemal dynein to be a critical regulatory point in the of flagellar motility the dynein ATPase is This results in the of the flagellar beat as the of ATP is into thus the microtubules to of dynein by the protein then this that the dynein arms are to each of the outer 9 microtubule doublet These arms project in the direction of the adjacent outer microtubule sliding occurs as the result of a of a dynein with its adjacent microtubular During this the dynein arms force between doublets, in the adjacent microtubules sliding another and 1989; et al, 1977). Because the axoneme is to the of the sperm this sliding force is into a in the flagellum (Figure Because dynein force in only a direction and the of a normal flagellar waveform that and the associated and of the dynein arms in an the and along the length of the axoneme. In Chlamydomonas, it has been shown that this occurs through the of the central pair microtubules and the radial spokes (Wargo and Smith, 2003). . representation of the mechanism by which axonemal dynein arms the flagellar The in the region of the flagellum adjacent outer microtubule doublets of the axoneme the only 2 outer microtubule doublets are (rather than the actual The central pair of microtubule doublets is not are the any of the accessory arms between the pair of are a pair of and outer dynein arms originating from the microtubule on the and toward the microtubule on the (A) of the dynein arms are as the adjacent microtubule doublets are straight and there is no flagellar (B) The first dynein has the adjacent microtubule (C) The first dynein has generated a in the adjacent microtubules sliding another Because both microtubule doublets are to the sperm this sliding force is into a in the start of a flagellar the dynein has the adjacent microtubule (D) The first dynein has the adjacent microtubule whereas the dynein has generated a This results in the of the flagellar down the length of the The dynein has the adjacent The flagellar beat is being by the of the dynein whereas the dynein has the adjacent The first dynein has to its in for another This will be by the dynein and on along the length of the One must a similar for all 9 dynein and their associated 9 outer microtubule Additionally, must this in an fashion the and along the length of the flagellum in 3 It is this of dynein arms and the associated bending of the outer microtubule doublets that result in a normal flagellar The ODFs and the FS structural In Chlamydomonas, it has been shown that the central pair of microtubules, together with the radial spokes emanating from the 9 outer microtubule doublets, and regulate the of the dynein arms and control the size and shape of the axonemal Sperm are highly cells in which functions are relevance to the present sperm motility is to the flagellum. many of the proteins directly involved in the regulation and of mammalian sperm motility must localize to the sperm tail. One of is in sperm is the of proteins to to the FS of the flagellum, thus the of of the kinase to close proximity of in the axoneme (Carrera et al, 1994; et al, 1997; Miki and Eddy, 1998; et al, 1999; et al, In to to the FS, proteins also may other signaling and metabolic proteins to the sperm tail. In this the major protein of the sperm FS is an (Carrera et al, It has been shown that sperm from mice the protein have reduced sperm motility and are In the of this protein results in a or of other proteins those proteins that normally are or targeted to the FS by from the FS, thus sperm function and evidence to the hypothesis that the FS functions as more than simply a structural support for the tail et al, 2002). has been shown to with a FS This suggests that proteins have both functional and structural in the FS et al, 2003). now have been shown to be major components of the FS in a variety of species, including rodents, and humans (Turner et al, 1998; et al, 1999; et al, 1999; and 2002). In all cases, they are to function in to the flagellum. signaling pathways have as central to normal mammalian motility: the and signaling (Suarez et al, Tash and Means, Lindemann and and 1989; 1991; Yanagimachi, 1994; Ho et al, 2002). Other signaling cascades also are likely to play example, both and pathways have been in sperm motility et al, 1993; Nakamura et al, 1999; Fujita et 2000; Carr et 2001). to there is evidence that some of these proteins are to the flagellum, and specifically to the FS, the of proteins et al, 2001). in also affect sperm motility (Yanagimachi, However, there have been relatively few studies on these signaling In mammals, activated sperm motility at least in part, and by the cAMP-dependent of flagellar proteins and Means, and A major of in sperm is the kinase thus it likely that this a central role in these et al, 1997). may through multiple pathways to control flagellar One likely mechanism of of is that the protein a as kinase or whose are located in the flagellum et al, 1996; and 2000). evidence supporting a role for the of and its associated in sperm motility has from studies in Although most mice with a targeted of the the of the of during the a few to These have and motile sperm et al, 2002). only a few of the protein for in sperm have been identified and 1998). One is axonemal and of this protein to be a critical regulatory point in the of flagellar motility, as was It is likely that to the fibrous sheath of the flagellum is important in the of the kinase to in the tail. of the of the regulatory of in sperm in an of sperm motility in study et al, 1997). However, targeted of the regulatory of and the associated of of the of no on sperm motility or fertility et al, It is likely that, in the of proper of the regulatory the I regulatory of is able to appear to provide a for and the of the relevant proteins is factor that the of sperm motility 1989; Tash and immotile sperm contain higher of the protein 2 than motile sperm, and motility can be in sperm by the of et al, 1996; et al, 1996). In this in somatic cells, members of the family scaffold both and to a the cell et al, 1995; et al, 1996). these proteins play similar in sperm, then they may as of the pathways that are critical for the regulation of motility.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1886267443
FWCI: 1.269
Cites: 161
Cited by: 202
Related to: 10