Level 5 leaders and the romance of leadership construct
Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This research study examines two recent conceptualisations of leadership that have evolved \nfrom previous leadership research. They are the Level 5 leadership theory and the romance of \nleadership theory. These concepts have been chosen as they represent conflicting \nperspectives of leadership. The aim of this research study is to investigate whether a recent \nhistorical profile of publicity given to a prominent Level 5 leader lends itself to a romance of \nleadership interpretation. \nThe present study addressed this aim by adopting a research methodology that is qualitative \nin nature and by utilising archival case history research and theory-based sampling. The two \nmeasuring instruments that were used are the items comprising the romance of leadership \nscale (RLS-C) and archival data. An exemplar of a Level 5 leader that has received ample \npress coverage, Bill Gates, was chosen. 201 articles from the following five sources and four \nyears were collected and their content analysed: the Wall Street Journal, the Economist, \nForbes, Fortune and Business Week in 1990, 1995, 1998 and 2006. The positive period \nincluded 1990 and 2006, and negative period 1995 and 1998. Once the 201 newspaper \narticles were randomly selected, the researcher analysed the content via 17 sub-categories. \nThe eight sub-categories from the principles of Level 5 leadership were used as a criterion to \nfind supportive evidence in the data for the Level 5 leadership theory. The researcher \nconcurrently used the nine items from the RLS-C, which comprised nine sub-categories as a \ncriterion to find supportive evidence in the data for romance of leadership theory. \nThis research study resulted in a follower-centric, non-traditional recognition of leadership as \nit provided clear support for the romance of leadership theory. In the positive period, subcategory \n1 and 5 dominated. Four trends were extracted: Ability, Image, Philanthropy and \nInnovation, constituting altogether 82 percent of the total propositions. Ability was the most \nsalient trend. In the negative period, sub-categories 1 and 5 dominated. Five trends were \nextracted: Power, Image, Ability, Innovation and Competition constituting altogether, 85 \npercent of the total propositions. Power and Image were the most salient trends. Conceptual \nand methodological reasons for the findings were offered, followed by a discussion of the \nlimitations and some theoretical and practical implications. Finally, future considerations for \nresearch were suggested.
Author: Sabrina Liccardo
Institution: University of the Witwatersrand
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W188862143
