Understanding Trusts: A Comparative View of Property Rights in Europe
Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: This paper explains the unique features and functions of the Trust in English law in the light of the structure and style of English Property law, in contrast with Continental European legal systems, where the absence of the Trust is linked with the special principles and dogmatic structures of Property rights, as developed by the Pandektenwissenschaft from original Roman law sources, and from the old droit coutumier of the French North.The division of the powers and benefits of ownership that lies at the foundation of the Trust is shown to be historically and dogmatically untenable in Civil law systems.Moreover, the different historical evolution of sources of liability in Civil law and Common law systems is shown to have prevented institutions functionally similar to that of the Trust from emerging on Continental European soil.Summary 1. Introduction 2. When is a trust a real trust?3. The dogmatic resistance of civil law to real trusts 3.1.The principle of Numerous Clausus 3.2.The principle of publicity of property rights 3.3.The principle of the unlimited powers of the legal owner 3.4.No room for Equity! 4. Conclusions InDret 1/2006 Stathis Banakas 1 Convention on the Law Applicable to Trusts and on their Recognition, 1 July 1985, 1-VII-1985, online: Hague Conference on Private International Law
Author: Stathis Banakas
Institution: University of East Anglia
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1891518346
