Sixth-grade students' mathematical problem-solving behavior. Motivational variables and gender differences
Year: 1997
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Introduction l 1.1 Gender differences in mathematics performance l 1.2 The role of problems within realistic mathematics education 4 1.3 Object of this study 6 1.4 Structure of this thesis 7 2 Mathematical problem solving: cognitive, metacognitive and affective variables 9 2.1 Conceptual framework 9 2.2 Factors contributing to mathematical problem solving 13 2.3 Individual differences in mathematical problem-solving behavior .... 21 2.4 Research perspective 27 3 Self-referenced cognitions in relation to mathematics 29 3.1 Conceptual framework 29 3.2 The model of adaptable learning 31 3.3 Motivational beliefs 32 3.4 Gender differences in motivational beliefs 36 3.5 Functional and dysfunctional motivational patterns 37 3.6 Task-specific appraisals 39 3.7 Variables and research questions 42 4 Method 45 4.1 Subjects 45 4.2 Measures 45 4.3 Procedures 55 5 Gender differences and intraindividual differences 61 5.1 Abstract reasoning ability 61 5.2 Motivational beliefs 62 5.3 Task-specific appraisals and attributions 65 5.4 Behavior-related variables 69 5.5 Conclusions . .78 Contents 6 Relations between cognitive and motivational variables 6.1 Relations among behavior-related variables 6.2 Variables contributing to task performance 6.3 Variables contributing to perceived confidence 6.4 Variables contributing to persistence 6.5 Conclusions 7 Discussion 7.1 General conclusions 7.2 General implications References Appendices Summary Samenvatting (summary in Dutch) Curriculum Vitae (in Dutch) ... Chapter 1Van der Schoot, & Eggen, 1996).Boys appear to have an advantage which is present from an early age, and this advantage seems to increase with age (Fennema & Carpenter, 1981;Hall & Hoff, 1988).There is no consensus, however, about the age at which these differences appear.Beller and Gafni (1996), for instance, did not find gender differences in the performances of 9-year old students.Van der Heijden (1993) reported that boys outperformed girls at the age of 8 years.In any case, in most studies there is agreement that gender differences are apparent by the time students reach secondary school age (about 12 years) (e.g., Beller & Gafni, 1996). Possible causesOver the years a wide range of explanations about the causes of gender differences in mathematics achievement have been offered.Biological, sociological, psychological, and educational factors have been considered as possible causes.Various models have been presented (Fennema, 1985;Ethington, 1992).A distinction can be made between research that examines the effect of environmental variablessuch as the influences of parents, teachers, peer group, and the wider society -and research which explores person-related variables, including cognitive and affective variables (Leder, 1992).There is evidence that some environmental variables exert a positive influence on the choices and behavior of males.For example, parental beliefs are a critical factor in determining students' attitudes toward mathematics, and it is believed that parents are often more encouraging of their sons' than their daughters' mathematical studies (Fennema & Sherman, 1977).Differences in patterns of teacher interactions with boys and girls also seem to affect mathematics learning.For example, males tend to receive more encouragement and are more frequently praised for correct answers than females (Hart, 1989;Koehler, 1990;Leder, 1987).It is difficult, however, to estimate the effects of environmental variables on the mathematics performance of boys and girls.Although we acknowledge the importance of this type of research, we restrict ourselves here to the effects of person-related variables on gender differences in mathematics, without making statements about the causes of these differences.Our starting point is that gender differences in mathematics performance are the outcome of complex interaction effects, in which both cognitive and motivational variables play a role. Content areasWhether or not gender differences are found may be influenced by the way a test is administered (e.g., open questions versus multiple choice items) and by the content
Author: Harriet J. Vermeer
Institution: Leiden University
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1903911944
