Twisting the truth: tinkering with patient decision aids to reduce health care expenditures.
Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: In some medical situations, there are clear right answers — the use of beta blockers after a myocardial infarction or glucose monitoring for diabetics, for example [1,2]. In these cases, there are unambiguous data supporting the efficacy of the intervention and virtual unanimity among providers and patients that the benefits outweigh any potential side effects. Other medical situations present significant uncertainty with regard to what physicians and their patients consider optimal therapy. Benign prostatic hyperplasia (BHP†) is the paradigmatic example, as there is generally no medical reason to prefer prostatectomy, medication, or watchful waiting, and patients will select different therapies depending on factors such as their aversion to surgery, tolerance for discomfort, and the importance of an active sex life [3]. The Stacey diagram (Figure 1) depicts the decisions faced by patients and providers by focusing on two dimensions — the provider’s beliefs about the level of certainty regarding the efficacy of therapy (x-axis) and the level of consistency of patient preferences (y-axis) [4]. When there is little agreement between patients about what they value (e.g., reducing pain vs. obtaining a conclusive diagnosis vs. increasing longevity at any cost) and low certainty in the mind of the treating physician about which treatment produces the best outcome, there is “chaos ” and little basis for care decisions. In areas of high agreement and high certainty, there is “order ” and a clear “right answer. ” In between these extremes lies the “zone of complexity.” When there is order on the Stacey diagram, the problem of inappropriate practice variation is easy to conceptualize. In these situations, there is a clear right answer that cannot be confounded by differences in patient attributes. The goal is, therefore, to bring non-complying physicians up to speed, such that they administer the prevailing standard of care. In all other areas of the Stacey diagram, and especially when there is “chaos, ” remedying undesirable practice variation is not so clear-cut. Con-To whom all correspondence should be addressed: Benjamin P. Falit, E-mail:
Source: PubMed Central
Author: Benjamin P Falit
Institution: Yale University
Language: English
Subfield: General Health Professions
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W190419021
