I Want to Speak Like a Native Speaker: The Case for Lowering the Plaintiff's Burden of Proof in Title VII Accent Discrimination Cases
Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: Discrimination on the basis of a person 's foreign accent has been found to be prohibited in certain instances under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.With the steady influx of non-native speakers of English into the United States, this area of the law is likely to see an increase in litigation in the coming years.However, more often than not, plaintiffs in accent discrimination cases are unsuccessful in winning their claim.Using linguistic, demographic, .andeconomic research, this Note argues that a plaintifs burden of proving accent discrimination should be lowered, in order to deter employers from discriminating against accented speakers.This in turn would better integrate immigrants into American society, allowing them to reach their full potential, at least in terms of employment.This Note further argues that one possible way of improving a plaintifs chances in accent discrimination cases is by statutorily excluding defendant's customer preference arguments and lay people's opinions about the plaintiffs verbal comprehensibility at trial.While most Title VII litigation excludes customer preference defenses, these statements continue to be relied on by courts in accent discrimination cases.An exclusion of customer preference arguments in these cases would likely mean a greater focus on the actual strength of a person 's English skills and potentially give plaintiffs a better chance to prevail at trial.
Author: Gerrit B. Smith
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Reduced inequalities
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1913415112
