Year: 2013
Type: other
Abstract: The crisis of the welfare state Since the 1990s, European welfare states have undergone major transformations that signal the surrender of public responsibility -transformations that may together signal the end to the welfare state as we know it.Previously significant variation between social-democratic, liberal and corporatist welfare state regimes (Esping-Andersen 1990) have narrowed due to reforms to contain costs (Pierson 1996).As the provision of services in a 'post-industrial society' replaces the postwar era's industrial production of goods, different welfare state regimes face similar social risks (Taylor-Gooby 2004) posed by flexible labour markets, lowskilled labour, and strained work-life balance due to increased female labour participation.Many countries also have ageing populations and growing dependency ratios (Cohen 2003), while the increasingly globalized economic order and financial crisis have fuelled the perceived necessity of reform (Clarke 2010).These socio-economic challenges in mature welfare states have led to political debate on the limits of public responsibility and the introduction of more selective welfare programs (Gilbert 2004).Paul Pierson (1996) a decade ago described these reforms as pathways to welfare state 'retrenchment'.In contrast to the post-war era of welfare state expansion through broad social programs and extensive social rights, retrenchment entails the off-loading of collective responsibilities (ibid.).The call for major reform has been touted as the end of the golden age of welfare, or even of the welfare state itself.If true, this would mean that the welfare state was a very brief stage in the history of some Western countries rather than a permanent feature of developed economies (Baldock 2007).Retrenchment parallels the turn towards 'active' welfare states.The European Union's Lisbon summit in 2000 introduced a strategy to reduce unemployment by 'activating' citizens, both men and women -policies that marked a turning point for many European countries.Social welfare was no longer to be unconditionally consumed (Trubek & Mosher 2001;Borghi & Van Berkel 2007); in return for social benefits, unemployed citizens were now expected to foster their employability through volunteer work or training programs (McQuaid & Lindsay 2005).Prompted by changes in social assistance, citizens in welfare states were discouraged to 'passively' consume Chapter 1 13 recommodification.'Recalibration' implies bringing welfare state programs in line with contemporary goals and demands for social provision.'Recommodification' reverses previous measures that distanced citizens from the labour market, while 'cost containment' prioritises cutbacks and control over public spending.Disaggregating these three dimensions, Pierson argues, enables us to better understand the political processes that make up welfare state reform.For example, in the field of care, 'cost containment is the issue in most countries, though flanked in some cases by efforts at modernization.Only rarely will recommodification provide the primary lens for analysing the character of reform in these core welfare state sectors' (Pierson 2001: 427).This is in contrast to labour market reform where recommodification and recalibration are primary strategies.Though retrenchment strategies vary across sectors, they centre on the contentious question 'who shall be eligible?' (Gilbert 2004).The adjudication of need is a political question; according to Fraser (1989), 'needs-talk' is an idiom through which 'political conflicts are played out and through which inequalities are symbolically elaborated and challenged' (Fraser 1989: 162).From this perspective, shifting private and public responsibility for certain 'needs' defines the boundaries between the political, economic, and domestic or personal spheres of life (Fraser 1989: 162).Given current economic and demographic trends, care needs are increasingly framed as a responsibility of the domestic and personal sphere.In terms of citizenship, it implies a shift from universal to selective social rights (Gilbert 2004) and an emphasis on individual responsibility (Dwyer 2006; Newman, Glendinning & Hughes 2008;Newman & Tonkens 2011).Many European countries -including states such as Sweden, Finland and the Netherlands which have maintained comprehensive public long-term care schemes -are increasingly reserving publically funded care for their 'neediest' citizens (Rostgaard et al. 2011).To achieve a 'just' redistribution of scarce resources, recent policies have aimed to distinguish between levels of need.First, monetary barriers provide financial disincentives for gatekeepers to distribute and for citizens to request public services.It builds on the premise that when people are made more responsible for (co-)financing public care, they will distinguish between urgent and less urgent needs.Examples of such measures include budget capping, positioning users as consumers in a care market, and demanding For money: the financial reform logicCost containment has always been a major thrust in the reform of Dutch longterm care.The debate on the AWBZ centres on the tension between guaranteeing access to quality care and the financial sustainability of public services.While cost containment strategies first sought to protect long-term care for all citizens, the more recent logic of financial reform is informed by new ideas about public-private responsibilities (Da Roit 2012).When cost containment first became a policy objective in the late 1970s and 80s, reforms centred on deinstitutionalization.The AWBZ was broadened to 'The care and support of and with that, daily life, is too often unnecessarily taken over -albeit with good intentions -by professionals (medicalization), causing people to be made too dependent on care.' (VWS 2013a: 2)The community spirit mantra dictates that fewer people should enter professional care trajectories and that professionals must learn how to disengage from clients' lives and instead focus on their self-sufficiency.A brochure on 'Welfare 2.0' instructs professionals on how to approach their clients: Complaining about decreased payments for care has become morally questionable.Informal care exchanged within private networks or performed by volunteers is considered altruistic, warm, loving and more durable than care that is contractual and/or motivated by payment.The key idea is that people in need of social care are better off relying on care that is altruistic and public-spirited rather than care that is directed by self-interested or 'knavish' motives (Le Grand 1997).This will eventually also lead to a better and more cohesive society. Eggink E, Pommer E and Woittiez I (2008) De ontwikkeling van AWBZ-uitgaven. Een analyse van awbz-uitgaven 1985-2005 en een raming van de uitgaven voor verpleging en verzorging 2005-2030.Den Haag: SCP.
Author: Ellen Grootegoed
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1925578872
