COMPASS| Advocating for Critical Frameworks and Research Methods in Issue-Based Policy Formation: A Case Study
Year: 2015
Type: article
Abstract: Whether validated by numbers or not, there seems to be a general sense that the humanities both inside and outside the academy are in a state of crisis.Economic worries, bleak predictions about the job market, and concerns about being mired in abstract theory at the expense of real-world impact have intensified in recent years.To this third point in particular, scholars who work within constructivist and participatory paradigms have argued that research performs a role greater than only seeking truth and knowledge; research should empower.Fine, Weis, Weseen, and Wong, frame this as "research for social justice" (2000, p. 108), Packer describes the research process as a "critical and emancipatory or enlightening practice" (2010, p. 7), and for Lincoln and Guba, through a sense of control and decision making in the research process participants themselves can experience "emancipation, democracy and community empowerment" (2000, p. 175).Even Habermas spoke of the need for a form of inquiry motivated by an emancipatory interest.Yet despite this desire, academics who subscribe to this outlook sometimes struggle to find the "real-world" impact of their work from within the institution of the university.There is, however, ample opportunity for the kinds of critical approaches, research methods, and frameworks that are often based in the humanistic tradition to play an important and transformative role in policy formation.Public and issue-based policy must be able to account for complexity and contradiction, and rarely function well in practice if these complications cannot be fully attended to.And yet approaches that often do just that are employed by policy and advocacy groups.Legal knowledge is frequently brought to bear on matters of policy, since whatever is being suggested must be in line with existing law (S.Tyson, personal communication, August 2014).Statistical analysis is often used in policy contexts since "hard" data in the form of numbers is often considered more credible than the vagaries of written interpretations (Packer, 2011).Other quantitative methods such as surveys, longitudinal studies, and content analysis are also used, but not all methods can answer all questions.Different methods must be applied depending on what one wants to know.For example, a content analysis is incredibly useful if we want to know how many instances of violence occur in a particular television show, but it will be unable to tell us about the nature of that violence, or to historicize violent imagery, or describe how shifts from broadcast to cable have affected media content.For those questions to be answered, researchers International Journal of Communication 9(2015)Advocating for Critical Frameworks 3415 would do well to draw on qualitative methods that get at questions of representation (discourse analysis, semiotic methods, narrative analysis), use historical analysis, or employ a media industries framework.Different methodological approaches have a place in the world of policy formation.Because of the political nature of policy development, however, qualitative approaches to research often have been marginalized in favor of quantitative ones that seek generalizable results (Lindolf & Taylor, 2011).Also, methods such as historical analysis are more likely to be time-consuming and as such are perhaps less suited to the fast-paced and time sensitive nature of policy and legal advocacy.With this mind, what, then, is the role and place of critical research methods within policy research and development, specifically issue-based legal advocacy organizations?Textual analysis, industry studies, and other analytic frameworks such as those of gender, race, and LGBT studies may not be the first approaches that come to mind in informing political strategy and action, yet they can be powerful tools for organizations to better
Author: Nicole Hentrich
Institution: University of Michigan
Language: English
Subfield: General Social Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W1952006327
