Nutritionists unimpressed by sugar lobby's outcry.
Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: Threats by US sugar industry to lobby Congress to cut off American contribution to WHO have failed to make organization withdraw a contentious expert report on nutrition and health. report, entitled Diet, nutrition and prevention of chronic disease, was formally launched in Rome on 23 April. It concluded that a diet low in saturated fat, sugar and salt and high in fruit and vegetables was required to tackle epidemic rise in chronic diseases worldwide. In a series of letters to WHO's Director-General Dr Gro Harlem Brundtland, sugar lobby attacked report's recommendation that sugar should represent at most 10% of daily energy intake. They claimed that report's conclusions were scientifically flawed and reflect the expert panel's complete disregard of preponderance of scientific evidence. At WHO, however, these reproaches made little impression. We took into account all comments we received from various stakeholders [upon publication of a draft version on Internet]. But we felt no need to reconsider recommendations, said Dr Pekka Puska, Director of Noncommunicable Diseases and Health Promotion at WHO. Denouncing a WHO report as unscientific, he adds, a standard procedure if big commercial interests are at stake. That's what tobacco people used to say. Though situation is reminiscent of WHO's fight with big tobacco companies, which has been going on for years, Puska is quick to point out that is not tobacco. Tobacco is an unnecessary product that kills its consumers, whereas food is necessary for life. So it's a question of changing dietary patterns from unhealthy to healthy. Besides, there is already a lot of collaboration going on between WHO and vast parts of food industry. nutrition and report, which had been commissioned jointly by WHO and UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), is result of a two-year expert consultation. Thirty independent experts from 20 countries analysed the best currently available scientific evidence on relationship of diet, nutrition and physical activity to chronic diseases, says Dr Ricardo Uauy from London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine who chaired expert group. The strength of report is that it is a real consensus document. At end, 30 scientists were happy with every single word in it. 100-page report provides scientific basis on which WHO can build its global strategy on diet, physical activity and health in accordance with a World Health Assembly resolution adopted in May 2002. strategy aims at reducing growing burden of chronic conditions such as cardiovascular disease, cancer, diabetes and obesity, which have reached epidemic proportions--not only in industrialized countries but in developing ones as well. Chronic diseases were cause of some 60% of 56 million deaths reported globally in 2001. We have known for a long time that foods high in saturated fats, sugars and salt are unhealthy; that we are, globally, increasing our intake of energy-dense nutritionally poor food as our lives become increasingly sedentary, said Dr Brundtland at launch of report. …
Source: Europe PMC (PubMed Central)
Author: Michael Hagmann
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1954569041
