Work

Collapsing dimensions, physical limitation, and other student metaphors for limit concepts : an instrumentalist investigation into calculus students' spontaneous reasoning

Year: 2002
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This research is an investigation of first-year calculus students’ \nspontaneous reasoning about limit concepts. The central theoretical perspective \nguiding the study design and the data analysis is based on an interaction theory of \nmetaphorical reasoning first proposed by Ivor Richards and later developed by \nMax Black. From this perspective, strong metaphors are characterized as those \nthat both support high degrees of elaborative implication and are ontologically \ncreative. This study investigates students’ spontaneous reasoning about limits \nthat may be described as metaphorical in this sense and are thus implicative for \nthe students’ emerging understandings. John Dewey’s instrumentalism, a theory \nof inquiry as the application of cognitive tools against problematic situations, \nprovides a focus on functional as well as structural aspects of students’ \nmetaphors. \nDescriptive answers to the following questions are sought: 1) What \nconceptual metaphors do students use to reason about limit concepts, and how are \nthey applied in specific problem contexts? 2) How do these metaphors affect \nstudents’ interpretations of content presented in class? 3) What are the \nimplications of trying to directly influence students’ metaphorical reasoning? The \nmethodology is a micro-ethnographic study of students’ problem solving through \nclinical interviews, writing assignments, and classroom observation. \nThe main result is the characterization of five metaphor clusters for limits \nthat were used in a variety of problem contexts by several students. These \nmetaphors involved reasoning about limits in terms of a collapse in dimension, \napproximation, closeness in a spatial domain, a physical limit for which nothing \nsmaller could exist, and the treatment of infinity as a number. Contrary to the \nimplications of much of the informal language associated with limits, students \nwere not observed to use motion imagery in significant ways to reason about limit \nconcepts. While many aspects of the students’ metaphors generated \nmathematically incorrect entailments for limits, most students were still able to \nuse them to great conceptual advantage. Two important factors were whether \nstudents critically reflected on their own reasoning to make refinements and \nwhether they attempted to make connections to relevant mathematical structures.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1954872257
Cites: 72
Cited by: 24
Related to: 9