Work

Editorial: Revisiting the concept of vulnerability: Recognising strength and resilience in the context of risk and susceptibility

Year: 2012
Type: editorial
Abstract: As a characteristic, vulnerability is considered undesirable, and is associated with susceptibility, debility, failure, flaw and weakness. In the context of population health, vulnerability is also viewed as detrimental, and has been defined as the degree of 'relative risk or susceptibility to adverse health outcomes' (Flaskerud & Winslow, 1998, p. 69). This disparity affects social groups who have limited environmental, social and economic resources, and is able to be measured in terms of factors such as early mortality, increased proportional morbidity, and reduced quality of life (Flaskerud & Winslow, 1998). Among the populations considered vulnerable in health terms are cultural minorities, such as Indigenous people, those who are homeless and destitute (Nyamathi et al., 2012), imprisoned people as well as their families (Nyamathi, Marlow, Branson, Marfisee, & Nandy, 2012), and economically disadvantaged people (Flouri, Mavroveli, & Tzavidis, 2010).The power of language is well recognised (Foucault, 1972), and literature highlights the ways that language creates reality, and positions people in particular ways (Bagshaw, 2006). Words can negatively label people, and using 'vulnerable' or 'vulnerability' as a descriptor can obscure the strengths people bring to challenging situations. Indeed, despite the many, seemingly overwhelming challenges people face on a daily basis, what is often revealed, and perhaps not adequately acknowledged or reported is the resilience and inventiveness individuals and communities draw on in the face of on-going adversity and continuing hardship.Adversity is associated with a range of factors including poverty, hardship, deprivation, misfortune, and traumatic or difficult life events - in other words, those factors that can also contribute to health vulnerability. In a discussion on children and child protection, Daniel (2010) suggests adversity exists in the presence of challenging circumstances, such as neglect and abuse, and that it could pose a threat to optimal health, growth and development (Daniel, 2010).Exposure to adversity does not necessarily result in poor outcomes. While some persons faced with adversity will experience suboptimal outcomes, others will adapt to adverse situations in ways that will act to cushion or buffer the effects of adversity. This is called resilience. The concept of resilience describes the ability of individuals and communities to maintain function and achieve positive adaptation in the face of adversity or trauma (Jackson, Firtko, & Edenborough, 2007; Daniel, 2010). As a concept, resilience has attracted considerable attention, and has been variously constructed as 'a trajectory, a continuum, a system, a trait, a process, a cycle, and a qualitative category' (Jackson et al., 2007, p. 2).Resilience can only be in evidence when an adverse situation is faced (Jackson et al., 2007), and until such a situation is confronted, it can be difficult to anticipate how one might react to a particular event or situation. However, the literature identifies various traits and qualities associated with resilience, and these include adaptability, intelligence, self- confidence, hardiness, curiosity, personal insight, self-discipline, reflexivity, and resourcefulness (Giordano, 1997; Jacelon, 1997; Jackson et al., 2007). Comparatively, adaptive capacity is also a necessary quality of resilience; in particular, embracing hardship as an opportunity for growth has been found to be beneficial (Longenecker, Zink, & Florence, 2012).There is some evidence in the literature that persons positioned as vulnerable and experiencing significant adversity also display considerable resilience in managing their situations. In arguing that individuals can develop enhanced resilience through story-telling, East, Jackson, O'Brien, and Peters (2010) has presented a range of findings that highlight how persons rendered vulnerable through a range of challenges such as living with HIV/AIDS and survival of civil war, were able to demonstrate some of the elements of resilience through their participation in research (East et al. …
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1970263485
Cites: 16
Cited by: 8
Related to: 9