Work

Considering ‘balance’ in information

Year: 2007
Type: editorial
Abstract: Few people would disagree that the information that health-care providers give to members of the public and patients about health conditions and health-care interventions should be balanced. However, the concept of balance has not received much critical attention in the context of health-related information. Answers to the questions of why, when and in what senses informational balance is a good thing, and whether and how it can be achieved and assessed, are somewhat underdeveloped. We can generate useful insights (and questions) about informational balance by examining concerns that are expressed about the lack of balance in different communication activities. In this issue, Shenaz Ahmed et al. discuss judgements of balance in the context of an evaluation of a website designed to support informed antenatal testing choices.1 The Antenatal Screening Web Resource (AnSWeR) was developed in response to a perceived imbalance in the information about antenatal testing that is usually given to expectant parents. It reflected concerns that (a) people who are offered antenatal screening are rarely exposed to information about what it is like to live with the conditions that are screened for, and (b) this omission could lead to personally suboptimal decisions about antenatal screening and subsequent options. Much of the interest in balance in health-related information has arisen in the context of efforts to help people make informed decisions about their health-care. There has been a strong reaction against situations in which people have been given particular health-care interventions in ignorance of their (significant) limitations or risks and in ignorance of alternatives that they might reasonably have preferred. This has led to the development of a broad consensus that people facing (at least certain kinds of) health-care decisions should be given information about the likely benefits and risks of each of the relevant options in a manner that promotes fair comparison between the options.2,3 This is one important contemporary understanding of what counts as balanced health-related information. But not all health-related information is intended primarily to help people make informed choices between several health-care options. The concept of balance might not be so important and an understanding of informational balance as depending on the presentation of comparable probabilistic facts about the outcomes associated with different health-care options might not be so applicable for different types of health-related information. Consider advertising, for example. Advertising aims to persuade people to buy or do particular things and we do not usually expect it to be balanced – at least we do not think that adverts should provide comparable information about all the alternatives to the products or services they promote: that would defeat their object. Potential concerns about informational imbalance within adverts are to a large extent mitigated by the recognition that most people understand the purpose of advertising and their understanding moderates its influence. The United States’ Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has attempted to promote some informational balance within direct-to-consumer advertisements for prescription medicines by requiring that they include statements about the possible side-effects as well as possible benefits, but this is highly unusual within the regulation of advertising and its effectiveness as a means of protecting consumers from inappropriate influence is unclear (the mandated inclusion of risk statements may incline consumers more strongly towards the advertised drugs if it renders the impressions of benefit conveyed by the positive imagery within adverts more believable).4 The AnSWeR website does aim to promote informed decision-making but an understanding of informational balance that focuses simply on the provision of comparable information about the probabilities of particular outcomes occurring with each of the possible options would have been inadequate to evaluate it, for several reasons. First, the website was apparently not designed to serve as a sufficient, stand-alone decision aid. It sought to promote informed decision-making by providing a counterbalance to the information that expectant parents are usually exposed to (which includes nothing or only ‘medical tragedy’ type presentations about conditions that are screened for). The fact that it focussed on experiences of living with the conditions that are screened for, led some of the people who reviewed it to judge it to lack balance. They were concerned that it did not, for example, provide information about experiences of terminating an affected foetus. This suggests that questions need to be asked about the portfolio of communication activities or information exposures that should be considered in assessments of balance, and the ways in which the objectives and scope (and descriptions of the objectives and scope) of particular information resources should feature in judgements of balance. Second, the AnSWeR website used case histories, testimonials and photographs to present experiential information about the lives of parents of children with Down’s syndrome, cystic fibrosis, spina bifida and other conditions. A number of issues other than those relating to the comparability of probabilistic outcomes information arise when we think about balance in the context of information resources that include significant amounts of visual imagery and accounts of subjective experiences. For example, developers who aspire to provide balanced collections of images and subjective experiences might seek to cover the range of experiences or to reflect the distribution of experiences in a population. The former might prompt concerns that the experiences of rare outliers are given too much attention, but the latter might prompt concerns that important but rare types of experience are obscured. These concerns might be alleviated to some extent if signposting within the collections gives people who look at particular examples a clear sense of how and where these fit in the range and distribution of experiences, but again it is not clear how this should be reflected in assessments of balance. (It is also important to remember that collections of subjective experiences are not always intended to be balanced in the sense of reflecting either the range or the distribution of experiences within a population. The developers of one educational resource that was intended to support positive self-management among people with arthritis deliberately presented a set of narrative accounts from individuals who were all in different ways ‘flourishing despite their condition’. They avoided negative accounts because they did not think these would help the resource to fulfil its purpose).5 Third, the AnSWeR website is, like all information resources, ‘inferentially fertile’.6 People may derive a wide range of understandings from it, depending on how they relate its content to their prior beliefs and attitudes, to information from other sources. This suggests that the balance of a particular information resource cannot be adequately assessed independently of its audiences and the contexts in which it is used. A basic recognition that different people will draw different meanings from the same information lies behind the widely used rule of thumb that if some people regard a particular information resource as biased in one direction and others regard it as biased in the opposite direction, then the balance is probably about right. But this approach perhaps needs further scrutiny. The beliefs and attitudes that influence individuals’ assessments of the balance of information are not necessarily correct and are probably unevenly and unpredictably distributed in populations. This raises questions about the appropriateness of assessing balance on the basis of an audience vote – even if a range of stakeholders are included. These are just some of a number of issues that need to be examined in relation to balance in communication that affects participation in health-care. We will be pleased to consider theoretical and empirical work that furthers understanding and debate about this topic for publication in Health Expectations.
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1973215933
Cites: 6
Cited by: 10
Related to: 10