Work

The underlying basis of the communication difficulties of high functioning pervasive developmental disorder

Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This study aimed to explore the underlying basis of the communication difficulties in children \n(between 5.0 and 7.11 years) with high functioning pervasive developmental disorder \n(HFPDD) (n=26), compared to children with specific language impairment (SLI) (n=26), and \nchildren with no history of developmental difficulty (NDD) (n=26). The study looked at: \nwhether different profiles could be obtained for the groups on comprehensive batteries of \ncommunication, cognitive processing and theory of mind; which areas measured were best \ncorrelated; and which measures best differentiated the groups. Comprehensive \ncommunication and theory of mind batteries were devised and conducted. Cognitive \nprocessing was measured using the Cognitive Assessment System (CAS) (Naglieri and Das, \n1997). Data was analysed using descriptive statistics, analysis of variance, the Kruskal-Wallis \ntest, Bonferroni t tests, frequency distributions, Pearson correlation coefficients and \ndiscriminant function analyses. Kappa coefficients and analysis of variance measures were \ncarried out on 23% of the rated data in order to establish inter-rater agreement and \nacceptable levels of agreement were reached. \nOn the communication assessment, the HFPDD group experienced the most difficulty on the \nmeasures of understanding abstract vocabulary, understanding conversation, pronoun \nalternation, higher level semantics, narrative ability and pragmatic ability. In contrast, the \nSLI group experienced the most difficulty on the measures of expressive grammar and \nnarrative clarity. On the cognitive processing assessment, the HFPDD group experienced \nmarked difficulty in the areas of planning and attention, while the SLI group experienced \nsignificant difficulty in the areas of successive processing and less marked but still significant \ndifficulty in the area of planning. Within the HFPDD group, a group with simultaneous \nprocessing markedly stronger than successive processing, a group with successive processing \nmarkedly stronger than simultaneous processing, and a group with simultaneous and \nsuccessive processing occurring at a similar level, were identified. The HFPDD group \nexperienced significant difficulty on all the measures of theory of mind, although a limited \nnumber of HFPDD subjects did not experience difficulty. The SLI group experienced \nsignificant difficulty on the two theory of mind measures that were more verbally loaded. \nStrong correlations were found between receptive language, expressive semantics, narrative \nability, pragmatic ability, planning, attention and theory of mind; and between expressive \ngrammar and successive processing. Pragmatic ability, narrative ability, planning, and \ncertain of the theory of mind measures best appeared to discriminate the groups. A combined \nmodel of language, cognitive and theory of mind processing is proposed to explain the \ndifferences between the HFPDD and SLI groups.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W197323493
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10