Work

A reply

Year: 2007
Type: article
Abstract: We thank Dr Stix and colleagues and Dr Cook for their interest and comment regarding our manuscript. At the time our study was performed, only two malpositions of the LMA ProSeal were described in the manual and in the literature [1]. The first is when the LMA ProSeal is placed too high in pharynx, leading to a poor seal and leakage through the drain tube, and the second is when the tip is in the laryngeal vestibule and ventilation is obstructed and deteriorates if the mask is pressed further distally. This, together with the descriptions concerning the LTS, led to our definition of a successful insertion attempt. At that time the study by Dr Brimacombe and colleagues [2] had not been published. We do agree, of course, with the importance of checking the correct position of the device, as otherwise the patient will be put at increased risk of aspiration or gastric insufflation. At present we confirm correct placement by passing a lubricated orogastric tube through the drain tube. It would be of value to perform a prospective study to confirm that such a simple and inexpensive test as the suprasternal notch test can assure us that the tip has not folded over. If reliable, this test will minimise the use of tube insertions for confirmation of the correct place. This will prevent complications of insertion of the gastric tube. Apart from these remarks, we think it is very important that manufacturers make every effort to be as accurate as possible in their information about devices. Meanwhile, the manual has been revised and extra tests to confirm the correct position of the device have been added [3]. In our study we used the LTS, which has been redesigned in the LTS-II, as Dr Cook describes. It might be true that this has led to improved insertion characteristics as well as ventilation characteristics, but this has not been shown so far. Only after it has been demonstrated that the insertion or ventilation characteristics are clinically different, and after correcting the results for the increased experience with this instrument, can one conclude that our study is dated and confusing.
Source: Anaesthesia
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1975584045
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10