Year: 2009
Type: editorial
Abstract: The Mediterranean-type diet (MeDi), a diet high in plant foods (such as fruits, nuts, legumes, and cereals) and fish, with olive oil as the primary source of mono-unsaturated fat and low-to-moderate intake of wine, as well as low intake of red meat and poultry, has been associated with a number of healthful outcomes including reduced risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, and mortality 5 .In 2006, Scarmeas et al 3 reported that adherence to the MeDi was associated with a reduction in incident dementia.This study was greeted with a feeding frenzy of media and public attention.15 However, a single study reporting an association must be replicated to assess its generalizability.In this issue of JAMA, 2 articles 1,2 report results of studies designed to replicate and expand that initial report.The first article, by Scarmeas and colleagues, 1 evaluated the association of MeDi adherence and physical activity with risk of incident Alzheimer disease (AD).MeDi adherence and physical activity were both independently associated with reduced risk for AD in the analytic models, and the authors concluded that the associations of AD with MeDi adherence and physical activity were distinct from a general tendency to adhere to a healthier lifestyle.This analysis was performed in the same cohort that Scarmeas et al originally reported 3 so could not address whether these results should be generalized beyond the study population.In the second article, Feart and colleagues 2 attempted to replicate the association of MeDi and cognitive decline previously described by Scarmeas et al 3 in a population-based cohort from Bordeaux, France.The authors used 4 neuropsychological tests to evaluate cognitive decline.Individuals who had high adherence to the MeDi in this study had higher Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) scores at the end of the 5-year follow-up period in some of the analytic models, but there were no associations with changes in other cognitive assessments with only one exception (the Free and Cued Selective Reminding) among the several models.Moreover, there was no reduction in incident dementia in those with high adherence to the MeDi, although the study was underpowered for this outcome.In addition, the neuropsychological tests used in the study may not have been ideal; while the Free and Cued Selective Reminding Task used by the authors was an excellent choice for detecting changes in short-term memory associated with pre-AD, other tests of executive function such as the Digit-Symbol Substitution test or the Trailmaking test might have been more sensitive to subtle cognitive differences associated with cerebrovascular disease.
Source: JAMA
Author: David S. Knopman
Institution: Mayo Clinic
Language: English
Topic: Nutritional Studies and Diet
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1546326989
