Work

Database of misidentified cell lines

Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: Much of current cancer and cell biology research depends on the use of cell lines cultured from normal and malignant tissue.However, ever since the time when continuous cell lines were first established, there has been a problem of the more vigorous lines contaminating and overgrowing more slowly growing cultures. This has been compounded by confusion of one cell line with another by mislabeling in routine culture or during and after cryopreservation. The result is that some 15–20% of cell lines in current use may not be what they are claimed to be. This has prompted a number of recent reports in the literature1-7 and discussions at scientific meetings. One of the main conclusions is that there needs to be a way to alert scientists using established and frequently propagated cell lines that there is a significant risk that they may be using cell lines which are not what they need them to be. This issue of International Journal of Cancer will address this problem and wants to increase the awareness of authors submitting their work for publication and of reviewers considering the merit of the work. Restrictions and conditions will be imposed regarding proof of authentication of cell lines used and advice given on how to authenticate cell lines (see editorial and letter by W. Dirks). My purpose in this letter is to notify the scientific community of the existence and free availability of a list of cell lines which are known or suspected to be falsely identified or cross contaminated. This will allow scientists embarking on a project or reviewers considering the work for publication, to have access to a data source which will advise them on the respective cell line's authenticity. This list is available for download from: http://www.hpacultures.org.uk/services/celllineidentityverification/misidentifiedcelllines.jsp by following the link after my and Amanda Capes-Davis's names. It has been compiled from quality assurance carried out by a number of cell banks (ATCC, CellBank Australia, sDSMZ, ECACC, JCRB, and RIKEN) and published on their websites, from an entry in Wikipedia, and from reports in the scientific literature. It must be emphasized that while many of the cell lines listed are clearly and incontrovertibly not what they are supposed to be, original and authentic stocks of other lines may yet exist. Where this is believed to be the case the line is included in the second table. This list will be published (Capes-Davis et al., ms in preparation). I would request that anyone who uses this list and finds that some misidentified cell lines have been omitted or that some cell lines reported as misidentified do have authentic stocks available should contact me ([email protected]), and I will arrange to have the database updated. Check that the cell line that you intend to use is not listed in the above database. Ensure that the cell line is obtained from a properly authenticated source (and that may not be the originator), preferably from one of the recognized cell banks. Authenticate cell lines received from a nonauthenticated source on receipt (see letter of W. Dirks, this issue, and instruction for authors of IJC). Repeat authentication at intervals of 3–6 months for cell lines used for an extended study, before cryopreservation, and after thawing for further use. It may not be possible to eliminate misidentification entirely, as new examples will continue to appear, but following these precautions should reduce the frequency and minimize the spread of the problem. Yours sincerely, R. Ian Freshney
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1986895526
FWCI: 0.858
Cites: 8
Cited by: 36
Related to: 10