Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: In order to make useful comparisons of different dark energy experiments, it is important to choose the appropriate figure of merit (FoM) for dark energy constraints. Here we show that for a set of dark energy parameters ${{f}_{i}}$, it is most intuitive to define $\mathrm{FoM}=1/\sqrt{\mathrm{det}\mathrm{Cov}({f}_{1},{f}_{2},{f}_{3},\dots{})}$, where $\mathrm{Cov}({f}_{1},{f}_{2},{f}_{3},\dots{})$ is the covariance matrix of ${{f}_{i}}$. In order for this FoM to represent the dark energy constraints in an optimal manner, the dark energy parameters ${{f}_{i}}$ should have clear physical meaning and be minimally correlated. We demonstrate two useful choices of ${{f}_{i}}$ using 182 SNe Ia (from the HST/GOODS program, the first year Supernova Legacy Survey, and nearby SN Ia surveys), $[R({z}_{*}),{l}_{a}({z}_{*}),{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{b}{h}^{2}]$ from the five year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe observations, and Sloan Digital Sky Survey measurement of the baryon acoustic oscillation scale, assuming the Hubble Space Telescope prior of ${H}_{0}=72\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}8\text{ }\text{ }(\mathrm{km}/\mathrm{s})\text{ }{\mathrm{Mpc}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, and without assuming spatial flatness. We find that for a dark energy equation of state linear in the cosmic scale factor $a$, the correlation of $({w}_{0},{w}_{0.5})$ [${w}_{0}={w}_{X}(z=0)$, ${w}_{0.5}={w}_{X}(z=0.5)$, with ${w}_{X}(a)=3{w}_{0.5}\ensuremath{-}2{w}_{0}+3({w}_{0}\ensuremath{-}{w}_{0.5})a$] is significantly smaller than that of $({w}_{0},{w}_{a})$ [with ${w}_{X}(a)={w}_{0}+(1\ensuremath{-}a){w}_{a}$]. In order to obtain model-independent constraints on dark energy, we parametrize the dark energy density function $X(z)={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{X}(z)/{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{X}(0)$ as a free function with ${X}_{0.5}$, ${X}_{1.0}$, and ${X}_{1.5}$ [values of $X(z)$ at $z=0.5$, 1.0, and 1.5] as free parameters estimated from data. If one assumes a linear dark energy equation of state, current observational data are consistent with a cosmological constant at 68% C.L. If one assumes $X(z)$ to be a free function parametrized by $({X}_{0.5},{X}_{1.0},{X}_{1.5})$, current data deviate from a cosmological constant at $z=1$ at 68% C.L., but are consistent with a cosmological constant at 95% C.L. Future dark energy experiments will allow us to dramatically increase the FoM of constraints on $({w}_{0},{w}_{0.5})$, and of $({X}_{0.5},{X}_{1.0},{X}_{1.5})$. This will significantly shrink the dark energy parameter space to either enable the discovery of dark energy evolution, or the conclusive evidence for a cosmological constant.
Author: Yun Wang
Institution: University of Oklahoma
Language: English
Subfield: Astronomy and Astrophysics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: dark energy, figure of merit, dark energy equation of state, covariance matrix, Type Ia supernovae, baryon acoustic oscillations, WMAP, Hubble Space Telescope, Hubble constant, model-independent constraints, linear equation of state, dark energy density parameter, cosmic curvature, model comparison, baryon density, dark matter density
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1999773690
