Work

An Ecologically Motivated Analysis of Plant-Herbivore Interactions in Native Tobacco

Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: You can't always get what you want, but if you try some time, you just might find, you get what you need… Mick Jagger Fitness optimization can arise from processes both internal (inside boxes) as well as external to a plant, and hence, tests of the cost-benefit paradigm require an understanding of biochemical and physiological function as well as the plant's evolutionary history and current selective pressures. The function of genes that contribute to whole-plant growth, storage, reproduction, and defense and for the transitions (circled numbers) between these functions are rapidly being elucidated. Ecological specialization in particular environments is frequently due to processes that regulate the allocation of resources to and from growth and defense (1); growth and storage (2); growth and reproduction (3); storage and reproduction; and the reinvestment of resources from vegetative (4a) and reproductive (4b) growth into the same functions. Because all allocations other than 4a and 4b incur opportunity costs by decreasing potential growth, they are of particular importance for understanding performance in particular habitats (Chapin et al., 1990). These within-plant optimizations are played out in an ecological arena which includes interactions with a plant's competitors (plant B), herbivores, pathogens, predators, mutualists (not depicted), and environmentally available resources, all of which can uncouple the relationships among gene expression, physiological performance and Darwinian fitness. In contrast, the cost-benefit paradigm has not found many advocates among plant molecular biologists. The problem lies first with the scale of biological organization at which it makes predictions. An understanding of how the expression of a gene product contributes to a plant's Darwinian fitness is required. All plants provide a quantifiable estimate of fitness, but the exact parameters to be measured (seeds, pollen, tuber, etc.) differ with each mating system. Fitness measures integrate whole-plant physiological performance that can be used to quantify the fitness consequences of variation in a particular trait, but these parameters are rarely measured in molecular studies. The translation of the functional parameters (growth, reproduction, storage, and defense; Fig. 1) into the language of specific gene products is an additional challenge. Ecological success stems not only from the elaboration of particular traits that confer higher fitness in particular habitats, but just as important, from the fine-tuning of allocation patterns (the transitions 1–4 in Fig. 1). For success in a particular habitat, timing can be everything. Unfortunately, a comprehensive understanding of internal processes is not sufficient to test the cost-benefit paradigm, because Darwinian fitness can also be influenced by processes external to the plant (Fig.1). Consider the example of induced resistance, in which inducible expression of resistance traits is thought to be a cost-savings measure, allowing plants to time the production of a defense with the need for the defense and forgo the payment of defense costs when they are not needed. These defense costs may arise from the internal processes of allocating fitness-limiting resources to defensive traits. However, an organism's ecological context frequently alters, or worse, uncouples the relationship between physiological performance (vegetative and reproductive growth) and Darwinian fitness. These external fitness costs can occur, for example, if a defense trait has negative effects on beneficial organisms (e.g. pollinators) or, if plant defense compounds are sequestered by herbivores and co-opted for defense against their enemies (Price et al., 1980), or from positive effects of defensive compounds toward other plants enemies (Fig. 1). These ecological interactions can select for genetic associations (pleiotrophy and linkage) that are not functionally comprehensible without an intimate understanding of the plant's current and past selection pressures. Tests of the cost-benefit paradigm require both a sophisticated reductionistic view of plant function and an equally sophisticated understanding of ecological function. None of the commonly used model plant systems meets both criteria. Many agricultural varieties have undergone intense selection for particular yield components, which must be considered with the selection regimes that prevailed during the plant's evolutionary history. Two solutions seem reasonable: develop molecular tools in a plant with a sophisticated and well-described ecology or exploit the ecological responses of near relatives to a plant with well-developed molecular tools. Both approaches are currently being explored at the Max Plank Institute for Chemical Ecology in Jena, Germany. An example of the latter strategy with Arabidopsis is described by Mitchell-Olds (2001). ThisUpdate will provide an example of the former approach with native Nicotiana spp. Nicotiana attenuata, a diploid, largely selfing, native tobacco of North America, was selected as a model system for two reasons: 1) it exhibits a large amount of morphological and chemical phenotypic plasticity that appears to be adaptive, and 2) it has evolved to grow in the primordial agricultural niche: the immediate post-fire environment. The habitat selection of N. attenuatais in large part determined by its particular germination behavior.N. attenuata “chases” fires in the Great Basin Desert by synchronizing its germination from long-lived seed banks with the immediate post-fire environment. The dormant seeds respond to a combination of germination stimulants found in wood smoke (Baldwin et al., 1994b) and inhibitors from the unburned litter of the dominant vegetation (Preston and Baldwin, 1999). As a consequence of this germination behavior, seeds germinate synchronously into nitrogen (N)-rich soils (Lynds and Baldwin, 1998) and hence have selected for rapid growth when water availability is high. Herbivores from more than 20 different taxa attack the plants on a variety of spatial scales, from mammalian browsers that consume entire plants to intracellular-feeding insects. The most damaging herbivores for a given population differ from year to year, as they too must recolonize these habitats after fires. How successfully a given genotype of N. attenuata alters its phenotype in response to these highly variable biotic selection regimes and translates vegetative growth into seed production will determine its representation in the seed bank, and, hence, its Darwinian fitness. In short, because the habitat ofN. attenuata is characterized by synchronized germination into N-rich soils, intense intraspecific competition, and highly variable herbivore and pathogen challenges, understanding the genetic basis of the phenotypic plasticity of N. attenuata might provide genetic tools to engineer greater ecological sophistication into our crop plants. To illustrate the specificity with which N. attenuatatailors its defense responses to different herbivores, I contrast the response to mechanical damage (which simulates the response to some mammalian browsers) and JA elicitation with that to attack from a specialized lepidoptern herbivore, the tobacco hornworm (Manduca sexta). Wounding elicits a massive metabolic commitment to nicotine production, a potent direct defense, that is produced and distributed throughout the plant in a manner that optimizes plant fitness. Wounding elicits the JA-cascade, and JA-elicitation produces a) durable resistance against a suite of herbivores; b) increases in secondary metabolites that function as direct and indirect defenses; and c) substantial fitness costs when plants grow with competitors in herbivore-free environments. Plants profoundly alter their wound responses when tobacco hornworm larvae attack, and the details of this alteration illustrate the overarching theme of this Update: the value of the fitness-based cost-benefit paradigm and an intimate understanding of a plant's natural history in understanding metabolism. Nicotine is arguably one of the most broadly effective plant defense metabolites in that it poisons acetocholine receptors and is thereby toxic to all heterotrophs with neuromuscular junctions. Given this defensive potential, one might expect that nicotine would be expressed constitutively in all cell types so as to provide maximum protection, just as many crop plants have been engineered to express the Bacillus thuringiensis toxin. However production and accumulation of nicotine does not meet this expectation, and the spatial and temporal details of its production are consistent with an optimization of defense allocation. Nicotine concentrations vary 10-fold among plant parts, but are remarkably homeostatic when viewed from a whole-plant perspective. The within-plant heterogeneity results from heterogeneity in synthesis and transport. Transcripts of the rate-limiting enzyme in its synthesis, putrescine N-methyltranferase (pmt), are found only in the roots, as are protein and activity measures. N. attenuata has two pmt genes, which are tightly coregulated (Winz and Baldwin, 2001) and correlate with rates of de novo biosynthesis, which, in turn, is readily measured by mass-spectrometry with 15N-pulse-chase techniques (Baldwin et al., 1994a). After its synthesis in the roots, nicotine is transported to the shoots in the xylem stream (Baldwin, 1989) and accumulated in tissues with a pattern that is consistent with predictions of optimal defense theory (McKey, 1974), which argues that defense metabolites are allocated preferentially to tissues with high fitness value and a high probability of attack. Young leaves, stems, and reproductive parts tend to have the highest concentrations; roots and old leaves, the lowest (Baldwin, 1999, and references therein;Ohnmeiss and Baldwin, 2000). Although xylem transport accounts for the initial distribution in the shoot after synthesis in the roots, it is likely redistributed from its location in the central vacuole by symplastic transport routes, particularly during elongation and flowering, when root de novo biosynthesis tends to decline (Ohnmeiss and Baldwin, 2000). Unfortunately, little is known of these symplastic transport mechanisms. Despite the high intraplant heterogeneity, whole-plant nicotine production is remarkably homeostatic. Plants produce allometrically corrected constant pools that appear to be maintained via adjustments in synthesis and biomass accumulation rather than nicotine turnover, regardless of variation in nitrogen supply rates, and even externally supplied nicotine (Baldwin, 1999, and references therein). Damage to leaves, such as browsing herbivores cause, dramatically increases de novo nicotine biosynthesis, the allometrically determined set points, and whole-plant nicotine accumulation 2- to 10-fold (Baldwin, 1999, and references therein). During vegetative growth, wound-induced nicotine production simply amplifies the within-shoot distribution observed in undamaged plants. However, during reproductive growth, when nicotine biosynthesis wanes, nicotine is transported preferentially to attacked tissues. In both rosette- and flowering-stage plants, the allocation of nicotine synthesized after wounding to above-ground parts is proportional to the experimentally-determined fitness value of those tissues (Ohnmeiss and Baldwin, 2000). The sequestration of nicotine biosynthesis in the roots results in a large spatial separation between the site of synthesis and accumulation. Although little is known about the communication between roots and shoots that maintains the allometric set points, the results of many experiments demonstrate that JA is an essential component of the signaling responsible for the dramatic wound-induced increases (Baldwin, 1999, and references therein; Ziegler et al., 2001). Our current working model for the long-distance signal transduction cascade is that wounding increases JA pools in which transport or a secondary signal such as et al., 2001) increases JA pools in in turn, nicotine synthesis in the roots and nicotine pools throughout the Given the defensive of plants for herbivore attack to their The may well in the metabolic of The in nicotine can be After of whole-plant is in this and this does not the used in biosynthesis, and storage (Baldwin et al., large of the in nicotine production is from after attack, but plants are of pools when plants are in synthesized nicotine is not to and to (Baldwin and the plant is not the substantial it makes in this defense and this fitness-limiting for growth and reproduction (Fig. 1). In to the large nicotine biosynthesis costs the of which on the of used for its nicotine synthesized from the costs of of synthesis from costs more plants preferentially for nicotine biosynthesis when given a (Lynds and Baldwin, may an of the germination of N. attenuata, which germination and growth in soils for the first after a (Lynds and Baldwin, Although the costs of nicotine production may for its inducible expression, the sequestration of nicotine biosynthesis in roots a to the of this induced defense (Winz and Baldwin, 2001). Plants a in so as they their of nicotine biosynthesis and accumulation more rapidly in response to (Baldwin and However, a in defense and that nicotine production may have that this sequestration may the induced a may but not the to produce the of the to a defense response is likely during after browsing when a plant's is Plants can a allometrically corrected nicotine response even after a of the shoot (Baldwin and In the intraplant details of nicotine biosynthesis and accumulation are consistent with an optimization of the costs and of a and the need to secondary metabolites in a whole-plant The fitness consequences of elicitation in N. attenuata on selective from herbivores and plants with of JA a of and in JA pools and secondary In natural that germinate from long-lived seed banks after fires in the habitats of the Great Basin an root increases nicotine concentrations and from mammalian browsers plant, and increases seed of and plants plants produced an of seeds and more than produced by the of the However, when plant not attacked seed production by an of seeds and with distribution of in produced plant between and plants in each a of more than its and positive a seed production and from from Baldwin, In experiments elicitation of plants in with in the same seed production at and the to for and the to seed production thereby a large fitness for However, these fitness costs not found when plants are without competitors (Baldwin et al., 1998) or when plants with plants from and Baldwin, 2001). nicotine production is likely to for some of the observed hornworm their nicotine grow on nicotine with in xylem solutions with induced nicotine concentrations (Baldwin, and on plants with and induced nicotine production by the expression of a pmt et al., However, many other secondary metabolites are induced by JA elicitation of N. attenuata putrescine and et al., and some of these are known to herbivore inhibitors for example, are by herbivore attack and JA et al., and are a that from plants at different after JA elicitation into to the chemical and their effects on tobacco hornworm larvae performance found that rapidly induced but in direct as as the induced in and nicotine and Baldwin, 2001). a of the chemical responsible for induced resistance have been many additional to be will be to how induced resistance from all of the chemical about by In contrast to the with direct the chemical basis of indirect defense function is JA elicitation and herbivore attack from different of not mechanical plants to a of and in to the that are from the et al., and Baldwin, 2001). during the and be by attacked tissues with inhibitors et al., 2000). The has been in plants in native it functions as an indirect defense in two the to tobacco hornworm and larvae and dramatically increases the rates from and Baldwin, 2001). These are likely the to plants competitors a tobacco hornworm larvae many plants to and to plants on which are likely indirect defense can be profoundly and in a the was to herbivore by and Baldwin, 2001). and of the to plants in by the plant, it was that from all to the a a and a each in The that the of of the was sufficient to in makes the of this of indirect defense in crop plants, in with direct a Although plants a higher fitness when they are attack, this resistance at a substantial fitness if plants are not In the same in which plants a fitness (Fig. JA elicitation seed production by in plants from herbivores by and (Baldwin et al., 1998) or by if plants simply not attacked (Fig. These fitness costs the costs of wound observed in a with the Nicotiana et al., 1990). In this plants a mechanical damage and their wound-induced nicotine response with to the wound a that wound-induced JA production (Baldwin et al., The seed production of plants that the wound-induced nicotine response was than that of plants that their wound-induced nicotine with The between the two of fitness costs the that JA-elicitation the responses to wounding and that wound-induced responses that nicotine exact a large from seed The responsible for these large fitness costs explored in experiments to determine the fitness be to the large of into nicotine production that not be used for growth and reproduction (Fig. 1). is that when plants in in which the and of be in seed production even when plants so that of their whole-plant was in nicotine (Baldwin et al., Because both of the experiments that found fitness costs of JA elicitation with intraspecific the fitness consequences of elicitation in the in and in which plants in in of and plants with supply rates and Baldwin, and 2000). In these the seed production of plants with other plants not differ from that of plants with plants, the time for reproductive was The was dramatically different when with plants. In these (Fig. an opportunity with a large in seed production at the of the seed production of the plants. The fitness of JA elicitation with supply and was with both a greater to for resources, measured with as well as an in allocation of to seed production (Fig. the in seed production with responses not be to allocations with the production of resistance traits. the component of JA elicitation appears to be from a of as to the of growth, with its of is for induced JA elicitation of a of genes et al., 2001) and this may be to resources for However, these effects of JA elicitation may not be a of Many other metabolic processes may be responsible for these in such as the of production (Baldwin and or the history of in the genetic of particular resistance traits etc.) will to determine defense traits are Two of the of a direct defense with the of that function to beneficial in N. by tobacco hornworm larvae is from wounding by the of at the wound site (the most is and results in JA and and a of which functions as an indirect defense by and decreasing the of The wound-induced nicotine production by decreasing the accumulation of putrescine the in nicotine biosynthesis and the in that results from found only in the of the in with the is from the in the in the of the the amount by Nicotine can be in the of and is in the parts of the the of the and the The pools of nicotine are throughout the during the of production and when nicotine pools and Baldwin, All of the tobacco in the wound responses ofN. attenuata can be by and to mechanical et al., 2001). suite of Fig. in the are and sufficient for not only the but also the JA and the these are from the by activity is and when are to the et al., 2001). In to the in defense phenotype after tobacco hornworm attack, N. attenuata also a was used to an view of the and from this it was that more than genes respond to herbivore attack et al., 2001). The genes be as being to and nitrogen and a to or of in those to and and in and nitrogen to defense These to the of central of which in are by of in tobacco et al., 2001). Although the patterns of with the observed phenotypic the basis for the known phenotypic a functional understanding of the would predictions about the of the In other if the secondary phenotype and of N. attenuata was so after tobacco hornworm attack, would be in a to how the are currently these larvae appear to be in a their of nicotine by the nicotine responses that of plants (Baldwin, and Baldwin, hornworm larvae a growth to as is by their higher growth rates on plants with nicotine by the expression of pmt et al., N. attenuata may be the defensive function of its by nicotine production, which be sequestered by the herbivore and used against by the defense compounds are commonly sequestered by herbivores for their defense and tobacco larvae are thought to nicotine against the et al., induced nicotine production may with the plant's to processes as a when N. attenuata plants by (Fig. with the defense optimization is the that tobacco hornworm attack does not the elicitation et al., are not known to be sequestered by larvae for defense and tend to herbivore growth, thereby the time that be to plants by the and attack The by the in of N. attenuata, is and only and first and larvae and Baldwin, 2001). that the time during which larvae in these would likely the of the indirect the in the wound response may an optimization of defense, in which the plant a suite of direct and indirect particularly effective against a particular herbivore the plant's wound response may also the fitness consequences of intraspecific and function to herbivore to fitness in response to selection from both and N. attenuata plants germinate from long-lived seed banks after fires and hence are commonly with Because these interactions may profoundly determine an plant's fitness (Fig. they may the fitness consequences of JA-elicitation and the of the resistance traits growth and makes and plants to (Fig. hornworm attack results in a dramatic that nicotine production, and this also the in with JA elicitation et al., the both nicotine production and the in is consistent with the that the large of nicotine biosynthesis contribute to the of growth during JA The was not found to the accumulation of from other tobacco genes et al., but it to be determined the of the on growth is by responses other than the of pmt accumulation and nicotine Although the to be the that N. attenuata a potent defense and does not its growth as part of its herbivore that interactions may have influenced interactions and to on induced and plants. tobacco hornworm larvae are and the costs of between plants are than the costs of on plants et al., However, when they the they readily plants to on plants. than of the N. attenuata by a tobacco hornworm is during the and if herbivores are by a plant's induced responses to to plants when they are most a or of defense might provide plants with an effective response to the selective of herbivore attack and intraspecific plants may herbivore attack when larvae are and to and when they are most et al., Plants attack from first larvae and have the of a defense response against first as is from performance on plants et al., 1999). However, plants appear not to of this As the of defense responses during herbivore may a optimization of a plant's defense plants have evolved sophisticated of with the of selection with which they are by plant fitness can one the plant's solutions to these selective pressures. The responsible for this ecological sophistication are likely in the details of the of the but without an intimate understanding of a plant's natural the responses will functionally The cost-benefit paradigm is a to about the function of a trait, but tools are to the traits and test the fitness consequences of the in environments. As the of gene and techniques that can be used with plants in natural habitats may provide the toward a functional understanding of metabolism. I and for with the and and for of on Nicotiana spp. the amount of from Nicotiana which of this
Language: English
Subfield: Insect Science
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2019797603
FWCI: 15.79
Cites: 44
Cited by: 284
Related to: 10