A petrogenetic model for the comagmatic origin of chassignites and nakhlites: Inferences from chlorine‐rich minerals, petrology, and geochemistry
Year: 2013
Type: article
Abstract: Twelve samples belonging to the chassignite and nakhlite subgroups of Martian meteorites were investigated using a variety of micro‐beam analytical techniques to gain insight into the petrogenesis of these two meteorite classes. There are a striking number of geochemical similarities between the chassignites and nakhlites, including mineralogy and petrology, crystallization age, cosmic‐ray exposure age, and radiogenic isotopic compositions. However, there are also geochemical differences, namely in trace element systematics of pyroxenes, that have led some authors to conclude that the nakhlites are comagmatic with each other, but not comagmatic with the chassignites. On the basis of data presented here, we propose a model in which these differences can be reconciled by the addition of an exogenous Cl‐rich fluid to the chassignite‐nakhlite magma body shortly after the formation of the cumulate horizon that was sampled by the Chassigny meteorite. This model is supported by the textural and chemical associations of the volatile‐bearing minerals apatite, amphibole, and biotite, which record a history starting with the addition of a Cl‐ andLREE‐enriched fluid to the magma body. As the magma continued to crystallize, it eventually reached chloride saturation and degassed a Cl‐rich fluid phase. Depending on the provenance of the Cl‐rich fluid, this model could explain how the chassignites and nakhlites originated from anLREE‐depleted source, yet all exhibitLREE‐enriched bulk‐rock patterns. Additionally, the model explains the range in oxygen fugacity that is recorded by the chassignites and nakhlites because eventual exsolution and loss of Cl‐rich fluid phases near the end of crystallization of the nakhlite sequence leads to auto‐oxidation of the magma body due to the preferential partitioning of Fe2+into the fluid phase.
DOI: 10.1111/maps.12095
Language: English
Topic: Astro and Planetary Science
Subfield: Space and Planetary Science
Field: Earth and Planetary Sciences
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
Awards: THIS PROPOSAL PRESENTS FOUR NEW SCIENCE TASKS FOR OUR RESEARCH TEAM: 1) A STUDY OF VALENCE STATE PARTITIONING OF EU CR AND V BETWEEN PYROXENE AND A MARTIAN BASALT AS AFUNCTION OF OXYGEN FUGACITY (IW-1 TO FMQ) AND CRYSTALLIZATION HISTORY 2) A COMPARATIVE PLANETARY MINERALOGY STUDY OF SULFIDES IN BASALTS TO GAIN A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF CHALCOPHILE ELEMENT BEHAVIOR IN DIFFERENT PLANETARY ENVIRONMENTS 3) A RECONSTRUCTION OF THE PETROGENETIC HISTORY OF OLIVINE MEGACRYSTS IN MARTIAN BASALTS TO GAIN INSIGHTS INTO THE PETROGENESIS OF "DEPLETED" AND "ENRICHED" SHERGOTTITES AND 4) COMBINED SIMS-TIMS STUDIES OF MARTIAN AND LUNAR METEORITES TO GAIN ADDITIONAL INSIGHTS INTO THE ORIGIN AND EVOLUTION OF PLANETARY MANTLES AND THE GENERATION AND HISTORY OF BASALTS FROM THESE TWO PLANETS. OUR DIVERSE RESEARCH BACKGROUNDS IN CRYSTAL CHEMISTRY MINERALOGY PETROLOGY AND GEOCHEMISTRY PROVIDE A STRONG FOUNDATION TO USE AN INTEGRATED APPROACH TO SOLAR SYSTEM PROBLEMS. THIS BACKGROUND COMBINED WITH EXPERIMENTAL PETROLOGY LABORATORIES (UNM AND JSC WITH INDIVIDUAL AND INDIVIDUAL) ELECTRON MICROPROBE (EMP UNM) SECONDARY ION MASS SPECTROMETRY (SIMS UNM) NANO-SIMS (CALTECH WITH INDIVIDUAL) TRANSMISSION ELECTRON MICROSCOPY (TEM UNM) THERMAL IONIZATION MASS SPECTROMETRY (TIMS LLNL WITH INDIVIDUAL) FOCUSED ION BEAM MICROSCOPY (FIB UNM) SYNCHROTRON MICROXANES AND SYNCHROTRON X-RAY FLUORESCENCE (XANES AND SXRF RESPEVTIVELY NATIONAL SYNCHROTRON LIGHT SOURCE AT ARGONNE NATIONAL LABORATORY WITHINDIVIDUAL) ENABLES US TO USE INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO THE STUDY OF SOLAR SYSTEM MATERIALS. THE TASKS OUTLINED IN THIS PROPOSAL HAVE HIGH RELEVANCE TO THE COSMOCHEMISTRY PROGRAM AND NASA'S GOALS FOR THE EXPLORATION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM. FULFILLING THESE TASKS WILL PROVIDE INSIGHTS INTO THE ORIGIN OF TERRESTRIAL PLANETS AND PROCESSES INFLUENTIAL IN THEIR EVOLUTION. FURTHER THESE PROPOSED STUDIES ARE RELEVANT TO THE GOALS IDENTIFIED BY THE NRC NAC LEAG AND MEPAG FOR THE EXPLORATION OF THE MOON AND MARS., THIS IS A PROPOSAL REQUESTING THREE YEARS OF FUNDING TO BEGIN A COMBINED EXPERIMENTAL AND MICRO-BEAM ANALYTICAL STUDY INTO UNDERSTANDING THE ROLE AND RELATIVE ABUNDANCES OF THE MAGMATIC VOLATILES WATER CHLORINE AND FLUORINE IN PLANETARY MATERIALS. THESE VOLATILES ARE SIGNIFICANT CONSTITUENTS IN A VAST NUMBER OF TERRESTRIAL GEOLOGIC SYSTEMS. HOWEVER WITH THE EXCEPTION OF MARS AND THE MOON RELATIVELY LITTLE IS KNOWN ABOUT THESE VOLATILES IN EXTRATERRESTRIAL SYSTEMS. TO HELP RESOLVE THIS GAP IN OUR UNDERSTANDING OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM WE WILL SEARCH FOR EVIDENCE OF VOLATILE-BEARING GEOCHEMICAL PROCESSES FROM A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT PLANETARY MATERIALS INCLUDING CHONDRITIES AND ACHONDRITES. THE PRIMARY TOOL THAT WE WILL USE TO DETECT VOLATILE-BEARING GEOCHEMICAL PROCESSES IN THESE MATERIALS IS THE MINERAL APATITE [CA5(PO4)3(F CL OH)] WHICH CONTAINS FLUORINE CHLORINE AND HYDROXYL AS ESSENTIAL STRUCTURAL CONSTITUENTS.THE PROPOSED INVESTIGATION WILL BE CONDUCTED THROUGH 3 MAJOR SCIENCE TASKS:1) A COMBINED TEXTURAL AND MICRO-BEAM ANALYTICAL SURVEY (EPMA AND SIMS) OF APATITE COMPOSITIONS FROM ACHONDRITE METEORITES TO INCLUDE BRACHINITES UREILITES HED S ANGRITES AND MARTIAN METEORITES.2) A COMBINED TEXTURAL AND MICRO-BEAM ANALYTICAL SURVEY (EPMA AND SIMS) OF APATITE COMPOSITIONS FROM CHONDRITE METEORITES THAT INCLUDE THE ORDINARY AND CARBONACEOUS CHONDRITE CLASSES.3) AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY INTO THE PARTITIONING BEHAVIOR OF FLUORINE CHLORINE AND WATER BETWEEN APATITE AND A MARTIAN BASALT (QUE 94201) OVER A RANGE OF RELEVANT PRESSURE AND TEMPERATURE CONDITIONS (RUN PRODUCTS WILL BE ANALYZED BY EPMA AND SIMS).THE THREE PROPOSED TASKS OUTLINED ABOVE ARE HIGHLY RELEVANT TO BOTH NASA'S OBJECTIVES FOR EXPLORING THE SOLAR SYSTEM AND THE GOALS FOR THE COSMOCHEMISTRY PROGRAM. THE PROPOSED TASKS WILL ADVANCE OUR UNDERSTANDING OF VOLATILES IN THE SOLAR SYSTEM FROM THEIR ROLE IN NON-TERRESTRIAL AQUEOUS ALTERATION OF CHONDRITES AND ACHINDRITES TO PROCESSING AND STORAGE OF VOLATILES DURING PLANETARY DIFFERENTIATION.THEREFORE ALL TASKS PROPOSED ARE HIGHLY RELEVANT TO THE OVERARCHING GOAL OF THE COSMOCHEMISTRY PROGRAM WHICH IS "TO SUPPORT RESEARCH THAT INCREASE THE UNDERSTANDING OF THE CHEMICAL ORIGIN OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM AND THE PROCESSES BY WHICH ITS PLANETS AND SMALL BODIES HAVE EVOLVED TO THEIR PRESENT STATE"., EXPERIMENTAL SIMULATION OF LUNAR MAGMA OCEAN CRYSTALLIZATIONTHIS PROPOSAL REQUESTS SUPPORT FOR A PROGRAM OF HIGH-PRESSURE EXPERIMENTATION TO SIMULATE THE CRYSTALLIZATION OF AN EARLY LUNAR MAGMA OCEAN. DESPITE THE WIDESPREAD ACCEPTANCE OF THE GIANT IMPACT LUNAR MAGMA OCEAN CONCEPT TO UNDERSTAND THE GEOLOGIC HISTORY OF THE MOON CRYSTALLIZATION OF THE MAGMA OCEAN HAS NEVER BEEN TESTED EXPERIMENTALLY. THE RESEARCH PROPOSED HERE WILL DO THIS THEREBY PROVIDING STRONGER CONSTRAINTS ON SUCH IMPORTANT UNRESOLVED QUESTIONS IN LUNAR SCIENCE AS: WHAT WAS THE EXTENT OF THE INITIAL LUNAR MAGMA OCEAN? DID THE ENTIRE MOON MELT OR ONLY THE UPPER FEW HUNDRED KM OR SOMETHING IN BETWEEN? WHAT IS THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE COMPOSITIONS AND DEPTHS OF SOURCE ROCKS FOR MARE BASALTS VS. THOSE FOR PICRITIC GLASS BEADS? WHAT IS THE ORIGIN OFMAGNESIAN KREEP-RICH BASALTS? THE EXPERIMENTS PROPOSED HERE WILL BE PERFORMED UNDER APPROPRIATE CONDITIONS OF TEMPERATURE PRESSURE AND OXYGEN FUGACITY TO ALLOW BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF THE INTERNAL STRUCTURE AND COMPOSITION OF THE MOON. RESULTS FROM THE PROPOSED EXPERIMENTS CAN THEN BE INTEGRATED WITH TREATMENTS OF POST-MAGMA OCEAN PROCESSES SUCH AS CUMULATE OVERTURN TO STRENGTHEN THE FRAMEWORK IN WHICH LUNAR SAMPLES BOTH THOSE ALREADY IN OUR POSSESSION AND THOSE THAT MAY BE RETURNED IN FUTURE ROBOTIC AND HUMAN MISSIONS MAY BE UNDERSTOOD., ONE OF THE FUNDAMENTAL PROCESSES OPERATING DURING THE EARLIEST STAGES OF SOLAR SYSTEM EVOLUTION IS THE DIFFERENTIATION OF PLANETARY BODIES. DIFFERENTIATION OCCURS ON MANY PLANETARY SCALES (TERRESTRIAL PLANETS MOONS AND ASTEROIDS) AND TYPICALLY LEADS TO THE PRODUCTIONOF A CORE MANTLE AND CRUST. THE NATURE AND EXTENT OF THE EARLY DIFFERENTIATION PROCESS PARTIALLY DICTATES THE EVOLUTION OF A PLANETARY BODY AND PERHAPS EVEN ITS EVENTUAL HOSPITABILITY FOR THE ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF LIFE. ABUNDANT EVIDENCE INDICATES THAT THE INITIALSTAGES OF PLANETARY DIFFERENTIATION TOOK PLACE FAIRLY RAPIDLY AND OCCURRED ON PLANETARY BODIES OF DIFFERENT SIZES THROUGHOUT THE SOLAR SYSTEM. THE MOON EXHIBITS MANY FEATURES THAT SUGGEST ITS DIFFERENTIATION OCCURRED BY A PROCESS OF PLANETARY-SCALE MELTING REFERRED TOAS A MAGMA OCEAN. UNLIKE MOST OTHER PLANETS WHERE EVIDENCE OF PRIMORDIAL DIFFERENTIATION HAS BEEN PARTIALLY TO TOTALLY ERASED BY GEOLOGIC ACTIVITY (E.G. EARTH AND MARS) THE MOON CONTAINS REMNANTS OF PRIMORDIAL CRUST AND MANTLE THAT WERE THE PRODUCTS OF "MAGMAOCEAN" CRYSTALLIZATION. ACCESS TO THE LUNAR MANTLE IS FAIRLY LIMITED AND IS PROVIDED BY DATA GENERATED BY THE APOLLO GENERATION SEISMIC NETWORK LARGE IMPACT STRUCTURES INTO THE LUNAR CRUST BASALTS THAT REPRESENT LIQUIDS PRODUCED BY MELTING OF THE LUNAR MANTLE AND HIGHPRESSURE EXPERIMENTS ON APPROPRIATE COMPOSITIONS TO MODEL THE CRYSTALLIZATION HISTORY OF THE MAGMA OCEAN AND GAIN INSIGHTS INTO THE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN LUNAR MAGMA OCEAN CUMULATES AND SOURCES FOR LUNAR MARE BASALTS. THIS PROJECT AIMS TO UTILIZE SOME OF THESE APPROACHES TO GAIN INSIGHTS INTO THE DIFFERENTIATION OF THE MOON AND RECONSTRUCT THE COMPOSITION OF THE LUNAR INTERIOR.LUNAR METEORITES ARE NEW SAMPLES OF CURRENTLY UNREACHABLE TERRAINS OF THE CRUST THAT MAY HAVE NOT BEEN SAMPLED BY APOLLO. THEY HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO SIGNIFICANTLY ADD TO OUR COMPROMISED KNOWLEDGE OF THE LUNAR INTERIOR BY OFFERING INSIGHTS INTO PREVIOUSLY UNIDENTIFIED SOURCE REGIONS IN THE LUNAR MANTLE. FUTURE ROBOTIC MISSIONS TO THE MOON (E.G. GRAIL SOUTH POLE AITKEN BASIN SAMPLE RETURN) AREDESIGNED TO EXPLORE MANY OF THESE UNKNOWN TERRAINS BUT UNTIL THESE MISSIONS TAKE PLACE LUNAR METEORITES PROVIDE OUR ONLY WINDOW INTO CURRENTLY UNREACHABLE PLACES ON THE MOON. THIS PROJECT WILL UTILIZE THE FACILITIES AT THE INSTITUTE OF METEORITICS TO CHARACTERIZE THEMINERALOGY AND GEOCHEMISTRY OF THREE LUNAR METEORITES IN AN EFFORT TO BETTER UNDERSTAND THE NATURE OF THE LUNAR INTERIOR.THE THREE METEORITES IN THIS STUDY REPRESENT LOW-TI BASALTS WITH SIMILAR MINERALOGY AND BULK COMPOSITION BUT WITH DISTINCT ISOTOPIC CHARACTERISTICS. OUR ANALYTICAL APPROACH WILL BE TO PERFORM A THOROUGH PETROLOGIC MINERALOGICAL TRACE ELEMENT AND ISOTOPIC STUDY OF THESE THREE METEORITES IN ORDER TO PLACE THEIR SOURCE REGIONS IN THE CONTEXT OF THE LUNAR MAGMA OCEAN HYPOTHESIS. OUR EXPERIMENTALAPPROACH WILL BE TO USE EXPERIMENTAL PETROLOGY ON THE BULK COMPOSITIONS OF THESE NEW MARE BASALTS IF WE DETERMINE THEY REPRESENT LIQUID COMPOSITIONS TO DETERMINE THE MINERALOGY COMPOSITION AND DEPTH OF THEIR MANTLE SOURCE REGIONS IN ORDER TO DEVELOP A MORE COMPLETE PICTURE AND MODEL OF THE STRUCTURE AND COMPOSITION OF THE LUNAR MANTLE. THE PETROLOGIC EXAMINATION OF THESE METEORITES ANDTHE EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM WILL EMPLOY THE ELECTRON MICROPROBE (EPMA) ION MICROPROBE (SIMS) AND THE HIGH PRESSURE LABORATORY AVAILABLE AT THE INSTITUTE OF METEORITICS. ISOTOPIC AND BULK ROCK ANALYSES WILL UTILIZE EXISTING COLLABORATIONS WITH LAWRENCE LIVERMORENATIONAL LABORATORY AND NOTRE DAME UNIVERSITY.
OpenAlex ID: W2019854118
