Work

A Critical Review: the Pathology of Cerebral Gliomas

Year: 1940
Type: article
Abstract: A CRITICAL review of the historical development and the present state of the pathology of cerebral gliomas is justified for different reasons.The first is the frequency of the condition: over 1 per cent. of all deaths are due to intracranial tumours (Ewing, 1928; Weil, 1934; Cox, 1935 ; Greenfield, 1936; Courville, 1937; Flock, 1937), about half of which are gliomas (Tooth, 1912, and all following authors).According to Peers (1936), intracranial tumours form 16-8 per cent. of all malignant neoplasms in man.Secondly, the number of papers written on this question during the last 50 years and the frequent con- tradictory opinions, make it almost impossible to reach a clear conception without an intimate acquaintance and an extensive personal experience of the subject.Thirdly, the whole glioma literature of the last 15 years practically ignores the previous work to such an extent that many previously well-estab- lished facts have completely been forgotten or often rediscovered in good faith by authors who believe that there was no worth-while glioma research before Bailey and Cushing (1926).Fourthly, the evolution of investigations on gliomas is extremely instructive from a general point of view: it demonstrates clearly that the study of a natural phenomenon transforms itself into sterile discussions as soon as the methods and principles generally applied in natural sciences are replaced by predominantly scholastic methods more devoted to the establish- ment of names, classifications, statistics, and theories than of facts.Finally, some recent developments of glioma research justify the hope that in the near future it will emerge from the deadlock of interpretations in which it has struggled for about 20 years and will become again a fruitful branch of natural sciences.To contribute to this evolution is one of the essential purposes of this paper.Trhis purpose determines both the form and content of the review.Owing to the limited space, it is impossible for the review to be complete.It has to deal essentially with the historical evolution of our knowledge of facts, but not with the creation of new names and systems for things known before under other names.This philological aspect of the question will be considered only in so far as it is necessary to understand the evolution of the glioma problem.
Language: English
Subfield: Oncology
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2043129534
FWCI: 1.551
Cites: 132
Cited by: 220
Related to: 10