Year: 2013
Type: editorial
Abstract: Rio+20: a critique -The global is personal: the personal is globalFollowing two decades on from the ground-breaking United Nations Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm in 1972, the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development in Rio in 1992 promised much in terms of the maturing of international environmental law.Among its most significant achievements, which included reaching international agreements on climate change and biodiversity, was the launch of the supposedly paradigm shifting concept of sustainable development into international law and policy agendas and ultimately, our global consciousness.This development ostensibly represented an attempt to redraw the relationship between humanity and the environment on a more viable footing, recognizing the complex interplay between environmental, social and economic factors.Accordingly, the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development (Rio+20) provided an ideal opportunity to take stock of progressor the lack of itin the intervening 20 years.What then was made of this opportunity?In fairness, as Adelman suggests, there is much to be discouraged about both in relation to the Rio+20 process and its outcomes.Widespread disappointment is clearly indicated not only by the (arguably expected) critical views of the 'usual suspects' (such as Greenpeace, which called Rio+20 a 'failure of epic proportions' 1 ) but is also evident in the more constrained views of 'establishment' figures.For example, Janez Potočnik (Europe's Environment Commissioner) expressed a certain amount of frustration with the final text, commenting that: '[t]he document does not entirely match our ambition or meet the challenge the world faces.But it's an important step forward … That's why we must engage with it …'. 2 Such muted frustration, however, casts off establishment constraints in the views of the more radically inclined nations, whose frustration was communicated in far stronger terms.For example, Nicaragua's representative, Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, pulled no punches when he stated that '[o]ur final document is an opportunity that has been missed.It contributes almost nothing to our struggle to survive as a species …'. 3 The depressing reality is that in the context of the stagnation that has characterized the more challenging aspects of international environmental law in recent years (characterizedas Lyster points outmost markedly by the recurrent failure of the Climate Change regime to make meaningful progress in developing a successor to the Kyoto Protocol), the very fact that any agreement was reached at all at Rio+20 is significanteven if that significance is painfully paradoxical in its implications.1.
Author: Karen Morrow
Institution: Swansea University
Language: English
Subfield: Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2046137807
