Year: 2006
Type: review
Abstract: Cancer incidence and mortality have virtually remained the same for the last 3 decades.1 During this time cancer research has been driven by the somatic mutation theory of cancer, which considers that cancer is a genetic disease caused by the acquisition of multiple mutations in key genes that control cell proliferation, cell death and genetic stability.2 This theory implies that cancer preventive and therapeutic strategies should be aimed at preventing or correcting these genetic alterations. It is recognized, however, that these alterations may be too unstable and too numerous to reverse3 and that the practical benefits derived from this theory may be very difficult to meet.2 This suggests that it is necessary to identify key carcinogenic events that can be exploited for the development of clinically useful anticancer strategies. Most of the energy that our cells need to live is obtained through the process of oxidative phosphorylation (oxphos). In this process, ATP generation is coupled with a reaction in which O2 is reduced to H2O. But under certain conditions O2 can also be reduced to H2O via the reactive oxygen species superoxide anion (O). Here I briefly discuss several lines of evidence that suggest that an excessive generation of O is a key event in carcinogenesis. The first piece of evidence that supports this view is that cancer cells have increased O generation4 and that an excessive O generation can cause malignant transformation.5, 6 For instance, it has been demonstrated that overexpression of the O-generating oxidase mox1 in NIH3T3 fibroblasts increased O generation and resulted in cells with increased proliferation and transformed appearance that produced tumors in athymic mice.5 The key role of O in carcinogenesis is supported by experimental observations that have shown that the malignant phenotype of cancer cells can be reversed just by reducing the cellular levels of O. Thus, it has been shown that overexpression of the O-detoxifying enzymes superoxide dismutases can reduce tumor cell growth, metastasis and other malignant features of cancer cells from different origin.7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 It is not completely understood, however, what species is directly responsible for the tumor suppression caused by the overexpression of these enzymes.13 Accumulative experimental data have revealed a consistent link between oxidative stress and carcinogenesis.14, 15, 16, 17, 18 Oxidative stress is caused by a cellular excess of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, including O, hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), hydroxyl radical (•OH) and peroxynitrite (ONOO−). These species have been implicated in many processes intimately related to carcinogenesis, such as cell transformation,5, 6, 19 proliferation,4, 20 apoptosis resistance,21, 22 metastasis23 or angiogenesis.24 These reactive species have also been found to induce genetic alterations, including DNA damage, mutations, epigenetic changes or genomic instability.17, 18, 25-29 It is unclear what species is directly responsible for each of these carcinogenesis-related processes; for instance, it seems that O2•−-induced cell transformation is not directly caused by O2•− but by H2O2.6, 30 However, it is known that O2•− generation is required for the normal production of most reactive oxygen and nitrogen species.18 These observations support the view that an excessive O generation plays an important role in carcinogenesis. Numerous reports have demonstrated that H2O2 is an efficient inductor of apoptosis in cancer cells.31, 32, 33, 34 This seems to contradict the idea that an excessive O generation plays a key role in carcinogenesis, as a high O production would increase the cellular levels of H2O2 and might stop the carcinogenesis process via induction of apoptosis. However, experimental data suggest that H2O2 may induce cell death at higher concentrations (micromolar) than those required to favor carcinogenesis (submicromolar).4, 27, 35 It is important to clarify that an excessive O generation would play a key role in carcinogenesis when this excessive O generation were not high enough to produce cytotoxic levels of H2O2. Although the somatic mutation theory of cancer is currently being challenged by numerous researchers,36, 37, 38, 39 it is widely accepted that cells must develop several acquired capabilities to become a malignant cancer. These capabilities include increased proliferation (caused, in part, by resistance to growth inhibition and independence from mitogenic stimulation), apoptosis resistance, cellular immortalization, increased angiogenesis and invasion/metastasis. Besides, genetic instability is considered a key event that favors the acquisition of these capabilities.40, 41 Figure 1 represents that an excessive O generation may explain all these marks of malignancy via activation of glycolysis and hypoxia-inducible factor 1 (HIF-1). An excessive superoxide anion generation may explain the hallmarks of cancer. An increase in the cellular production of O may activate glycolysis, as O produces intracellular alkalinization42, 43 and intracellular alkalinization increases glycolysis via activation of the enzyme phosphofructokinase.44, 45 Glycolysis activation has been associated with invasion, metastasis, angiogenesis and cell proliferation.44, 46 Indeed, glycolysis seems necessary for sustained cell proliferation because cell proliferation requires the synthesis of new molecules and glycolysis provides most of the building blocks required for the synthesis of these molecules.44 Recent data have demonstrated that O generation results in HIF-1 activation; this is understandable because O is detoxified via H2O2 and H2O2 is a key activator of HIF-1.45, 47 Activation of HIF-1 can induce apoptosis resistance, invasion, metastasis and angiogenesis,48 and may also produce cellular immortalization via activation of telomerase.49, 50 HIF-1 activation has also been associated with increased proliferation (HIF-1 increases the expression of growth factors and growth factors receptors) and genetic instability.51 There is evidence that HIF-1 activates glycolysis and vice versa. It has been shown that HIF-1 can upregulate glycolysis by increasing the expression of glucose transporters and glycolytic enzymes,48 and that glycolysis activates HIF-1 via accumulation of glucose metabolites.45, 52, 53 This suggests that O-induced activation of HIF-1 may occur independently of H2O2 (Fig. 1) and may explain recent observations that have shown that H2O2 does not mediate HIF-1 activation under certain conditions (e.g., under hypoxic conditions when the levels of manganese superoxide dismutase are low).54 Figure 1 shows that an increased O generation may explain the hallmarks of cancer by increasing the levels of H2O2, by producing intracellular alkalinization, by increasing the activity of the transcription factor HIF-1 and by activating glycolysis. Interestingly, it is known that cancer cells have increased production of H2O2,55 alkaline intracellular pH values (7.12–7.65 compared with 6.99–7.20 in normal cells),56 overexpression of HIF-148 and increased glycolytic rates.46 In short, there is an evidence that cancer cells have increased generation of O, and that an increased generation of O2•− can produce malignant transformation and may explain all the hallmarks of cancer. It is not surprising, therefore, that the malignant phenotype of cancer cells can be reversed just by reducing the cellular levels of O. Other reactive oxygen and nitrogen species have also been involved in many aspects of the carcinogenesis process and it is difficult to assign a particular species to a specific carcinogenic event. However, O generation is necessary for the normal production of most of these species. These observations suggest that an excessive O generation is a key event in carcinogenesis; preventing or decreasing excessive cellular levels of O might therefore represent an important anticancer strategy. Yours sincerely, Miguel López-Lázaro.
Source: International Journal of Cancer
DOI: 10.1002/ijc.22493
Author: Miguel López‐Lázaro
Institution: Universidad de Sevilla
Language: English
Subfield: Molecular Biology
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2052735421
