Work

Mortality from Lung Cancer in Asbestos Workers

Year: 1955
Type: article
Abstract: Sixty-one cases of lung cancer have been recorded in persons with asbestosis (Boemke, 1953 ;Hueper, 1952) since Lynch and Smith (1935) reported the first case.In view of the infrequency of asbestosis, this large number of cases suggests-but does not prove-that lung cancer is an occupational hazard of asbestos workers.The strongest evidence that it may be a hazard has been produced by Merewether and by Gloyne.Merewether (1949) found that lung cancer was reported at necropsy in 13-2% of cases of asbestosis (31 out of 235) but in only 1-3% of cases of silicosis (91 out of 6,884) and Gloyne (1951), on personal examination, found lung cancer in 14*1% of necropsies on subjects with asbestosis (17 out of 121) against 6.9% in silicotics (55 out of 796).Neither author gave full details of the sex composition of the groups examined, but since women form a higher proportion of asbestos workers than of persons employed in occupations liable to give rise to silicosis (coal-miners, stonemasons, pottery workers, foundrymen, metal grinders) and since lung cancer is less common among women, the differences in the proportions of cancer cases cannot be accounted for by differences in sex distribution.In fact the proportions which are more properly com- parable with the findings in silicotic subjects are the proportions of lung cancer found among men with asbestosis, 17.2% in Merewether's series and 19.6% in Gloyne's.Animal experiments are inconclusive.A positive result was reported by Nordmann and Sorge (1941) who found that of 10 mice which had been exposed to asbestos dust and survived for 240 days, two developed lung carcinoma.Smith (1952), however, considers that one of the " carcinomas " was, in fact, an example of squamous metaplasia and that the other, an adenocarcinoma, may have developed spontaneously from the common mouse adenoma.A negative result has been reported by Vorwald and Karr (1938).The majority of workers (cited by 81 * Necropsies on asbestos workers are ordered by the coroner when.in his opinion, there may be a question of asbestosis being a contri- butory cause of death.
Author: R. Doll
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2052905864
FWCI: 1.325
Cites: 8
Cited by: 742
Related to: 10