Desiccation Tolerance in the Resurrection Plant Craterostigma plantagineum. A Contribution to the Study of Drought Tolerance at the Molecular Level
Year: 2001
Type: article
Abstract: Adverse environmental conditions restrict the productivity and the range of habitats available to plants. This represents a severe economic constraint on agricultural production. Plants as sessile organisms have evolved a wide spectrum of adaptations to cope with the challenges of environmental stress. Quite often, however, adaptation mechanisms themselves adversely affect yield parameters, and a compromise between biomass production and environmental fitness has to be accepted. One major factor that limits the productive potential of higher plants is the availability of water. The International Water Management Institute predicts that by the year 2025, one-third of the world's population will live in regions that will experience severe water scarcity (www.iwmi.org). Therefore, it has become imperative for plant biologists to understand the mechanisms by which plants can adapt to water deficit while retaining their capacity to serve as sources of food and other raw materials. Water deficit can affect plants in different ways. A mild water deficit leads to small changes in the water status of plants, and plants cope with such a situation by reducing water loss and/or by increasing water uptake (Bray, 1997). The most severe form of water deficit is desiccation—when most of the protoplasmic water is lost and only a very small amount of tightly bound water remains in the cell. Both forms of water deficit have been studied at the molecular level using a variety of experimental systems. Arabidopsis has been extensively studied as a model plant that tolerates moderate water deficit. Genes involved in many different pathways are expressed in response to water stress in Arabidopsis, and the molecular complexity of the process is best illustrated by recent microarray experiments (Seki et al., 2001). Mutant analysis has greatly contributed to our knowledge of the mode of gene regulation under stress, and it has become obvious that a network of signal transduction pathways allows the plant to adjust its metabolism to the demands imposed by water deficit (Shinozaki and Yamaguchi-Shinozaki, 2000; for review, see Kirch et al., 2001b). These studies raise two major questions: (a) Do diverse plants use different pathways to respond to the stress?, and (b) Do variable degrees of water stress activate different metabolites? Most flowering plants cannot survive exposure to a water deficit equivalent to less than 85% to 98% (v/v) relative humidity during their vegetative growth period, although desiccation is an integral part of the normal developmental program of most higher plants in the context of seed formation. Only a few plants possess desiccation-tolerant vegetative tissues; these include a small group of angiosperms, termed resurrection plants (Gaff 1971), some ferns, algae, lichens, and bryophytes. Some of these species can equilibrate the leaves with air of 0% (v/v) relative humidity. Resurrection plants can be revived from an air-dried state and are often poikilohydrous, i.e. their water content varies with the relative humidity in the environment. Resurrection plants are found in ecological niches with limited seasonal water availability, preferentially on rocky outcrops at low to moderate elevations in tropical and subtropical zones (Porembski and Barthlott, 2001). It has been estimated that around 200 species of resurrection plants may exist, mainly in Southern Africa, Australia, India, and South America (W. Barthlott, personal communication). The physiological basis of desiccation tolerance in resurrection plants is complex. Some mechanisms may vary between different species; for example, some species retain chlorophyll during dehydration, whereas others lose their chlorophyll. The desiccation-tolerant resurrection plantCrateostigma. A, C. pumilumplants in their native habitat in Kenya (photograph courtesy of Dr. W. Barthlott, University of Bonn). B, Effect of desiccation on a C. plantagineum fully turgid plant, a desiccated plant, and a plant rehydrated for 12 h. C, Callus from left to right: untreated, 0 to 7 d. Abscisic acid (ABA)-treated callus, dried and regrown. The desiccation-tolerant resurrection plantCrateostigma. A, C. pumilumplants in their native habitat in Kenya (photograph courtesy of Dr. W. Barthlott, University of Bonn). B, Effect of desiccation on a C. plantagineum fully turgid plant, a desiccated plant, and a plant rehydrated for 12 h. C, Callus from left to right: untreated, 0 to 7 d. Abscisic acid (ABA)-treated callus, dried and regrown. The attraction of C. plantagineum as an experimental system is due to the fact that desiccation tolerance is expressed in vegetative tissues and in undifferentiated callus cultures. This allows one to compare gene expression in two systems with the same genetic background—in the absence of developmental complications, such as those that may arise when acquisition of desiccation tolerance during seed development is investigated. Callus from C. plantagineum is not intrinsically desiccation tolerant, but it acquires tolerance after it has been cultured on medium containing the plant hormone ABA (Bartels et al., 1990). Treatment of callus with ABA induces the expression of a set of mRNAs comparable with that activated upon drying in the whole plant. C. plantagineum is suited for molecular studies because it can be genetically transformed byAgrobacterium tumefaciens (Furini et al., 1994) and it is suited for transient expression analysis using protoplasts or a ballistic approach. Studies with C. plantagineum have shown that the physiological state of the plant before the onset of drying appears to be critical for survival. The plants only develop the ability to survive desiccation, if water loss occurs slowly enough to allow their metabolism to adapt by activating a specific program of gene expression. If dehydration occurs too rapidly, plants do not acquire tolerance to desiccation. Most changes in gene expression occur during dehydration and relatively few are observed during the rehydration phase. Thus, many dehydration-specific gene products have been isolated but very few rehydration-specific proteins are known (Bernacchia et al., 1996). This is in contrast to observations made on T. ruralis, a representative of the desiccation-tolerant bryophytes, which survives rapid desiccation. Here, the major changes in gene expression occur during the first hours of rehydration (Wood and Oliver, 1999). In this case, changes in gene expression in response to dehydration and rehydration are regulated at the translational level, resulting in a change in the complement of mRNAs selected for protein synthesis from a relatively constant mRNA pool (Wood and Oliver, 1999). These findings support the suggestion that desiccation tolerance in bryophytes differs from that in C. plantagineum in being mainly a rehydration-induced cellular repair response (Oliver and Bewley, 1997). In C. plantagineum, dehydration leads to drastic changes in gene expression and carbohydrate metabolism, increases in ABA levels and photosynthesis-related processes, and changes in cell ultrastructure. This plant reacts within the first 2 h to dehydration, and the metabolic changes are initiated before any signs of wilting are apparent. All of the dehydration-induced processes are reversed during rehydration. In this review, we will mainly focus on the processes that occur during dehydration because these appear to be important for cellular protection and probably also for recovery during rehydration. Water relations in plants are regulated to a large extent via the opening and closure of stomata. Water deficit leads to closure of stomata and at the same time to a decrease in intercellular CO2 concentration. As a consequence of the lower CO2 availability, carbon assimilation is inhibited and ultimately photosynthetic capacity is lost. This observation is common to dehydration-sensitive and drought-tolerant species (Schwab et al., 1989). These physiological changes are reflected at the molecular level: The steady-state levels of transcripts related to photosynthesis are down-regulated in response to water stress, e.g. the transcript for the small subunit of the Rubisco enzyme in C. plantagineum (Bernacchia et al., 1996). However, a particular feature of resurrection plants is that they recover full photosynthetic activity following rewatering. Respiration is quickly restored in C. plantagineum on rewatering when the water content reaches about 20% of its initial value. This allows us to conclude that protective mechanisms must be in place that maintain the integrity of the photosynthetic machinery in the dried plant tissue. This inference correlates well with observations that several putative protective proteins accumulate in plastids of C. plantagineum, which are targeted to the stroma and to thylakoid membranes (Schneider et al., 1993). The most prominent sugars found in C. plantagineum. 2-Octulose is predominant in untreated leaves and is converted to Suc upon dehydration. Stachyose is the major sugar in both untreated and dried roots. The most prominent sugars found in C. plantagineum. 2-Octulose is predominant in untreated leaves and is converted to Suc upon dehydration. Stachyose is the major sugar in both untreated and dried roots. To understand the biochemical basis for this switch in sugar metabolism, the expression of genes encoding sugar-metabolizing enzymes was investigated. C. plantagineum possesses a set of genes encoding isoenzymes of Suc synthase and Suc phosphate synthase (Ingram et al., 1997; Kleines et al., 1999), which are differentially expressed. Besides these enzymes and the dehydration-induced expression of cytosolic glyceraldehyde dehydrogenase, it has been proposed that transketolase contributes to the conversion of octulose to Suc. In addition to a constitutively expressed, plastid-localized transketolase, induction of two genes for transketolases during rehydration has been reported (Bernacchia et al., 1995). In C. plantagineum, two main questions concerning the carbohydrate metabolism are still open: (a) What enzymes are involved in the biosynthetic pathway leading to octulose?, and (b) Does Suc act as a protectant in the dehydrated leaves? The basic pattern of changes in gene expression that occur in response to dehydration can be summarized for C. plantagineum as follows: (a) Transcripts accumulate to high levels during dehydration and disappear early during rehydration, (b) transcripts accumulate transiently during the initial dehydration phase, (c) transcripts decline during dehydration, and (d) transcripts remain unchanged in response to dehydration. It is estimated from transcript profiling that several hundred genes probably are differentially expressed in response to dehydration (Bockel et al., 1998). The identified genes encode compounds that can be assigned to diverse metabolic pathways, although their precise function has not yet been demonstrated. The following main groups can be distinguished: (a) genes encoding proteins with protective properties, (b) genes encoding membrane proteins involved in transport processes, (c) genes encoding enzymes related to carbohydrate metabolism, (d) genes encoding regulatory molecules, such as transcription factors, kinases, or other putative signaling molecules, and (e) genes that show no homologies to known sequences. Studies on tissue-specific expression patterns and subcellular localizations have revealed specific cellular distributions of RNAs and proteins that appear to correlate with their predicted functions (Phillips et al., 2001). This group includes the proteins that accumulate most abundantly in different tissues of C. plantagineum during dehydration. Its major representatives include late embryogenesis-abundant (LEA) proteins (Schneider et al., 1993), some proteins with enzymatic function, e.g. an aldehyde dehydrogenase (Kirch et al., 2001a), and also some small heat shock proteins (Alamillo et al., 1995). LEA proteins are a heterogenous group of proteins found universally in plants, which were first discovered because they accumulate to high levels during late stages of embryo development. Synthesis of LEA proteins is associated with dehydration in seeds and with water deficit in vegetative tissues (Cuming, 1999). Dehydration-elicited expression of LEA genes is not restricted to resurrection plants but has been extensively reported also for non-tolerant plants. LEA proteins are divided into different classes based on conserved sequence motifs. In general, LEA proteins are hydrophilic and have a biased amino acid composition, mostly lacking Cys and Trp. They are typically highly water soluble, and they often remain soluble after boiling. Despite extensive studies, our knowledge of the biochemical function of LEA proteins is still rudimentary, but molecular and biochemical features strongly suggest a protective role for them. A protective function correlates with their cellular distribution: LEA polypeptides are found in all cell types, accumulating abundantly in cytoplasm or plastids (Schneider et al., 1993). This protective role is further corroborated by Wolkers et al. (1998), who showed that LEA proteins may be anchors in a structural network stabilizing cytoplasmic components during pollen drying. Two approaches have been used to demonstrate that LEA proteins function as cellular protectants: in vitro protection assays with purified proteins and in planta studies in which LEA proteins were overexpressed. The results generally support a protective role (Xu et al., 1996), although contradictory observations have also been reported (Iturriaga et al., 1992). One conclusion that can be drawn from functional analysis indicates that individual LEA proteins make only a small contribution to dehydration tolerance, whereas the coordinated synthesis of the complete set of proteins probably plays a central role. Biochemical experiments, including structural analysis of native proteins, are needed to understand the role of each specific LEA protein. It is remarkable that LEAgenes contain sequence motifs that are conserved in all higher plants. This strict conservation during evolution indicates that these motifs define functional units within these proteins. Thus, our studies suggest that desiccation tolerance in vegetative tissues in C. plantagineum is probably not due to structural genes that are unique to resurrection plants, but that relevant genes are also present in the genome of non-tolerant plants. The difference between tolerant and non-tolerant plants is likely to reside in the expression patterns and is likely to be at least in part a quantitative with to LEA A of dehydration-induced gene expression in the tolerant C. plantagineum with a non-tolerant relative may further for this of gene regulation is important in the of a desiccation tolerance because different regulatory pathways the expression of a whole set of of regulatory is individual have been but their with other within the network is for the most part experimental approaches have been to involved in the of gene expression in response to stress. Most is from and from have contributed to gene regulation in Arabidopsis (Shinozaki and Yamaguchi-Shinozaki, A to desiccation tolerance in C. plantagineum is because of the of its One that is central to gene expression is the plant hormone of C. plantagineum plants and callus to ABA induces genes that are activated by dehydration. in callus ABA is to the genes needed for the expression of The regulation of gene expression by dehydration and ABA several signaling pathways and different in the of genes and of genes encoding enzymes have been and of the not obvious common motifs. Therefore, several were in and Arabidopsis plants to define functional The were found to be highly in seeds and but two of were not in vegetative tissues of Arabidopsis or (Furini et al., et al., 1998). Only the of the was by dehydration or ABA in vegetative tissues of a plant. However, expression of the Arabidopsis gene leads to of the other two in Arabidopsis leaves upon ABA (Furini et al., et al., 1998). a transcription factor that is during seed development in In of the fact that C. plantagineum in vegetative tissues many transcripts that are related to those genes expressed during seed was isolated from C. the that such a gene be for of genes in vegetative tissues plantagineum. A gene related to the gene was and its was to LEA genes in transient expression assays and 1997). However, expression of the was not in fully leaves of C. plantagineum. Therefore, other transcription must be involved in the of LEA In many genes regulated by ABA and stress, one or ABA response a role in The have a It is that transcription of the basic as to the are present in LEA gene in C. plantagineum, but they do not to be the major of ABA e.g. in the other have been identified that proteins in an and are for of a gene in response to ABA (Kirch et al., 2001b). with putative or with a putative signaling role have been in our in the of is based on sequence to known Transcripts encoding these are during the early of dehydration and/or by ABA an in the dehydration In this genes for several potential transcription were and it was shown that of diverse gene in the response of C. plantagineum to dehydration. These include genes for and a heat shock transcription of the a a and the These genes in a regulatory but in most their genes are still and it is not known if individual regulatory pathways with each In the following of studies on such C. plantagineum will be genes are specific for plants and are to developmental processes, and to environmental from to and stress. proteins are by the of a to a that et al., The activity of proteins in of the to specific present in of genes that are regulated by dehydration have been isolated plantagineum, that this of transcription is likely to a major role in gene expression during dehydration. in Arabidopsis this Two genes from C. and are of particular because their products were shown to in a system et al., 1998). Both transcripts were by dehydration, but was to This that the two genes act in different pathways of the regulatory an pathway and an between these two pathways be the of the two proteins. no genes for the proteins have been for proteins were found in the of at least two of its level, the best to plantagineum is to The induction of desiccation tolerance in the callus system the to for such plantagineum are transformed by tumefaciens a containing of the The are into the genome if present in to gene of a callus was selected that was of desiccation addition of ABA to the of transcripts showed that genes were constitutively expressed in the callus, which in can only be by ABA The gene targeted by the which to the of was isolated and et al., 1997). is present in in the genome of C. plantagineum and its expression can be by ABA in callus and plants. The most feature of the gene is that it has only a very encoding a putative of amino To it has not been to demonstrate the of a by and further experiments support the that may act as a regulatory for a gene with such is the gene from which the of et al., sequence to identified in the Arabidopsis but this not the that Arabidopsis transcripts that may function at the the other the function of may be related to the highly and set of that C. plantagineum from the of severe desiccation. metabolism has been to be involved in plant to forms of stress and 2001). The of signaling may well be the in the signaling that leads from the of water stress to In the context of the desiccation response in C. plantagineum, is of particular the of a structural and other to form acid in protein or small proteins. In C. plantagineum, activity is within by dehydration et al., The activity is specific for dehydration and is not by Two and encoding have been The transcript is constitutively expressed, whereas is to dehydration et al., of proteins indicates a regulation at the level of expression and cellular on the physiological status of the plant. The constitutively expressed is likely to be involved in early to dehydration, as a that the stress may be involved in metabolism and the membrane that are observed as a consequence of cellular desiccation. forms of in Arabidopsis, and a was also reported from this plant et al., 2001). This low sequence with the from C. plantagineum. The Arabidopsis that is most related to the products of the C. plantagineum genes is not to water deficit in vegetative it is associated with and is reported to be present in the closure of and is involved in water relations et al., 2001). The of the in two plant C. plantagineum and that sequence expression patterns and gene functions have during The adaptation of C. cope with desiccation may have from the of genes to than are to this in a plant that only tolerates a moderate of water stress. is to define gene functions and the regulation of gene the genes isolated and from C. plantagineum to us many into the protective mechanisms that desiccation The studies on C. plantagineum our knowledge of the of plants to dehydration, a on of the from the extensive studies of A of the from C. plantagineum and Arabidopsis can to the following the of desiccation tolerance in resurrection plants comparable with the used in the seeds of most higher plants or has C. unique genes to its vegetative In of it is a that most in of basic patterns of growth and of plants will be from studies on However, these studies will not be to the adaptation of C. plantagineum to The available from Arabidopsis is often in genes isolated from C. plantagineum. studies have to be because several see the on have us that sequence not functional on C. plantagineum has This is the for the and very in leaves of the sugar which to be restricted to a small group of plants. of the may us in carbohydrate A that not have been the plantagineum was the of the the function of the gene is not it is likely that it as a regulatory This to molecular mechanisms that may have a important role in the evolution of adaptation to environmental stress. The analysis of desiccation tolerance in C. at least to a large the same are involved in the tolerance in seeds and in vegetative tissues of C. plantagineum. This is important because it that the genetic for desiccation tolerance is present in the genome of if not higher plants. in the of gene expression probably for the of desiccation tolerance to specific stages of seed development. of the molecular that the and patterns of gene expression during the acquisition of desiccation tolerance in seeds in the to the of the desiccation response also in vegetative on C. plantagineum has us to several questions that are important in and plant adaptation to ecological The of from studies on the genetic model plant Arabidopsis and on diverse plant species us to understand one of the most in plant ability to survive water. for with the of the and for with the
Source: PLANT PHYSIOLOGY
DOI: 10.1104/pp.010765
Authors: Dorothea Bartels, Francesco Salamini
Language: English
Subfield: Plant Science
Domain: Life Sciences
SDG: Zero hunger
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2053981702
