Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: Cullompton : Willan ( 2008 ) 192pp. £50.00hb ISBN 978-1-84392-366-4 £22.00pb ISBN 978-1-84392-365-7 John Pitts has for a long time laboured in the youth crime and justice vineyard and has previously drawn attention to the atomisation of the working class and the formation of a youth group, often non-white, effectively excluded from economic activity and prospects (Pitts 2003). In Reluctant Gangsters he takes this analysis further with supporting, ethnographic evidence, though the precise extent of the evidence is left somewhat opaque: there is no detailed methodological account. His self-avowed purpose is the promotion of more effective interventions to limit the damage being wrought by violent youth gangs and lay the foundations for a longer-term strategy to tackle the conditions in which they thrive. Countering the caution exercised by many analysts about employing the G word – namely, the contention that most youth group affiliations within which much youth crime occurs do not merit the term ‘gang’ and thus to employ the word excites unwarranted assumptions and fears – Pitts is clear: in some parts of contemporary Britain there is a developing youth gang culture, the consequences of which are serious. The blurb on the cover puts the issue starkly: During the time it took to write this book 39 young people were either shot or stabbed to death on the streets of London in gang-related murders. … In certain parts of our towns and cities, and among certain social groups, life has become far more dangerous for children and young people. At the heart of this problem is the proliferation of violent youth gangs and the culture they ferment. Pitts gathered his evidence in three London boroughs – identified only as Red, White and Blue – during the period 2005 to 2008. He mapped, with the evident assistance of Metropolitan Police intelligence, the number, nature, seriousness and social impact of youth gangs. He talked to young people in, and on the fringes of, the gangs and with many of the volunteers and professionals working with them. He monitored gang desistance programmes. His conclusions are stark. The dramatic contraction of recent years in the proportion of the population living in social housing, combined with the growth of the illicit drugs trade and the failure of our education system and labour markets to engage with many of the young people living in these deprived pockets, has created conditions within which violent youth gangs thrive. Times have changed. American-style gangs have arrived. They provide a haven in a heartless world. Kids join them to survive and become locked into them. They have a structure and, increasingly, a business base. Pitt's final chapter comprises a lengthy review of the more sophisticated gang intervention strategies developed in the USA, Belgium, Manchester and London. Pitts is very clear. We have a growing problem and suppression alone will not solve it. He tentatively outlines some of the ingredients for tackling the issue, but does not duck the fact that the work will be difficult and dangerous. Neighbourhood policing, engaging parents and community volunteers, working within schools and in partnership with faith groups – all should be part of a strategic ‘whole community’ approach. What won't work, he stresses, is a managerial, formulaic, check-list, taken-off-the-shelf approach along ‘what works’ lines. This is ‘horses for local courses’ work.
Author: ROD MORGAN
Institution: University of Bristol
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2056630265
