Year: 1958
Type: article
Abstract: PSYCHOLOGY, under the guise of'mental science applied to education', was first introduced into the training college curriculum about the year 1850, and since that time it has been a suspect subject.In 1856, in the 'Report on Church Training Colleges', the Rev. F. Temple, later to become Archbishop of Canterbury, was sceptical of the value of contemporary psychology as an aid to teaching and discouraged its study by students in training.Robert Lowe, as might have been expected, denied the existence of such a subject as mental science and, after the introduction of the Revised Code in 1862, succeeded in excluding it altogether.It was reintroduced gradually as part of the course in principles of education after the Act of 1870, and since then has been criticised on various grounds, chiefly perhaps that it is often sterile and academic, that it is difficult and sometimes even dangerous to apply, and that psychologists are still often in violent disagreement on fundamental issues.It is probable that, apart from those who, like Lowe, were motivated by mere prejudice, the early critics of 'mental science' had good reason for their doubts.For one thing, it most certainly was not a science.Herbart had seen that it might one day become one, while physicists--for example, Mtiller, Helmholtz, Weber and Fechner--had begun to investigate the problems of sensation, but much current psychology was highly speculative.It is ironic that a teacher of today must know something of contemporary psychology in order to combat the effect of the application of the dubious psychologies of a century ago on which much present-day educational practice is still quite clearly based.The empiricist who believes that he has evolved his own teaching methods is, more often than not, the mere imitator of those who practised teaching a generation or more ago and who, on their part, showed the effect of either associationist or faculty dogma or both.Within the living memory of mature teachers, that is during the twenties of the present century, psychology of a sort had obtained a firm grip upon education courses in colleges and universities, but it was usually sterile, innocuous, and in the opinion of most students a flagrant waste of time.Herbart, who, two decades or more before, had made a somewhat tardy appearance upon the educational scene, was now under heavy criticism, and the very considerable developments in pure psychology which had occurred earlier in the century had not yet found their application in the classroom.Small wonder then that the generation of trained teachers who passed through the colleges and universities at this time were extremely sceptical of the value of psychology as an aid to teaching and have remained so all their lives.In some courses the nature of intelligence and the problems of testing received
Author: J.A. Lawton
Institution: University of Huddersfield
Language: English
Subfield: General Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2066124235
