Year: 1999
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: EPIDURAL analgesia is most often used for postoperative pain relief, whereas it is no longer so commonly used for long-term treatment of pain from malignant diseases. For perioperative use, the epidural catheter is most frequently inserted before induction of anesthesia while the patient is awake, although there has recently been some debate as to whether regional techniques should or should not be performed during general anesthesia. 1Side effects of epidural analgesia are common, 2but the majority are innocuous and well known to anesthesiologists. However, two serious complications of epidural analgesia may result in severe morbidity: the spinal epidural hematoma and the spinal epidural abscess. In a recent editorial, 3the incidence of spinal epidural hematoma after epidural analgesia in association with the use of low-molecular-weight heparin was estimated to vary from 1:1,000 to 1:10,000 epidural procedures, which is much higher than previously thought. The incidence of spinal epidural abscess after epidural analgesia remains unknown but has been reported to vary widely. No cases of epidural abscess were found in a large Swedish study of 9,232 epidural procedures, 4whereas there were two cases of abscess formation among 13,000 epidural procedures in a German report, 5and 3% of the patients in a smaller North American study developed epidural abscess after long-term epidural treatment of chronic pain. 6The incidence has also been reported to vary from 0.6 to 0.77 per 1,000 catheter days. 7,8The present study was undertaken to estimate the incidence of epidural abscess after epidural analgesia in Denmark during a 1-yr period and to evaluate the overall use of epidural analgesia during the same period. We further wished to analyze the treatment and outcome in patients with spinal epidural abscess.All anesthetic departments in Denmark were invited in writing to participate in a prospective 1-yr study of patients with epidural abscess after epidural analgesia from May 1, 1997, to April 30, 1998. After a reminder was sent to departments that failed to respond to the initial invitation, a questionnaire was distributed to the participating departments. The questionnaire was to be completed when a patient developed an epidural abscess after epidural analgesia, and in each department a local coordinator was responsible for the collection and transfer of data for the relevant patients. Because the anticipated total number of epidural procedures during the 1-yr study period was high, only information about patients who developed an epidural abscess or in whom the diagnosis was suspected (i.e. , were referred for neurosurgery) was requested. Epidural catheterization was classified as complicated (multiple attempts) or uncomplicated (straightforward).No single method was used at all departments to identify all patients with complications after epidural catheterization. All Danish physicians were informed about the ongoing study through the Danish Medical Journal , 9and the coordinators were reminded at regular intervals of the progress of the study. Patients with indwelling (long-term) epidural catheters were examined on a regular basis by an anesthesiologist according to local routines to ensure that the epidural analgesia was working and to renew the content of the epidural infusion pump.A national identification system (Central Personal Registry) based on a person's date of birth plus a four-digit number, which, taken together, is unique to that person, is used in all cases of contact with the Danish health care system. This central identification facilitates subsequent tracking of any given individual within the society. Furthermore, a national coding system of diagnoses and surgical procedures facilitates cross-checking information about specific hospital admissions. The Danish population of 5.5 million people is predominantly white and may be considered fairly homogenous from racial and social points of view. Therefore, the study population was relatively closed and well documented.At the end of the study period, the number of epidural catheters used in each department was calculated. Patients who developed epidural abscess at the end of the study period, after an epidural catheter had been inserted during the study period, were to be included (n = 0). The follow-up of patients with spinal epidural abscess was terminated at the most recent hospital discharge as documented in the patients' notes. The ethics committee waived the need for consent.Local variations in the facilities available for departmental recording of anesthetic activities during the study period accounted for interhospital differences in the calculation of the number of epidural catheters. The number of catheters used during the study period may either be calculated from number of catheters in stock on May 1, 1997, plus the catheters purchased during the study minus the stock on April 30, 1998, or may be derived from computerized registration of epidural anesthetics. The validity of the latter method was tested at one university hospital where 88% of the purchased catheters (2,900 of 3,285) were used during the 1-yr period. Allowing for a 10% waste rate (e.g. , because of technical problems), this figure suggests an acceptable correlation between the two numbers. As for patients with epidural abscess after epidural analgesia, the combination of a national system of coding of diagnoses and surgical procedures and the Central Personal Registry made it possible to identify all patients referred to neurosurgical departments with a diagnosis of spinal epidural abscess during the study period, and to cross-match admitted patients and operating lists with the patients with epidural abscess. This analysis of data was performed by the authors. A manual review of the neurosurgical operating lists at six neurosurgical departments was performed by the authors in four cases and by the chiefs of neurosurgical departments in two cases.After the study period, three subgroups of epidural procedures were analyzed:(1) catheterization time was studied in 343 epidural procedures from one university hospital;(2) level of catheterization was investigated in a subgroup of 2,171 patients from two university hospitals and two nonuniversity hospitals; and (3) indications for epidural analgesia were studied in 1,795 patients from one university hospital and four nonuniversity hospitals.Results are presented as mean ± SD. Intergroup comparisons were analyzed by chi-square test with Yates correction and P values < 0.05 were considered indicative of statistical significance.Forty-six of 59 departments participated in the study. This represents 78% of anesthesia departments in Denmark, covering a population of 4.5 million people. There were 12 participating university departments and 34 nonuniversity departments; two university departments and 11 nonuniversity departments chose not to participate. Sixty-eight percent of the epidural procedures were performed at the university departments. Twenty-three of 44 anesthetic departments (52%) possessed computerized registration of epidural anesthetics, and 21 departments (48%) used stock recording for calculation of the number of catheters used. Two departments did not use epidural anesthesia. A total of 17,372 epidural catheters were used during the 1-yr period.Data from 12 patients with possible epidural abscess formation were collected. Nine of these 12 patients had developed a true spinal epidural abscess, two had subcutaneous infections, and one suffered from sequelae from a misplaced epidural catheter. However, only the nine cases of epidural abscess are considered here. These cases occurred at eight different departments. No cases were identified in neurosurgical departments that had not already been registered by the coordinators. The incidence of spinal epidural abscess after epidural analgesia was 1:1,930 catheters. The incidence of epidural abscess was 1:5,661 catheters at the participating university hospitals, and 1:796 catheters at the nonuniversity (community) hospitals (P < 0.01). Case reports of the nine patients with epidural abscess are presented in the appendix.The catheters remained in situ for a mean of 11 days (11.2 ± 3.6 days) and a median of 6 days (range, 3–31 days;table 1).Of the nine patients with epidural abscess, five had a thoracic catheter placement, whereas a lumbar epidural catheter was inserted in the other four patients (table 1).In the nine patients with epidural abscess, 67% received epidural analgesia for perioperative pain relief, 22% for cancer pain, and 11% for trauma-related pain. Low-molecular-weight heparin was given as thromboprophylaxis before epidural catheterization in six of nine patients.Symptoms and signs of meningitis (fever, meningismus, headache) were found in 11% of the patients, 56% of the patients were febrile, and 67% had signs of local infection (table 1). Sixty-seven percent complained of localized back pain, and 78% developed neurologic disturbances such as lower-limb paraplegia, urinary or fecal incontinence, or irradiating pain (table 1).The time from appearance of the initial symptoms of development of an epidural abscess to the time diagnosis was established varied from 1 to 32 days (mean, 8.2 ± 9.9 days; median, 5 days). For patients undergoing neurosurgical decompression of the spinal cord (n = 7), the mean time from first symptoms to confirmation of the diagnosis was 5.9 ± 4.0 days (median, 5 days). Staphylococcus aureus was isolated in six patients (67%). Coagulase-negative cocci were found in one patient, and no bacteria were found in two patients (table 1). Bacteremia was diagnosed in two patients (S. aureus in one case and Staphylococcus epidermidis in one). All patients received intravenous antibiotic treatment.Seven patients with neurologic deficits underwent neurosurgical decompression of the spinal cord within 24 h of verification of the diagnosis, and two patients were treated successfully with antibiotics and were discharged free of neurologic symptoms. Four of the patients who underwent surgery developed persisting neurologic deficits (table 1); two patients suffered severe paraplegia, and two developed paraparesis. The risk of persisting neurologic deficits was 1:4,343 catheters. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was used in eight of nine patients to establish the diagnosis of spinal epidural abscess, and computed tomography plus myelography was used in one patient.For comparison, three subgroups of patients were analyzed. A subgroup of 343 catheters at one university hospital was analyzed for details of the catheterization period. In this group, the median and mean catheterization time was 3 days (range, 1–10 days) and 3.5 days, respectively (fig. 1). A subgroup consisting of epidural procedures from two university and two nonuniversity departments were analyzed in detail with respect to the level of catheterization. At the university hospitals, 863 catheters were used; 80% of these were thoracic and 20% lumbar. At the nonuniversity departments, a total of 1,308 epidural catheters were inserted: 33% thoracic and 67% lumbar. The indications for epidural catheterization were analyzed in a subgroup of 1,795 patients. Eighty-seven percent of the epidural catheters were inserted for perioperative pain relief (including obstetric analgesia), 9% of the patients were trauma victims, and 4% had an epidural catheter inserted for relief of cancer related pain. The findings of these comparisons may not be entirely representative of the total study population. However, the hospitals were selected at random, and the total number of catheters in the subgroups included 24.8% of all epidural procedures.The large majority of the anesthetic departments indicated that registration and later follow-up of every epidural anesthetic procedure would not be possible. Subsequently, we planned the study so that a staff member at each department immediately conveyed data of patients who developed epidural abscess after epidural analgesia to the authors. Furthermore, the medical community was informed of the study in an article appearing in the Danish Medical Journal , 9which is received by all Danish physicians. Because of the severity of the complication, we believe it is unlikely that cases were not reported, but because of the study design, the true incidence of epidural abscess may be even higher than calculated here. However, no further patients were admitted to the neurosurgical departments, and in our opinion, the incidence reported here is nearly accurate.During a 1-yr period, a total of 17,372 epidural catheters were used in a population of 4.5 million people. Approximately 400,000 anesthetics are given in Denmark each year. 10Subsequently, epidural analgesia was used alone or in combination with general anesthesia in 6% of all anesthetic procedures. In a recent review of the European anesthesiology literature from 1974 to 1996, a total of 42 cases of epidural abscess after epidural analgesia were reported. 11This number probably represents a significant degree of underestimation of the problem. In this series, the incidence of epidural abscess after epidural analgesia was 1:1,930 catheters, which is higher than previously quoted estimates of approximately 1:5,000 catheters. 5However, epidural abscess was associated with simultaneous occurrence of long duration of catheterization, possible immunosuppression, and low-dose anticoagulation in the large majority of patients.Epidural abscess formation may occur spontaneously in approximately 1:10,000 hospital admissions in the United States. 12We believe it to be unlikely that patients with previous epidural catheterization should develop a spontaneous abscess unrelated to the epidural catheter, because the abscesses in all patients were found at the same level as the previous catheter, and they occurred within a relatively short interval of the epidural catheter insertion.Our results suggest that the use of thoracic versus lumbar epidural analgesia is similar. Epidural catheterization is performed after surgical hand wash, and the procedure includes wearing a hat, face mask, and sterile gloves, disinfecting the patient's skin twice with a chlorohexidine/70% alcohol solution (most often from a multiuse bottle), and using disposable epidural kits and drapes. When intraoperative epidural analgesia is used, it is likely to extend into the postoperative phase, and prolonged epidural catheterization (≥ 3 days) is generally accepted for major general and orthopedic surgery in Denmark. Subsequently, segmental analgesia and segmental placement of the epidural catheter is the most commonly accepted procedure. This is further supported by the results of an international study of the use of spinal opioid analgesia in which 75% of the respondents preferred segmental analgesia for postoperative pain relief. 13In accordance with this approach, we observed an 80% frequency of thoracic epidural catheterization at two university departments and a lower frequency at nonuniversity departments. Although these figures are the result of a subgroup analysis of 2,171 catheters, we believe that they are a reliable representation of the national anesthetic activity and of the use of segmental epidural analgesia. The distribution of the epidural abscesses presented here reflects the distribution of the epidural catheters, and our results do not support the assumption that thoracic epidural analgesia is more likely to result in symptomatic abscess formation than the lumbar approach. However, the absolute number of abscesses is, in this respect, low.Eight of nine patients experienced uncomplicated catheter insertion. Therefore, our results do not support the anticipation that a technically difficult catheter insertion may predispose the patient to development of infectious complications. It has been suggested that multiple needle insertions carry a risk of asymptomatic epidural hematoma formation that may later become the focus of bacterial colonization. 11This remains undocumented, however, and hematogenous colonization of an epidural catheter is believed to be most unusual. 14Two thirds of patients with epidural abscess received low-dose or low-molecular-weight heparin as thromboprophylaxis before epidural catheterization. Thromboprophylaxis for surgical patients has attracted much attention in Denmark. An analysis of periodic questionnaire surveys from 1981 to 1990 showed that 68% of all surgical departments had included regimens for thromboprophylaxis in departmental instructions. 15This figure compares well to the finding of 66% of patients who received thromboprophylaxis in this study. However, our results cannot establish a cause-and-effect relationship between the use of low-molecular-weight heparin and the observed incidence of epidural abscess. Furthermore, our findings do not permit differentiation between an epidural abscess and an infected epidural hematoma, because MRI studies may be unable to distinguish the signals from a primary epidural abscess from those of a degrading hematoma with infection.All patients in this study with spinal epidural abscess had epidural catheters in situ for ≥ 3 days, and there are still no reports of abscess formation in patients with short-term epidural analgesia (≤ 2 days). Figure 1illustrates that patients with epidural abscess had the catheter in situ three times longer than the mean catheterization time in 343 patients from one hospital (11.2 vs. 3.5 days). However, the figure also shows that in this group of 343 patients, most had the catheter in situ for 3 days, as was the case in one third of the patients with epidural abscess; therefore, although there are no reports of abscess formation after 2 days of catheterization, it seems that a catheterization time of 3 days does not eliminate the risk of epidural infection.Patients in need of long-term epidural pain relief are by necessity severely ill. In our study, only one patient had no complicating disease, whereas four patients suffered from malignant disease, two had non–insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, and two patients suffered from multiple trauma and chronic obstructive airways disease, respectively. This predominance of immunocompromised patients has also been found in previous studies. 8,11,16Because long-term (≥ 3 days) postoperative epidural pain relief most often is used after surgery for cancer, it is not surprising to find malignancy as a complicating disease in patients with epidural abscess. However, our findings do not permit the opposite conclusion, that epidural abscess is more likely to occur in patients with cancer than in patients without malignancy.Seven patients underwent neurosurgery for evacuation of the abscess, and four were discharged with neurologic sequelae in the form of paraparesis of varying degrees. The patients who were treated with antibiotics only were discharged free of symptoms. The approach is in accordance with the results of Du Pen et al. , 8who described successful antibiotic treatment of 15 nonsurgical patients with epidural infection after long-term epidural catheters in the absence of neurologic deficits. The overall outcome in patients with epidural abscess after prolonged epidural analgesia is grave, because 44% of these patients left the hospital with a persisting neurologic deficit. Larger studies of the outcome after epidural abscess after epidural analgesia have shown a similar incidence of neurologic deficits, and apparently no improvement in outcome has occurred since the period from 1947 to 1974. 11It is generally accepted that decompression of the spinal cord should be performed as soon as possible should signs of medullary affection occur. 12,17In our study, there was a 6-day delay in the referral and neurosurgical treatment of patients. The outcome after epidural abscess is related to preoperative impairment, 17which emphasizes the importance of and It is possible that the and may have to the incidence of in this may that there is a risk of referral to neurosurgical departments of patients from nonuniversity However, this was not in the present of localized infection occurred in 67% of our patients, whereas 56% complained of back pain, and 56% had patient had symptoms and signs of and neurologic deficits were found in results are in accordance with those of an analysis of patients admitted to a neurosurgical department with epidural abscess in which and suffered from and neurologic deficits, respectively. the most signs and symptoms of epidural abscess after epidural catheterization of neurologic deficits, and back pain, whereas meningitis is aureus was isolated in 67% of patients, which is in accordance with other patients received antibiotic which is in with United for treatment of spinal epidural abscess. patients were treated with antibiotics It has been suggested that this treatment is acceptable in patients with a lumbar epidural abscess without neurologic symptoms in whom the bacteria is findings of this study suggest was a significant in the frequency of epidural abscess at university versus community However, the study does not permit of interhospital differences in the indications and of patients with epidural catheters, and further analysis of the for the observed the of this analgesia was used in 6% of all anesthetic procedures in Denmark. There is that epidural analgesia is a method of pain and it is the of each anesthesiologist with the patient to on the and the most acceptable method of postoperative pain relief. It is that the results of this study may the anesthesiologist in that A national Danish of all anesthetics given in the may in the of the incidence of spinal epidural abscess after epidural catheters in to the catheterization authors the at anesthesiology and departments in Denmark for in data and with a medical of chronic obstructive airways disease and was admitted for of a with general anesthesia. the before the patient received low-molecular-weight heparin the perioperative before induction of an epidural catheter was inserted at the antibiotics were not used. a catheter was inserted one level because of analgesia from the initial epidural catheter. The catheter was used for postoperative analgesia for 3 days and was Four days later the patient was febrile, the epidural was and after days a was by the with a to the A computed tomography with a myelography an epidural abscess at the The patient was to a neurosurgical department and underwent surgery aureus was isolated from the abscess, and antibiotic treatment with and was Two later the patient suffered from fecal and urinary and to and was The patient 11 after the neurosurgical procedure after for with a medical of disease, severe chronic obstructive airways disease, and non–insulin-dependent diabetes was admitted for of a previously inserted with epidural analgesia. low-molecular-weight heparin and were An epidural catheter was inserted at the and was left in situ for postoperative pain The catheter was on postoperative The postoperative was complicated by severe and a postoperative urinary was with a persisting showed in the lumbar days an MRI showed an epidural abscess at the and the patient was to a neurosurgical department days after the epidural procedure and underwent surgery the same the of aureus , and antibiotic treatment with and was The patient was discharged from neurosurgery with deficits in the with the than the At a 1-yr follow-up the patient was unable to without and suffered severe lumbar back with a medical of was admitted for of a with general and epidural analgesia. The epidural catheter was inserted at the level and was left for postoperative pain relief. low-molecular-weight heparin was not used, whereas a single of and was given The catheter was after 6 days because of localized back pain. The patient was discharged from the hospital but was after 6 days because of back pain. The patient was examined by the anesthesiologist and was referred for which an epidural abscess at the that the patient underwent of the same spinal a lower-limb was and the patient was to with treatment of and for aureus with a medical of non–insulin-dependent diabetes was admitted for insertion of a with epidural analgesia. low-molecular-weight heparin was given on the before The epidural catheter was inserted at the and left in situ for postoperative pain treatment during days the patient complained of lumbar back pain, and the days the pain local back pain at and at the insertion were the 6 days the patient developed irradiating pain in to the level of the in to urinary aureus The patient was to hospital for MRI and subsequent neurosurgical decompression of an epidural abscess at the treatment of and The postoperative was complicated by and days a was still but the was The patient was to the neurosurgical department 11 days later for a epidural abscess, but a diagnosis of was with no complicating was admitted for insertion of a with epidural analgesia. The patient received low-molecular-weight heparin on the before and a single of was given An epidural catheter was inserted in the and remained in situ for postoperative use during days the patient complained of back pain and the insertion showed signs of and was the catheter. on the of the was also found on the patient underwent surgical of a large subcutaneous abscess at the catheter insertion MRI was performed 2 days and a diagnosis of epidural abscess was The patient was to hospital for neurosurgical of the abscess at the aureus was isolated from the catheter as well as the abscess, and treatment with was no deficits were later the patient was for neurosurgical of the subcutaneous with a medical of a severe trauma with multiple of and and The was treated with and was given with low-molecular-weight An epidural catheter was inserted at the for pain relief during from The patient was at the time of epidural catheterization. Because of and local signs of infection at the of the epidural catheter, it was after days. aureus was isolated from the catheter the days the patient developed of the and fecal The patient was to hospital for which an epidural abscess at the neurosurgical decompression of the spinal cord was performed the same but the only days only and was treatment of The postoperative was complicated by a total of the left a further period of with cancer with to the and the lumbar for which received underwent epidural catheter insertion at the for long-term treatment of cancer pain. days later the patient complained of pain at of the and the 5 days two of epidural were and the catheter was on After days of the catheter showed and and the patient developed signs of meningitis (fever, meningismus, There were no neurologic deficits, but the the days. An MRI performed on showed an epidural abscess from to epidermidis was isolated from the catheter and as well as from the and antibiotic treatment of and After neurosurgical surgery was because of a of neurologic deficits. A follow-up 2 later showed no signs of infection and no neurologic with previous health was admitted for a for cancer with general and epidural anesthesia. Low-molecular-weight heparin and antibiotics were The epidural catheter was inserted at the and was left in situ for pain relief. the postoperative the patient complained of of the left no signs of local at the catheter insertion were An MRI showed a epidural collection at the level without of the spinal tomography of the was No bacteria were but antibiotic treatment with and was with a medical of cancer, for which had and of the on received for asymptomatic urinary An epidural catheter was inserted at the for long-term pain relief. later the patient developed lumbar back pain and irradiating pain in the left with in the same The patient was after days with pain. No or local signs of infection were however, an MRI performed at a different hospital on the showed an epidural abscess to the left of the neurosurgical decompression of the spinal cord was performed on the same The neurologic signs but the postoperative was complicated by signs of Because of the patient was treated with decompression of the intravenous and and of the previous were suspected as the
Source: Anesthesiology
Authors: Lars P. Wang, John Hauerberg, Jes F. Schmidt
Language: English
Subfield: Infectious Diseases
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2069335874
