Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: The use of climate matching to improve the success rate of introductions of biological control agents into new environments is well-established (DeBach, 1964). Similarly, there have been robust examples where the risk of establishment of invasive species has been successfully defined a priori using climatic modelling. These include: Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Say) in Europe (Sutherst et al., 1991), Amblyomma variegatum (Fabricius) and A. hebraeum (Koch) in Zimbabwe (Bruce & Wilson, 1998); Chrysomya bezziana (Villeneuve) in Ethiopia (Hall & Wall, 1995) and Boophilus microplus (Canestrini) in east and southern Africa (Sutherst, 2001). Samways et al. (1999) claim to have tested 'how accurate predictions of range change might be before entertaining global climatic change'. They attempted to do this by using climate matching to predict the success of establishment of fifteen species of ladybirds (Coccinellidae, Chilocorus spp.), which had been the subject of efforts to spread them beyond their native ranges to enhance biological control. The 'percent correct predictions of establishment' was the criterion used to test their hypothesis, expressed also as 'predicting species climatic tolerances'. After achieving an apparently low success rate, they concluded that 'even in the absence of climate change, range cannot always be determined, which means that most predictions of range change with climate change are likely to be wrong'. I discuss here how such a statement demonstrates weak scientific inference. Samways et al. used the CLIMEX model (Sutherst & Maywald, 1985; Sutherst et al., 1995, 1999) and its associated 'Match Climates', climate-matching algorithm to make their predictions. The CLIMEX model is a simulation model of moderate complexity for inferring the responses of a species to climate from its geographical distribution. Once response functions have been fitted, the model can be run with meteorological data from other parts of the world to estimate the species response to new climatic environments. The potential range, as determined by climate, can then be estimated. The model parameter values constitute the hypotheses on the climatic factors that determine the species population growth, and survival during adverse seasonal conditions, and so limit the geographical distribution. Alternatively, the meteorological data base can be manipulated to create scenarios of climate change. Samways et al. attempted to explain the success or otherwise of particular introductions of Chilocorus species to new environments based on their estimated potential climatic range. This assumes that both the claims of the predictive success of climate matching, in this case using CLIMEX, and the base rates for establishment of exotic introductions are both 100%. However, Smith et al. (1999) showed that low base rates for establishment of exotic species influence the reliability of predictive tools. In the field of biological control, using arthropods, the base rates are in fact quite high, at around 65% (Julien et al., 1984; Waterhouse & Sands, 2001). Nevertheless such a suboptimal base rate caps the maximum success rate for predictions below the accuracy that is estimated on the assumption that all introductions into suitable climates will be successful. Sutherst & Maywald (1985) stated a caveat that users of CLIMEX need to exclude non-climatic factors limiting the distribution before assuming that climate is the only factor. The CLIMEX model, or other climate-matching tools, do not pretend to predict the outcome of particular introduction events. They define the role of climate as a factor in determining the potential for establishment when all other factors are not included. In addition, the CLIMEX software includes a facility for comparing meteorological data from different places (Match Climates). Samways et al. also used this algorithm in their efforts to explain the outcomes of introductions. A comprehensive response to correct errors in Samways et al. would have required many weeks of literature reviews and re-calculations of their analysis of each species, which was not practical. Rather, I point out examples of the main types of factual and methodological errors, inappropriate assumptions and omissions in the paper and show why the results of their analyses are invalid and their conclusions are not logical. I then investigate re-fitting of the parameter values of the CLIMEX model for one species –C. cacti (Linnaeus 1767) – to illustrate how the modelling is recommended to be carried out. Before proceeding further, we need to distinguish between the CLIMEX model and the CLIMEX software package. The software contains two distinct functions: first, a species-specific response model (CLIMEX), which can be run in either 'Compare Locations' or 'Compare Years' modes. For present purposes we need only to be concerned with the former mode in which the suitability of different geographical locations for a given species is compared, based on long-term average meteorological data. Secondly, the software contains an algorithm, 'Match Climates', for simply comparing meteorological data at different locations. A brief outline of the CLIMEX model is necessary to explain the deficiencies in the Samways et al. paper. Sutherst & Maywald (1985) gave the original description of the model. Since then many other features, insights and caveats have been described by Maywald & Sutherst (1991), Sutherst et al. (1995, 1996, 1999, 2000), Sutherst (1998, 2000a, 2001) and Yonow & Sutherst (1998). The software has been used extensively in the fields of biological control, climate change and pest risk assessment with positive results in many countries. A list of c. 150 citations is provided at: http://www.ento.csiro.au/climex/climex.html. Samways et al. seem to be unaware of the considerable CLIMEX literature. The CLIMEX model is designed to extract maximum information on the response of a species to climate out of minimal field data. It derives weekly and annual indices that describe the responses of a nominated species to temperature and moisture, and light in the case of plants. The model is based on a conceptual model that there are two types of seasons each year – one with population growth and the other with population decline (Fig. 1). These are referred to as growth and survival or stress seasons, respectively. A population has to be able to survive during the stressful season, with its negative effects on population density, in order to exist at the start of the favourable season (unless it is a migratory species). In practice there are exceptions to this rule in small regions of the world, such as East Africa where there are two stressful (dry) seasons. They need additional interpretation of CLIMEX seasonal results. The overall climatic suitability of a nominated location for a given organism is provided by an 'Ecoclimatic Index' (EI, scaled from 0 to 100), which combines the annual potential for population growth with the annual stress. As the EI is an aggregate measure, it alone is inadequate to explain an organism's response to climate. The model parameter values for growth and stress constitute the description of the organism's response to climate and, as such, they represent the hypotheses to be tested. Testing demands that, like any mathematical model, the parameter values are published so that the results can be repeated and the values challenged and refined as further observations become available. Schematic diagram showing the year conceptually divided into two seasons, one for population growth and one for survival of stressful climatic conditions, when using the CLIMEX model. CLIMEX incorporates a hydrological model to integrate the effects of rainfall and evaporation into a 'moisture index', which describes the availability of soil moisture to plants or animals. The index is then combined with a temperature response curve to produce weekly and annual 'Growth Indices' (GIW and GIA, respectively, with the former scaled between 0 and 1 and the latter between 0 and 100). Any suboptimal weekly values of either temperature or moisture reduce the values of the growth index from its potential. This point is particularly pertinent to the current critique. Extreme values and duration of temperature and moisture limit the survival of populations, and so set the ultimate bounds of the potential geographical range as determined by climate. In CLIMEX, their effects are described by four annual 'Stress Indices': wet, dry, cold and hot, that estimate the threat to that species posed by prolonged or intensely extreme periods of adverse conditions, and their interactions where appropriate. The weekly values of each stress index are accumulated using a nonlinear function to give an annual value. If that value exceeds 100, the species is deemed not to be able to persist in that environment. The EI gives an overall measure of the suitability of a given location for permanent occupation by a species. It is therefore a measure that is both species-specific and location-specific, and implies that establishment is only possible when the value exceeds zero. In practice, with variable seasons, values of EI < 10 indicate that the location is marginal for the species and large annual fluctuations in numbers are likely. A location can only have a perfect suitability for a species (EI = 100) if it provides ideal conditions throughout the year for that species. We saw above how the year can be divided into favourable and stressful seasons. One consequence of this assumption is that in temperate regions or other regions with distinct wet and dry seasons, the maximum achievable value of the EI is likely to be around 50. In practice, values in excess of 20 have been found to support substantial population densities and values in excess of 50 are rare and usually confined to the wet tropics. CLIMEX analyses usually require that a species climatic requirements are inferred from information on its known geographical distribution, relative abundance and seasonal phenology. This 'top-down' procedure is called 'inverse' or 'inferential' modelling and it is the reverse of the reductionist approach usually used to build mechanistic models. Where laboratory data are available, they can be used to bolster the model fitting process or to explain the processes. The aim is to capture the core features of the species climatic requirements from minimal observations, not to describe the population dynamics in detail. CLIMEX analyses have proved very illuminating even with species that have been studied intensively. This is partly because CLIMEX starts with the geographical distribution, which is the result of the integration of the influences of all the factors affecting the life cycle. The model is designed to mimic the integration of all the climatic influences on populations at each location. Given the huge range of possible, seasonal permutations of temperature and moisture associated with locations spread across geographical space (Sutherst, 1998), the fitting process is, in fact, very demanding of the model. In order to function on a global scale, the parameter values of a CLIMEX model for a given species need to be valid over a very wide range of values of temperature and moisture. These demands partly explain why the results can be quite robust. In contrast, with a reductionist approach, it is difficult to define limiting climatic factors over a useful range of parameter values. Thus both reductionist and inferential modelling approaches have strengths and weaknesses, and they complement each other in ecological investigations. Indeed, I never start a fresh ecological study (or overseas travel) without doing a CLIMEX analysis first, because it provides such a useful geographical and climatic context, within which site-specific observations can be more readily interpreted (Sutherst, 2001). Two of Sutherst & Maywald's (1985) caveats on the CLIMEX model in relation to the process of inferring climatic responses from geographical distributions are pertinent to the current discussion. The first is that the process can only define climatic limits if the original distribution covers a sufficiently large and/or heterogeneous area. This is needed to provide the necessary range of possible temperature and moisture values for fitting parameters. If the original distribution is very much restricted, perhaps through historical lack of opportunities to migrate for example, or does not cover a sufficiently heterogeneous area, there is little alternative but to leave some limits undefined or to estimate them from other information. For example, Mediterranean climates do not expose species to hot-wet conditions, so the ability of species from those areas to survive such conditions in summer rainfall areas is not definable a priori, but it can be assumed – as a working hypothesis – that they will be poorly adapted to them. Where irrigation is practiced in such environments, it can provide some insights into the likely response of the species to summer rainfall. The second caveat relates to any assumption that climate alone limits the geographical distribution. Naturally, that is not the case because biological or other physical factors reduce the population growth and so may prevent the species from occupying the whole area that is climatically suitable for it, referred to as the fundamental niche (Hutchinson, 1957/8). Sutherst & Maywald (1985) gave an example of how most of sub-Saharan Africa is climatically suitable for the Asian livestock tick (Boophilus microplus), but its ability to invade the region has been impeded by unstable interspecific interactions with the local species, B. decoloratus (Koch) (Sutherst, 1987) and low movement rates. Since that time B. microplus has invaded large areas in southern Africa and Tanzania, as movement restrictions on cattle have been relaxed, allowing an increase in the propagule pressure that is needed to overcome the barrier provided by B. decoloratus (Sutherst, 2001). Gutierrez (2000) described the seasonal growth index of Fitzpatrick & Nix (1970), which was adapted by Sutherst & Maywald (1985) and incorporated into the CLIMEX model. He also discussed the physiological basis of the growth index concept, and applications of a tri-trophic (plant/herbivore/predator) growth index approach to impact assessments under climate change. However, there is scope for confusion with the CLIMEX model because the model described by Gutierrez was confined to the description of population growth during the favourable season, not to survival during the adverse season. The absence of growth was taken as an inability to survive without any description of the mechanism or cause of mortality involved. This differs fundamentally from the core CLIMEX 'stress' functions for estimating limiting factors when predicting geographical distributions. These stress functions attempt to mimic the biological processes that limit species in extreme climatic conditions. Instead Gutierrez used modified climograms (Cook, 1925) based on seasonal patterns of growth indices in different habitats to delimit the climatic range of a species. A second major difference is that Fitzpatrick & Nix (1970) and Gutierrez (2000) approached the use of growth indices using a physiological, reductionist approach. In contrast, the real power of the CLIMEX model, in the present context, is the application of an inverse or inferential modelling approach. The 'data' is the geographical distribution and any field observations on relative abundance in different seasons. The model fitting process works in reverse to infer what climatic processes determine that distribution. This is necessary when appropriate experimental data are not available, which is usually the case for all but the most intensively studied species. CLIMEX is based on 'the art of the possible', referred to by Worner (1991) as a pragmatic approach. I urge users to 'listen to CLIMEX' when fitting model parameters, rather than force parameter values from laboratory studies into the model. Once the iterative process has provided one or more adequate descriptions or explanations of the geographical distribution of the species, the parameter values are examined for insights into the species responses to climate. These can form the basis for more informed experimental research. Forcing a physiological approach onto the model fitting process is a two-edged sword, in that it can strengthen the description of some processes, but it is at the risk of over-riding some epidemiological processes that are occurring in the field. Consistency between the results from using both approaches increases confidence in the interpretation of the physiological processes limiting a species geographical distribution. The second function in the CLIMEX software package is 'Match Climates'. This function is designed simply to compare meteorological data from different locations. That is often the only option available, for example when targeting collection sites for searches of new, as yet unidentified biological control agents that will be adapted to the climate at the proposed destination. We refer to the Match Climates function as the poor man's option, because it addresses the situation where no knowledge is available on the distribution of the species and it therefore provides much less intelligent information than the CLIMEX model. The function generates a climate Match Index, MI (unfortunately with the same acronym as the Moisture Index in the CLIMEX simulation model above and since changed to CMI). The index is analogous to a correlation coefficient but it is scaled to make it more sensitive to small deviations in the range of interest, i.e. 0.6–1.0. Based on past experience, values of MI < 0.60 indicate poor matches between locations, with the potential for significantly different limiting effects of some variables in some of the locations. Hence, as a rule-of-thumb only, similarities of this order or less are not considered to be promising in terms of finding well-adapted species to introduce into the matching location. A number of caveats are necessary when using the function. Sutherst et al. (2000) emphasized the need to support the index with visual assessment of the data to see whether deviations between locations were positive or negative. Deviations from a given location in the direction of a species range boundary will give opposite conclusions to deviations in the direction of the core of the species climatic envelope, as illustrated schematically in Fig. 2. While the climates at the extremities of the circle at points B and C have the same (Match to the location with a B is more favourable for the species C is Thus there is an in the index when with the geographical distribution which is under where the geographical distribution is Schematic of the between the range of a CLIMEX Match Climates index and a geographical distribution of a species in the A. the distribution of the species point it, both locations the same CLIMEX Match In addition, a climate that has a annual range of temperature and moisture parameters, and is more may have a poor when with the climate of areas where the species & For example, it is possible to have a very low value of MI when comparing locations with temperate because the former climate may represent ideal summer conditions for a species that in the temperate (Sutherst et al., One such example is the success of of in the of A of the meteorological data of the two regions gives a very low MI value because there is no in the potential for population growth of a temperate species in the is to a summer in a temperate region with no of the These features of climatic that are using Match all other that are used to compare the CLIMEX model above and et al., which do not on of meteorological data & 2001). They that be taken when them. Samways et al. used the CLIMEX Match Climates function to compare the climates of with of the fifteen species of They Sutherst & Maywald as that is the value below which an introduction of a species is to such in the paper. has been stated is that that a value of is the that is usually & This is an and it is quite inappropriate to use it as Samways et al. (1999) to areas where their species were to be able to They a value of MI = to locations in which establishment of introductions was from those in which the species of the caveats referred to above were taken into In they of a location for species and survival were determined using the of As the Match Climates function does not to a species, it that they inferred that locations with climatic within the range of would support the species. If the MI is to it a of but that does not whether the deviations from the climate of the location are more or less suitable for any given species. the need for when using values as low as to infer of climates for a particular species. CLIMEX modelling to determine the potential range, on the assumption that all other non-climatic are Thus Samways et use of the 'percent correct predictions of establishment' of particular introductions to test their hypothesis that the range can be determined using climate alone was inappropriate in light of the rule & a success rate of c. in predicting the outcomes of introductions by with data and a model as they on to that the range cannot always be determined by and so predictions of range change with climate change are likely to be wrong'. This is not a The outcome of a particular introduction cannot be with the species range. The of particular introductions of a species to in a new area does not that the climate is a suitable climate does not This is why the practice of biological control on propagule pressure to that there is a of to in the of from such factors as native or & 1987) or poor & from errors, it is from the description of Samways et and results that they the model and used an inappropriate The consequence is that their analyses are so and that their results and conclusions are It is difficult to the process that Samways et al. used to estimate the CLIMEX model parameter values from their description of the the they a number of apparently They stated that 'the were determined by estimating climatic to maximum and and rainfall based on the that species is at model from 0 to Any indices above determined for were considered here to be a of the model for the species was if the EI and were both or and MI the Match Climates was or The of a location for species and survival were determined using the of CLIMEX, and the were determined for all The model, assumes that all species are sensitive to the same climatic the value was taken to be as as that for the distribution of the species EI at or above which was the value at which the species geographical ranges These to be the main of the As as it is possible to from this description of the it that the conditions for growth were In addition, the limiting effects of extreme climatic conditions, as described by the CLIMEX stress do not to have been taken into when fitting the model to the geographical distribution of each species, there is one to them. As of the model parameter values for any of the species was in the their values not be The combined of success using both the EI and values are a as the EI incorporates the information from the The additional of the MI has a on the measure of success by what be species-specific information with information. We saw above how the year can be divided conceptually into favourable and stressful seasons and how it means that the maximum achievable value of the EI is likely to be around 50 in most regions of the world with either a cold or dry season. Samways et al. examples where both the annual and the EI Indeed, in their they EI = with a = for and EI = with = for to give the to the model. In their the and EI values for each location are to each that there is no stress incorporated into the model. As the EI is a of the and the stress it is not possible for the value of EI to that of the not only are the values of EI by Samways et al. high, the used to define a to the (EI MI are In practice there is no why the EI in the area of not have been as low as which is to support substantial population densities (Sutherst & Maywald, The that Samways et al. used to define a to the area of demonstrates that they not the model. In addition, as a low Match Climates MI does not indicate that the matching location is for a given species. CLIMEX of the potential geographical distribution of the Chilocorus cacti (Linnaeus in and using a low temperature stress model. The of in each 50 is to the estimated climatic suitability of the area. The areas by Fig. 1 in Samways et al. (1999) as the geographical are as with CLIMEX with a cold stress model and 1 for CLIMEX of the potential global distribution of the Chilocorus cacti (Linnaeus The of each 50 is to the climatic suitability of the area, estimated using the cold stress model. locations where the has successfully or was the range in Fig. 1 of Samways et al. A of the provided by Samways et Fig. of the geographical of each species is the apparently or of the areas of of many of the and the lack of of species. to which this include: and This a that there is either a or that the distributions are defined or that non-climatic limiting factors are at For example, their (Fig. showed the geographical of cacti to be to the and southern areas of the with a large between them. This was not with the in their 1 to the of cacti as It is not which set of data they used to the CLIMEX parameters. were with some other species. I attempted to the CLIMEX to describe the ability of cacti to in the two environments of in southern
Source: Journal of Biogeography
Author: Robert W. Sutherst
Language: English
Subfield: Ecological Modeling
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Life on land
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2081915727
