Work

Driving Simulation Performance Predicts Future Accidents Among Older Drivers

Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: To the Editor: The number of automobile accidents per mile driven increases steadily each year beyond age 60.1 This is of concern for two reasons. First, older drivers incur greater physical injuries than younger drivers involved in similar accidents.2 Automobile crashes are the leading cause of death due to nonintentional injuries among individuals between the ages of 65 and 74.3 Second, the aging of our society will result in an increasing number of older drivers, such that 30% of the driving population will be older than the age of 55 by the year 2000,4 and 50 million drivers may be 65 years or older by the year 2020.5 In order to address these concerns, a procedure is needed that can assess driving ability and risk of future accidents reliably and accurately. If high-risk drivers can be identified, preferably before they are involved in an accident, it might be possible to assign high-risk drivers to a program that could identify specific driving decrements and then assist the driver in either correcting these decrements or compensating for them. If remediation is not a possibility for a particular individual, removal of the driving privilege may be necessary. Programs have been shown to take high risk older drivers and improve their driving abilities,6–7 but typically these interventions take place only after some driving infraction involving police intervention has occurred. What is needed is a driving assessment procedure that is sensitive, reliable, objective, and predictive of future driving accidents. Prediction of future driving accidents is difficult for several reasons. First, driving accidents are often a combination of bad driving and bad luck. Accidents result from bad driving only if there is something or somebody in the path of the errant driver. Second, older drivers are often aware of their compromised driving abilities and, therefore, reduce their risk by reducing their exposure by avoiding night driving, heavy traffic, inclement weather, etc.8 Computer technology in simulation has progressed tremendously in the recent past, allowing the realistic simulation and assessment of such varied activities as flying jets,9 operating tanks,10 driving locomotives,11 driving large trucks,12 and even playing squash.13 In collaboration with Atari Corporation, we have developed a realistic, fixed platform, three- screen driving simulator that differentiates older adults with and without Alzheimer's Disease,14 older-aged from middle-aged male drivers, and older drivers when sober and when intoxicated.15 Performance on this simulator has correlated with neuropsychological test performance among older drivers16 and has correlated with on-road driving performance of older adults.17 What has not been tested is whether driver performance on the simulator predicts occurrence of future accidents. We contacted 38 older people who 3 years previously had participated in a driving simulation study.18 Twenty of these drivers had scored above the 90th percentile (Low risk), and 18 had scored below the 10th percentile (High risk) on the driving simulator test. Demographic details appear in Table 1. During a brief telephone interview subjects were asked four questions: . Are you currently driving? . On average, how many miles a week do you drive? . How many automobile accidents have you had in the past 3 years? . What percentage of the time do you wear your seat belt? Table 1 summarizes these data. High- and Low-risk drivers were still driving, reported driving similar miles per week, reported using their seat belt equally as often, and had a similar gender distribution. However, the High-risk drivers reported having 47 crashes per 1,000,000 miles driven whereas the Low-risk drivers reported having six crashes per 1,000,000 miles (P = .04), and this was still significant when controlling for age (P = .035, 1-tailed). Interestingly, self-reported ability to drive was unrelated to either crash history or age. Although this study employed a small sample size and relied on self-report of past automobile crashes, it does support the idea that evaluation of the driving ability of older people on a driving simulator may be a useful future approach. Possibly of equal clinical significance, as seen in another study,14 is that the individual's self-appraisal of driving ability was unrelated to objective measures of driving ability (simulator performance and recent crash history). It is anticipated that further developments of driving simulation technology will occur that will enhance realism (e.g., motion) and simulation of a variety of high risk driving scenarios (e.g., at night, during rain and snow, on highways and rural and urban roads), with more sensitive driving performance measures (reaction times at sudden stop). With such refinements, greater predictability could be anticipated. If this is realized, healthcare providers may have a means to assess driving abilities before a tragedy occurs, much like risk of heart disease can be assessed by serum cholesterol tests.
Authors: Daniel J. Cox, Peter Taylor, Boris Kovatchev
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2082844582
FWCI: 1.708
Cites: 10
Cited by: 39
Related to: 10