Work

A Necessary Good: Nuclear Hormone Receptors and Their Chromatin Templates

Year: 2001
Type: review
Abstract: The eukaryotic genome is exquisitely responsive to a great variety of internal, developmental, and environmental stimuli and yet is most commonly visualized in packaged form: each 180 bp of DNA are bound to histones into a nucleosome, chains of nucleosomes coalesce into a necklace, and the necklace twists into a chromosome of undetermined structure that is somewhat inert in its regularity. This seeming conundrum is easily resolved in vivo, because, rather than treat the histones and chromatin as some pernicious obstacle that ought to be swept out of the way, eukaryotic transcriptional regulators clearly see a powerful ally in the nucleoprotein architecture of chromatin and make extensive use of its disruption, modification, and assembly to control the genome’s behavior. In this review, we focus on a well researched example of such a symbiosis: the intimate functional relationship that nuclear hormone receptors (NHRs) have with their chromatin templates. Its history in biological scholarship is a distinguished one and includes the pioneering study by Klever and Carlson (1) in the 1950s on the insect steroid hormone ecdysone that revealed a functional connection between hormone action, gene activation, and remodeling of chromatin, studies in the 1980s on the glucocorticoid receptor that took such analysis to a molecular level (2), and subsequent work in the 1990s from a number of laboratories that characterized the extraordinarily diverse spectrum of chromatin-modifying and -remodeling factors that partner with the NHRs to effect gene regulation (3). In this review, we address some textbook schematic-inspired misconceptions about the structure of the nucleosome and of chromatin that are relevant to transcriptional control and elaborate on the structural impediments created by chromatin for access to DNA by nonhistone factors. We highlight mechanisms whereby such NHRs as the glucocorticoid, estrogen, and thyroid hormone receptors overcome this impediment and present a hypothetical scenario for gene activation by NHRs in vivo. Various types of chromatin disruption and modification phenomena that occur in vivo and the chromatin-modifying machines thought to be responsible for such modifications are described. We list the evidence implicating such machines in NHR function and conclude by reviewing recent data that illuminate the remarkably dynamic nature of in vivo gene regulation by NHRs. The elementary particle of chromatin—the union of 8 molecules of core histone, 1 molecule of linker histone, and approximately 160 bp of DNA—is often represented as a featureless spool, the DNA’s thin thread winding around its surface. The inevitable oversimplification inherent in such textbook-style schematics creates three common misconceptions. 1. From a structural standpoint, the histone octamer is not a spool—a more adequate analogy would be to imagine DNA wound around a Rubik’s cube: a dynamic, pliable, internally nonhomogeneous particle (4). All four core histones, H2A, H2B, H3, and H4, contain a distinctive lysine- and arginine-rich COOH domain that forms a histone fold motif (an extended central α-helix flanked on either side by a loop and two shorter α-helices). Histones H3 and H4 heterodimerize via a handshake interaction of their histone fold motifs, and this dimer then associates with a second such entity to form an H3/H4 tetramer. In vivo, this particle is deposited onto nascent DNA by dedicated molecular chaperones (5, 6) and binds to approximately 130 bp of DNA. The resulting seminucleosome has interesting properties (7) immediately relevant to transcriptional regulation by NHRs (see below) and normally exists only on newly replicated DNA (i.e. when proliferating cells are in S phase). Histones H2A and H2B are added, by a distinct set of chaperones, to the DNA-bound (H3/H4)2, thus completing the assembly process and compacting approximately 146 bp of DNA (in the nucleosome, H2A and H2B also interact via a handshake). The x-ray crystal structure of the core histone octamer has been solved (8) and reveals the extended network of electrostatic and, surprisingly, hydrophobic interactions between the DNA and the octamer. 2. The junction between (H3/H4)2 and (H2A/H2B)2 is a delicate one, a feature most likely exploited not only in assembly (6), but also, possibly, in the disruption of chromatin by regulators (9). The consequences of such disruptions are not immediately apparent from thread on a spool drawings because they obscure the extraordinary structural stress that B-form DNA undergoes when assembled onto the histone octamer. The 1.7 turns made by DNA in a nucleosome feature the sharpest curvature of the DNA backbone that is thermodynamically feasible, coupled with an underwinding of the double helix (10); thus, the DNA is not complacently wound on the spool—it is extensively bent and twisted out of its familiar B-form shape. Thus, while the union of DNA and core histones in a structurally intact nucleosome is a stable one, is to disruptions modifications of the histone octamer that the the DNA a of to into a a with consequences (see of as well as an to present drawings from the nucleosome one of its and most structural the of the core to the domain that the DNA the histone for approximately of the of the nucleosome and are to of the core nucleosome, they to x-ray analysis Thus, while is about the two are the are and in extended form the core particle in they contain a of nucleosome of has a of the nucleosome is by In a of the nucleosome, an with the DNA wound around its in an of in the this be via of the we that eukaryotic that has been a number of histone of this and have extensive data such their functional histone of function transcriptional control by NHRs (3). The are as in NHRs make use of chromatin modification and disruption to effect gene is to regulators are to interact with their in the of (i.e. The twisted necklace drawings of chromatin an chromatin in some a and nucleoprotein a nonhistone access to its data are as to the interaction of NHRs with chromatin we that NHRs to their when they are assembled into are commonly to the in a DNA is assembled into The core histone octamer forms the most stable with approximately 146 bp of the of linker histone an approximately and about bp of DNA are with core This as creates an inherent in the the genome is bound into some are with core histones, and are in the The is to the are in a the of DNA to form nucleosomes in bound to histones is double while DNA in the linker is in is to that while some in the genome are with a of histone octamer on nucleosomes hypothetical is that 1 is a for a to and but and are not of the nucleosome is obstacle to the see is evidence that a number of transcriptional regulators that in eukaryotic with their in the of a for is the for the for a structural in the of the DNA by is with the structure of the DNA in the is by the well to its the in the of a nucleosome in the DNA is in a linker and with the DNA is on the of the nucleosome the is the on two the in the DNA is wound around the histones also has consequences for the of nonhistone regulators to access their the of the gene The of this DNA is a thyroid hormone receptor two by bp and in the form of a with the bound by the receptor and the bound by the thyroid hormone receptor The inevitable of winding DNA around a histone octamer is that the side of the histones, and some the thus a a of in the double helix to the octamer. for is the in three distinct in a are while in a that is the histones are the are in of NHRs is their to DNA in and in vivo in a of thus, NHRs only a in for their when they are with core glucocorticoid receptor with its on the in in and in vivo an is that the has to be such that the core for to DNA are for 1 and the to the while the a an of the NHR with its in and in vivo has been for on the for on the for receptor on the and for receptor on the is thought that the domain of one NHR molecule the that on the of the and the second molecule of the receptor in the dimer some inevitable of in the of for NHRs and in the of NHRs is not that the structural of the DNA the nucleosome to distinct of of on when the of the is the nucleosome is likely that the two double of DNA that into of the nucleosome also to such via The have the of transcriptional control by receptor receptor and in in with receptor on chromatin templates. are not is to chromatin, and nuclear is to the with transcriptional an and in the and a of receptor on chromatin (see the of receptor interaction with a The NHR bound to the has a molecular of approximately to that of a core histone a common NHR thyroid is an of as most of the and in NHR the receptors that for a the for and thyroid hormone the chromatin remodeling and the and are well 1 in molecular with the DNA-bound the factors and the an and form an entity that the in and is that a scenario be that for the of would be a of the of the NHRs in transcriptional The is on studies from a number of laboratories and from structural and functional studies on the gene the the gene and the gene 1. The receptor its in the either to an (see to nucleosome to the DNA that such a to the receptor to the of a that the of a a in the of DNA when chromatin is assembled and the nascent DNA is in an (5, 2. when in the that effect transcriptional of chromatin also an with an undetermined that is not of the NHR an chromatin remodeling that in the of the receptor a such to the of a of chromatin in the DNA is more to factors than DNA in The receptor on and the DNA while the in to the of factors the that on the transcriptional The as well as that this In to NHRs also that the transcriptional and are also in transcriptional activation by regulators We recent in of some of of gene regulation by NHRs. In to NHRs and that are in the in the of some and are is to have some effect on the of of is a of chromatin and is that the for exists as to the stable by of gene in the of of such receptor in the biological function of thyroid hormone and as of and is thought that and that are for of this and that a of transcriptional and a in and its have a well in such as but is not to as a transcriptional exists with the NHR in the ecdysone that an function in insect The in are with a but evidence from studies of of and in are with this and as transcriptional on and studies with in that such occur on DNA for with for by and when two receptor and of obscure work from laboratories the that the transcriptional associates with the histone via the molecule This a connection between transcriptional and the modification of is to that a relationship between of and transcriptional of by then been well for of chromatin to be while the in to be Thus, to that the of chromatin to transcriptional in evidence that and interact with and that with to a in a hypothetical of the with by the NHR to in the of in vivo with the by to some the hypothetical in vivo in with NHRs of with to transcriptional by most associates with in vivo also to be that NHRs to for while the to transcriptional of a by this in the of the receptor the and the hypothetical with the that on to the hypothetical by stable of by has been to in vivo while for such in are of via of by be data the of a hypothetical in transcriptional by NHRs. the of two to an in cells the that to with this The of and that are not in this are not with either of and to and its the an with and Thus, the present the of an in vivo between and NHR a of this hypothetical entity in NHR function are the and are of analysis a in is to stable in this entity histone between and also in as well as in a distinct to cells than have been to and but evidence is as to are relevant to NHR In the has been in by NHRs by of In one of its the (see transcriptional by when an of that to also to to In associates with and with thyroid hormone transcriptional by and between the receptor and of by in such to by the to on the of of rather than to by NHRs is by the of on functional between their are than into the by the from In interesting to the a spectrum of histone for (see with The by of in is an interesting one, because this to be more than its in histones assembled into nucleosomes have functional for when associates with nascent DNA in the of DNA common that a variety of types in the such newly replicated chromatin is assembled by molecular chaperones that histones onto DNA in The nucleosomes are into a about by on bound by such transcriptional be by of evidence that transcriptional by is via an as well as an eukaryotic transcriptional for for be to a connection between in data that with function and in vivo of the and in the is a of evidence that transcriptional by NHRs to histone such data are only for transcriptional that in chromatin is an powerful and that has on of function in is the of and the in of histone are likely to in the of a and on this that is that and transcriptional via not is for that some structural feature of the DNA-bound NHR to the of the into a nuclear an that a chromatin remodeling and functional recent work a and connection between and chromatin when a 1 as a stable of a This is for two in have been in in and evidence in in from a standpoint, has the to histone a of the transcriptional its in via the assembly of a is to that when bound to in proliferating chromatin is by DNA and gene activation is more likely than in transcriptional by as well as the assembly of chromatin by with the histones via the of the and their via of chromatin in transcriptional activation by NHRs only a would have been a one would the of with the and the of a the the subsequent by factors such as and on the that interactions with the in the of In the of and the of on the also the most and, in some the well This from two in the of transcriptional of in NHR to a in a in this this (3). of chromatin, is to see that the eukaryotic is with and -remodeling but such not easily to into In to be a between of of such machines in and of in vivo structural and functional consequences of their In we have evidence that the assembly of into chromatin and the to NHR action, but the of such a between chromatin and the receptors are only in the types of chromatin disruption and modification that occur in vivo and also the that NHR by such in chromatin structure We on of NHR on chromatin templates. is to make a between the two types of chromatin structure disruption that occur in vivo and are to be with transcriptional activation by NHRs. The is often and to a in the of chromatin in a nucleosome, a structural The is the of a of DNA that is more to its is a in vivo is that such remodeling by NHRs via the of In the of the is a In powerful data that gene via a and chromatin remodeling is to be In is not remodeling in vivo In the has a variety of the of nucleosomes to access to DNA and the of histone octamer to the DNA is the and nucleosomes in in structure to the entity that is revealed in vivo as a thus, while NHRs are to effect such remodeling their in such a that well to be analysis of eukaryotic a number of chromatin remodeling machines of contain a core as of is evidence to gene regulation in vivo in than in of a has not been and have been to in the that such remodeling in vivo, is to that such a disruption is not a for gene activation and that transcriptional remodeling some responsive for the gene not a in chromatin structure transcriptional the of the histone octamer while that the octamer is subsequent in studies that of the DNA in some with the octamer and that factors and histones the nucleosome of chromatin structure in vivo that with histones and for and is that the of the octamer in the of the is to mechanisms of transcriptional to hormone (see the receptor on and the DNA and of DNA by a nonhistone is to histone from its somewhat to a analysis of chromatin structure the to the of two studies that this is assembled into an of and one of on its the glucocorticoid to the in chromatin in this is assembled into but that some are more common than see thus, data the of a chromatin because the data that a common is that in vivo, nucleosome to from one to and that the receptor then that a in are in a a study on interaction with the in the of to chromatin not only around its but in the thus, a on the that a thought to be in the regulation of by the be of great to such is a of chromatin in a via a a remodeling that effect the of chromatin into a of in the by into a of by The the of histone to the of the the and the The the of as by The of the each to its for some the is in to the The visualized on from from the nucleosome in this DNA data in and is on 8 in that of in the by into a of by The the of histone to the of the the and the The the of as by The of the each to its for some the is in to the The visualized on from from the nucleosome in this DNA data in and is on 8 in that only the its nucleosome, we that the remodeling by is not a while the more to and the of this DNA is than one nucleosome but shorter than two such a on DNA molecules and is not a of from two nucleosomes that in the are thought to to this are to the nature of the remodeling is that some feature of (8) is by the by The second of chromatin structure disruption that in vivo is commonly to as the core histones are the of modifications the most of is the of the by and by transcriptional in powerful data that a between histone and transcriptional for the is for of this is on the of as a to the of histones and the of in histone via their to a the for in transcriptional activation is to that the between of and level of transcriptional not for with has rather to transcriptional activation by on the and data from and also to an for in gene activation In most with and with contain a number of and a variety of evidence with in of to by NHRs (3). In vivo evidence for a of in transcriptional activation by NHRs with some the of to thyroid hormone in from in the domain of analysis that of the to such as steroid receptor In powerful of of the gene for in to to thyroid hormone in the to in an in with chromatin and such by use of the be of great to the of by NHRs in such in to of chromatin on a to that by that to in assembled chromatin This be because of a between the of such NHR as to histones H3 and H4 with the that in vivo, a in the of histone H4, while such in histone H3 are rather is that than NHR that the of histone H4 is not only by but of NHR for H4 is to in proliferating cells In are to have nonhistone and of the is that in of such also for some of the transcriptional of NHRs. The of evidence the of to NHRs is by of of chromatin to transcriptional to some this is to a of structural about the histone In data have that of chromatin by and recent evidence from to this NHRs are not to their with is that the they are to transcriptional have been and in most that a nucleosome is more to by nonhistone transcriptional regulators has been to this in vivo, in because NHRs not only but also the also of DNA to nonhistone a of the two to data in and in vivo on the a of for the of responsive to this an that is the of a nucleosome, and a bound the of nucleosome approximately bp (i.e. two nucleosome see the stable and of two nucleosomes is likely to properties of the DNA to its on the of the octamer and, a in to of the gene that remodeling to that the not occur on this an the of such that with to of histones H3 and H4 nucleosomes in with this chromatin modification, the and in with while not access its in the when assembled in into chromatin an in with chromatin of to the on the of a nucleosome of on a chromatin the that nonhistone are responsible for access data in and a to data in to transcriptional of in vivo. of with the a loop by a nucleosome interactions between DNA-bound and the transcriptional the a nucleosome from the histone the binds to four the are in linker DNA and on the of and chromatin assembly of the of with the a loop by a nucleosome interactions between DNA-bound and the transcriptional the a nucleosome from the histone the binds to four the are in linker DNA and on the of and chromatin assembly of the interesting of chromatin disruption in when of chromatin by the in the of chromatin remodeling the and histone chaperones the that by an of the from the nucleosome to the histone (9). not a H3/H4 on the this an interesting on studies of (H3/H4)2 with DNA to this entity is remarkably DNA in of to nonhistone regulators and Thus, is that remodeling of and of histones by to a more of chromatin disruption that be by either is to that of the disruption, modification in that have been in vivo in NHR in the of DNA. In are well the of on the and the of on the on the in the assembly of DNA into chromatin NHR function this not only by the transcriptional but also by the with properties that be on DNA example is the regulation of the by and on (i.e. not such factors as and access to the such and the in are on NHRs and NHRs and is likely that the transcriptional regulation by NHRs with functional properties that are not of in in in the study of transcriptional control are on a of common phenomena that have not been to of are not with a of but rather are by to occur in a most with common such are by more and are to an of in vivo of in cells an interesting of the between common and the of is to study the of the interaction of NHRs with their a to be with to transcriptional of their and while has been to this in in in an intact not to In most that interactions with in vivo with chromatin that an of a for the of molecules by a nonhistone is to a in vivo from chromatin to the of bound by a a is a that has yet to be In a has to on a of the of interactions in chromatin of cells The obstacle of overcome by a that in approximately of a in the is to the gene this and has been to chromosome in vivo for a to then into the genome the control of an this control the of NHR and, via the use of the of is in cells revealed a structure in the to the of as by in The of between bound to its and in the then two that have been to the of phenomena in and in In a is a in the (in this the and for a of of in the only occur molecules the from in the by the of is to the of In to of stable by of as as be and in of the molecules bound to the NHR molecules by data that DNA-bound undergoes and with its DNA in a of transcriptional activation powerful evidence to that effect in the and approximately the This and on by and on the of that occur transcriptional activation of the in functional analogy to regulation by in the activation of this gene is on a DNA-bound the of a chromatin remodeling and the subsequent of a chromatin in cells that the on the for a of and from the DNA approximately the as the then for 1 thus, of has been is the of this and functional to the data to address either by of is that remodeling of from the DNA the that via on the on the histones the the in for binds to and such is by chromatin assembly the structural of DNA that more to the of to the disruption of chromatin around the receptor and is to a that has for the receptor (i.e. to receptor with an in that regulation by on a chromatin that in the of but not chromatin the The of to chromatin remodeling coupled with an of DNA the receptor in with the for for the functional of such a of NHR is in the of The to to is that the of from the DNA is responsible for this In is stable in the of than in its is to be a of by the an example of a of by is for that such NHR from the DNA as by studies of and to a more of NHRs for and to a more of to The study of NHR on chromatin in a of great and in the when in and in vivo in that The of such is an one, the of data from most the genome and of the and and for for analysis of NHR regulation and in one to We and for and for in vivo We the for and in by analysis of in that in vivo as a transcriptional for to effect of in a to that by are the data on a in they an on in studies that is a transcriptional for such NHRs as and
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2085451506
FWCI: 1.028
Cites: 169
Cited by: 66
Related to: 10