Work

An Exercise in Geometry

Year: 2002
Type: review
Abstract: "To get back my youth I would do anything in the world, except take exercise… . " Oscar Wilde The Picture of Dorian Gray, Chapter 19 IN THIS ISSUE of the Journal, Petit et al.1 report the structural changes accompanying exercise during growth.1 During 7 months, 43 pre- and 43 early-pubertal girls, mean age 10-10.5 years, were exercised for 10 minutes three times weekly using a jumping program of gradually increasing intensity. Changes in these two intervention groups were compared with changes in 25 pre- and 63 early-pubertal controls matched by age, sitting height, leg length, and lean and fat mass from a different school. Structural changes occurred in all groups. However, in the prepubertal group (Tanner stage 1), the changes in the intervention group were no greater than in controls. In the early pubertal group (Tanner stages 2 and 3), the changes in femoral neck bone cross-sectional area (CSA), cortical thickness, and section modulus (a measure of bending and torsional strength) in the intervention group were greater than in controls. The study raises many issues regarding the rationale, hypothesis, design, execution, analysis, and interpretation of clinical trials of exercise during growth. About 30-50% of women and 15-20% of men will suffer the consequences of fractures related to osteoporosis.2 Drugs reduce fracture risk by about 40-50% in the subgroup of women at highest risk, that is, women with osteoporosis.3 However, at least 50-75% of all fractures in the community come from the larger segment of the population at mild or moderate risk due to modest deficits in areal bone mineral density (aBMD) or younger age.4 This distribution of event rates is well recognized in the cardiovascular field but underemphasized and poorly appreciated in the field of bone metabolism because of our obsession with fracture "thresholds." Although persons with aBMD reduced by more than 2.5 SD below the young normal mean are at highest risk, this represents only a small proportion of the whole population, most of whom have aBMD above −2.5 SD. Thus, the population burden of fractures and events like stroke or myocardial infarction come from the larger population, not from the tail end of the population distribution containing the high risk group but smaller numbers of individuals.5 The public health burden of fractures cannot be solved with drugs, because drug trials have been done largely in women at highest fracture risk due to osteoporosis—those women with aBMD in the tail end of the population distribution (aBMD < −2.5 SD below the young normal mean). The risk of events such as fractures, strokes, and myocardial infarction is low in the larger segment of the population; to prevent one morbid event, large numbers need to be exposed to the costs of medical care, inconveniences, and side effects of drug therapy at no benefit whatsoever. The cost of treatment using this approach is greater than the cost of fractures.6 We can reduce fracture risk in the subgroup of high risk individuals (case-finding), but they contribute only 25-50% of all fractures in the population. The solution to the public health burden of fractures remains an enigma, particularly as more and more of us are living longer to enjoy the fruits of old age. Thus, nondrug related interventions are needed to reduce the population burden of fractures. For these population-based approaches to be successful, several criteria must be fulfilled. The interventions must be efficacious, safe, accessible to all, easily carried out, and inexpensive to implement. If it were possible to move the population distribution of the structural determinants of bone strength just a few percentage points using an intervention applied to the whole population, there is likely to be a profound benefit on the population burden of fractures.5 Of all the modifiable lifestyle factors that influence the skeleton, such as nutrition, tobacco use, and exercise, it is exercise during growth that has the potential to fulfill all these criteria and therefore could reduce the public health burden of fractures. The answer to this question is unknown. Inferences regarding the anti-fracture efficacy of exercise will never be based on the highest level of experimental evidence. There will obviously never be a double-blind trial of exercise. There will almost certainly never be a randomized open trial of exercise during growth or aging with fragility fractures in old age as an endpoint; the sample sizes needed to show a biologically worthwhile fracture risk reduction are similar to those needed in industry funded drug trials. Issues of design, compliance and funding almost certainly make these trials too difficult to execute successfully. The firm belief held by many that exercise reduces fracture risk is derived from lower levels of evidence—retrospective and prospective observational cohort and case-control studies that suggest active persons have fewer fractures than less active persons.7-9 This inference may be correct, but these studies are subject to systematic healthy user bias and should be evaluated with skepticism and interpreted cautiously.7 Healthier individuals may choose to be more active and are less prone to falls and fractures. Persons inheriting a larger musculo-skeletal size have higher bone mass and lower fracture risk before starting exercise. The exercise may be a consequence of the larger musculo-skeletal mass rather than the larger musculo-skeletal mass being a consequence of the exercise. There is no strength in numbers. Meta-analyses of observational studies examining efficacy should not even be under taken, much less interpreted. At very best, they are hypothesis generating, not hypothesis testing. Recall the iconoclastic impact of the first randomized double-blind trial examining the effect of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) on cardiac events, and the more recently reported negative results concerning cerebrovascular morbidity and mortality using HRT.10, 11 One or two properly conducted studies shatter the dogma created by meta-analysis after meta-analysis of observational studies that claim HRT reduces cardiovascular events. Thus, we are forced to make inferences within the constraints of the uncertainty imposed by even lower levels of evidence—the effect of exercise on surrogates of anti-fracture efficacy such as changes in bone mass, structure and derived measures of bone strength. These endpoints also have limitations that should be acknowledged. For example, a change in aBMD in response to drug therapy is a poor surrogate of the reduction in fracture risk.12 What then are the effects of exercise on the surrogates of anti-fracture efficacy? There is little replicated and methodologically sound evidence to suggest that exercise during young adulthood, peri-menopause, late adulthood, or old age modifies bone size, prevents bone loss, or restores bone mass, architecture, or strength. Consistency in results is lacking; some studies suggest bone loss is prevented by exercise and others suggest bone loss is not prevented or is increased.7-9, 13 The increase in aBMD of a few percentage points reported in some studies is probably due to a reduction in the size of the reversible remodeling space.14 There is little, if any, evidence of changes in bone tissue mass beyond that produced by reducing the remodeling space. There is no evidence that exercise in adults increases cortical thickness by increasing periosteal apposition, reducing endocortical resorption, or increasing endocortical bone formation. Whether exercise reduces intracortical porosity, increases trabecular thickness, connectivity or the mineral content of the matrix tissue mass (regrettably called "true" density), is not known. When exercise is stopped, bone loss accelerates,15 probably due to an increase in the size of the reversible remodeling space. Exercise during adulthood may reduce the risk and severity of falls, but evidence that this translates into fewer fractures is lacking.7 It is during growth that exercise produces its most beneficial effects. Growth is the single most opportune time to modify the mass and geometry of the skeleton.16-24 The studies of vigorous exercise during growth provide evidence that large increments in aBMD can be achieved in loaded compared with unloaded regions of the skeleton. High impact loading in gymnastics, weight lifting, and racket sports is associated with high regional aBMD. Differences of 1-3 SD are often reported in the playing arm compared with nonplaying arm in racket sports, increments that are an order of magnitude higher than produced by exercise in adults. These changes are the result of distinct structural changes in bone mass, size, and geometry, not just small changes in the remodeling space. The region specific differences in playing versus nonplaying arm cannot be the result of sampling bias or genetic factors so that this data provides one of the few "facts" in the bone field that is not controversial—vigorous competitive loading exercise during growth is good for bone. All of this is hardly new. The original study comparing bone mass and structure of the playing and nonplaying arms of racket sports was published about 20 years ago.17 The results have never been challenged on methodological grounds and have been replicated several times.20-23 The skeleton adapts remarkably to local loading during growth by changing its size, shape, architecture, and mass. These changes are likely to produce biologically worthwhile differences in the bending, compressive, and torsional strength of bone that may well be the solution to the problem of fractures in old age, provided the changes can be maintained during the next six or seven decades of life. There are subtle issues in study design that need to be considered before the greater changes reported in an exercise compared with a control group can be legitimately inferred to be the result of the group differences in exercise (rather than being due to group differences in many other factors). Petit et al.1 studied an intervention group of prepubertal and early pubertal girls matched with a control group by age, pubertal maturation, sitting height, leg length, and lean and fat mass. The authors are to be congratulated for this attention to design. Why? These baseline characteristics may influence the outcome independent of the exercise. A small difference in baseline characteristics in an exercise and control group, even 2 to 3 months in age or pubertal maturation, can produce large changes. If controls are more advanced in maturity, and so are about to move into an accelerated phase of growth, then any benefit of exercise in the other, less mature group, will be obscured by the accelerated growth in controls. The investigator will falsely infer that exercise had no benefit. If the exercise group is more maturationally advanced, then the changes in the exercise group will be greater than the changes in the controls due to both the maturational difference and any independent benefit exercise may produce. This may have occurred in a 10-month study of exercise reported by Morris et al.24 Bone mineral content (BMC) and bone area increased 2- to 8-fold more rapidly in the exercise than control group; large differences in growth rate better explained by a combination of differences in maturational progression and exercise, than differences in exercise alone. Studies in which the participants are not confined to a single gender or racial/ethnic group also create difficulties in interpretation. Males and females of the same age differ by maturational status. If they are matched by maturational status, they will usually differ by age. The rate of maturational development may differ according to racial/ethnic group.25 About 30% of the participants in the study by Petit et al.1 were Asian. Although the data were not analyzed according to racial/ethnic group, in an earlier study of white and Asian girls and boys, these authors reported that the increase in total body and trochanteric aBMD was greater in the Asians than whites, and greater in the girls than boys.26 In another study by these investigators, baseline exercise levels were lower in Asians than whites.27 Whether the race- or gender- specific aBMD responses to exercise reflects race- and gender- specific differences in maturational rate, baseline differences in usual exercise (which may influence the response to exercise), or true race- and gender- specific responses to loading is not clear. The difficulties in interpreting observations made in heterogenous samples comprising males and females of different racial/ethnic origin are not solved by reporting that baseline differences are "not significant." Lack of statistical significance is assured by small sample sizes of males and females, different ethnic groups, and wide ranges in age, height, and weight in the exercise and control groups. The importance of maturational stage is highlighted by a novel aspect in the design of the study by Petit et al.1 Chronological age of all four groups was no different, about 10-10.5 years, yet there was about 1 SD difference in sitting height, leg length, and lean and fat mass in the prepubertal cohort than early pubertal cohort. The lesson is clear, matching an exercise group with controls only by chronological age in studies of growth is inadvisable. The above addresses some issues in studies comparing an exercise group with a control group receiving no exercise. There are greater difficulties addressing the question of whether exercise is more efficacious in prepubertal than early-pubertal children, more efficacious in males than in females, or in one ethnic group compared with another. These comparisons require evidence that there is equivalent loading in these groups. Exercise in pre- versus early-pubertal girls may produce relatively less loading in the prepubertal girls. Even if loading intensity is measured and is equivalent in two groups, differences in the rate of maturational progression of the and skeleton pre- and groups, and racial/ethnic groups in study design that cannot be easily In groups, most sample sizes will be too small for and observations are likely to be 2 The whether or will be to on methodological grounds and will no the statistical of We are in the and effects of Thus, the many that may influence outcome in it may be more to the design of these studies by single racial/ethnic groups, groups with maturational with bone age rather than males and females or of different racial/ethnic Although there are many cross-sectional studies that have higher bone mass than the needed to produce this skeleton us is not is in for The question is, moderate exercise produces biologically worthwhile changes in bone What is When is the time during growth to What is the structural any increase in bone strength produced by exercise during the exercise is Petit et al.1 studied the effects of moderate exercise, an intervention that can easily be into a exercise This study is of a larger study in which the authors report the results of of by to be the of intervention groups and other to be This is a approach because it controls exercise. However, the not the were to exercise or no exercise. to one of the groups have occurred and a For example, a at the randomized to be the of controls but may if a randomized to be the of the intervention A more active may for the intervention group but to as a an effect that may result in a the baseline exercise characteristics of the sample published in an earlier it that there were no differences in baseline exercise characteristics in the intervention and control groups. of exercise to some of or cannot be differences in the that influence growth may also a of individuals rather than is one of that are in both groups. is The in produced by may be if or poor compliance in exercise The were a program of jumping 10 minutes three times The authors reported compliance in the only of the study due to loss of or reported an compliance prepubertal and girls during 7 In this from were into the carried during three times In another study of prepubertal 10 years, et an exercise program of of three times weekly during months with all but 2 compliance was reported by Morris et al.24 events were in all these trials. Thus, moderate exercise is accessible to all, by the of children, safe, and inexpensive to but it can be from the in the study by Petit et the the increase in most during 7 months not and so were in all four groups femoral in the prepubertal However, the increases in prepubertal intervention group were no greater than in the prepubertal controls. the increases in the early pubertal intervention group in femoral neck bone cortical thickness and section modulus were greater than in early pubertal controls. and similar observations in aBMD the authors suggest that the most of to exercise is during early (Tanner stages 2 and 3), rather than during the prepubertal There are several to suggest that this is the authors have not whether the increments in bone mass, or section modulus in the early pubertal intervention group are greater than the increments in the prepubertal intervention group and most after for the large differences in baseline characteristics these two maturationally different groups. A at the the mean changes this is so the inference that one of growth is more than another cannot be the in the prepubertal group is not by the results of several In the study by et femoral neck bone mass and bone area increased in prepubertal and girls of the exercise group more than in the controls. Whether there were gender specific changes is In a study of prepubertal boys, the increase in aBMD was greater than controls and was the result of less of the In with the of Petit et et suggest that the not is a to exercise. However, this was a cross-sectional study and the group had for a longer of a small increase in periosteal to exercise may have been for rather than The numbers of controls in the early pubertal group was larger than in the prepubertal group and from stages 1 and 2 occurred in of controls and of the intervention group, more of the intervention group in stage Thus, maturational progression in greater numbers of controls than could the benefit of the exercise. In periosteal and endocortical were measured at one the and bone may result in periosteal in the change in the a change in bone and data in the of the by Petit et suggest that periosteal increased in prepubertal to a the as using et report greater periosteal and endocortical in the playing compared with nonplaying arm in prepubertal some measure of loading such as of a or in the that loading produced by the jumping was relatively less in the pre- than early-pubertal girls cannot be lean mass to weight was no less in the prepubertal than in early pubertal Thus, both of growth are likely to be opportune of to a skeleton. growth is more than growth in the prepubertal most of the growth is growth then accelerated growth then but its growth whether one of growth is more opportune than another is the it possible for a of regional the response of the skeleton may be by loading before the response of the skeleton be by loading during exercise to skeleton in girls and be carried in the prepubertal years at the skeleton be and at a different chronological age in and girls, to for the differences in maturational The greater changes in the intervention than control groups were by Petit et al.1 in the early-pubertal The higher aBMD in the early-pubertal intervention may be the result of one or both of two greater bone than in controls or less or greater than in controls. Even a small change in produced by periosteal bone a large change in the cross-sectional because it is to the of the However, the increase in in the early pubertal intervention group was less than the increase in the controls not It was the increases in femoral neck bone cortical thickness, and section that were greater in the intervention group than controls. The greater increase in femoral cortical bone is a of bone mineral derived as if the tissue were not there is not the of the femoral The increase in and femoral cortical thickness is likely to be more the result of events on the endocortical than periosteal This is reported in exercise et in a prospective study of high impact exercise in reported changes on the not periosteal in the study of et reported that the greater cortical in the playing compared with the nonplaying arm was the result of greater endocortical in the years and greater periosteal in the prepubertal et report that the greater increase in aBMD in prepubertal in a moderate exercise program at was the result of greater endocortical not greater periosteal than in controls. is needed to the effects of exercise on the on the endocortical If exercise reduces remodeling this may reduce the of during growth compared with a and a may the of bone and in by the or of the and This may result in less or a exercise may produce bone independent of the remodeling The effects of exercise on of matrix are unknown. In all of these the of bone were measured at one the bone and in the The of periosteal and endocortical and remodeling the whole of a loading will modify of the geometry of the bone in with the imposed In racket sports, the greater cortical area of the playing versus nonplaying side is the result of both greater periosteal and greater endocortical The of periosteal and endocortical to the greater cortical thickness in the playing than nonplaying arm in a study by et were at the and at both and In the study by et the of greater periosteal and greater to the greater cortical thickness were in the and in the in men and Thus, loading both the periosteal and endocortical but the magnitude of the effects according to whether the is or and whether the region is or the These are not with a single and cortical thickness Thus, as by Petit et inferences about or of must be made only one was measured and of cortical and whole bone strength were then We need safe, and that measure the size and of the that us Although greater periosteal in the playing arm than nonplaying arm is reported by several investigators, periosteal at bone be less in the intervention than control group in the above et reported greater increase in bone size in prepubertal and girls. can this be In the studies by Petit et al.1 and et the changes in the periosteal were for changes in This is If the change in in an exercise and control group is the any difference in the change in periosteal can be to the exercise. If increases less in an exercise group than control group due to reduced growth of the or skeleton, then this may be by periosteal of the region independent of any local loading that may be This must be into in the and of the of the bone that is for total may if growth is region specific (which of it In one study by et and girls, increase less in the exercise than control sitting and leg not differ in the study by Petit et and the changes in these reported in the also not differ in intervention or control groups in the prepubertal or early pubertal Although not leg increased by about SD less in the prepubertal intervention than control Exercise may be associated with reduced growth in and and may be confined to one The is that the of the is on the local effects of the exercise as well as possible local growth and other factors that and growth of the The study by et was confined to changes in the In the aBMD of the increased more in the early pubertal exercise than control of the changes in body was not probably because of the difficulties in the of this This is needed if are to be made about the fracture efficacy of exercise. and aBMD increase during growth because bone size the in a the increase in may be the result of an increasing bone size and not an increase in the mass of would the skeleton to be if it can to greater well by changing its will increase during growth if the increase in the of bone within the periosteal is greater than the increase in the size of the bone. The results of changes in were reported in the study by et increased at the femoral with the that there was change on the periosteal so of the bone endocortical remodeling of the by bone or less endocortical so there was more bone the same bone. not increase at the In the study by et increased in the exercise group increased in controls so that the increase in area were no different in the two groups. of the increased by similar in both groups with no change in in et reported that the difference in aBMD in a playing versus a nonplaying arm was due to differences in bone size produced by greater periosteal apposition, not due to an increase in These studies all suffer from the methodological we measure bone size and so we If all the of exercise achieved during growth are exercise is stopped, This question is The answer to this question whether or not can be made regarding exercise as a public health There is evidence that exercise bone loss Whether this at the endocortical and trabecular any periosteal is maintained is not known. In such as are maintained for many years, but these are young The are about lower than the SD in active but this may changes in intensity the may have achieved a lower bone size and mass than the In years, to be or largely rates were no less in the than in but the study may have been These are cross-sectional but as good as it is to We will not have prospective studies of young they the to the There is no evidence of a benefit of exercise during growth on bone structure or strength in old age falls and fracture risk The evidence regarding no or is based on studies in not based on studies of moderate exercise. There is no data to or the that the modest achieved by moderate exercise during growth are into adulthood are There is only one by et published in that the derived from 7 months of exercise were maintained 7 months after the jumping This study must before the of the results can be is data addressing the most whether any achieved during growth will be by a less or less exercise If the are is it better to never have exercised at There is we are from such as and aBMD and a greater of The skeleton is not an that can be into a single or single like aBMD. is an its and during growth because they are The skeleton is not a single The growth of the and are not single that at end like an the segment of the bone more rapidly than the The at the same time being exposed to the same of There is no one cortical in bone shape, size, and cortical thickness is at its and its and these are changes to region of the and skeleton, on the and a and is by genetic local and into a structure to The effect of exercise may on the stage of growth exercise is as well as the intensity and of we need of all of these at the I We must get from and aBMD we about the of growth and We have recognized that the effects of loading are region specific and the changes are the result of the and of the periosteal and measure and the that in space. we that moderate exercise during growth a skeleton of with a a and or more If do we that this skeleton will just a little less and a little less after decades of a in the of and than would have occurred had moderate exercise not been during but I is There are many and of the studies reported by Petit et al.1 and et and these should be studied attention to study design is in all but the needed are particularly in studies of growth. We need studies that are in a single gender and single ethnic group, with pubertal bone age. We need that measure bone size and its and bone If the design is the studies will be to and the or will be to and difficult to on When statistical can do we will not need clinical trials. we need study design rather than statistical that by in small sample sizes to the with the to us by a in a
Author: Ego Seeman
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2089989658
FWCI: 2.155
Cites: 39
Cited by: 133
Related to: 10