Year: 2002
Type: review
Abstract: Biological nitrogen fixation is a process that can only be performed by certain prokaryotes. In some cases, such bacteria are able to fix nitrogen in a symbiotic relationship with plants. Bacteria of the genera Azorhizobium, Bradyrhizobium, Mesorhizobium, Rhizobium, and Sinorhizobium (collectively referred to as Rhizobium or rhizobia) are able to establish an endosymbiotic association with legumes. Under nitrogen-limiting conditions, the leguminous plants can form root nodules, in which the rhizobia are hosted intracellularly. There they find the proper conditions for reducing atmospheric nitrogen into ammonia. This review will focus on signal transduction events of Rhizobium-induced nodulation. Basic research on the legume–Rhizobium interaction becomes more and more focused on two model legume species, Lotus japonicus and Medicago truncatula (Cook, 1999; Stougaard, 2001). Two model legumes have been selected because most legumes form nodules that belong either to the determinate or to the indeterminate nodule type and L. japonicus and M. truncatula, respectively, represent these two major legume groups (Pawlowski and Bisseling, 1996). Although the morphology and ontology of these two nodule types is different, the mechanisms underlying the formation of them are probably very similar. In this review, we will only give a description of nodule ontogeny of the indeterminate nodule type, as represented by M. truncatula. The formation of a nodule requires the reprogramming of differentiated root cells to form a primordium, from which a nodule can develop. Furthermore, the bacteria must infect the root before the nitrogen-fixing root nodule can be formed. These steps in nodule formation involve changes in three root tissues, namely epidermis, cortex, and pericycle. When rhizobia have colonized the root surface of their host, they induce morphological changes in the epidermis. These morphological changes are preceded by the induction of certain genes in a broad region of the epidermis. The best-studied examples are the early-nodulin genes ENOD12 and ENOD11, which are homologous and belong to a gene family encoding proline-rich proteins. ENOD12 and ENOD11 have a similar expression pattern and have been used as molecular markers to monitor signal transduction events in the epidermis (Scheres et al., 1990; Pichon et al., 1992; Journet et al., 2001). Schematic Drawing of Early Steps in Root Nodule Formation in Medicago truncatula Induced by Sinorhizobium meliloti. (A) Nodule primoridum formation. The bacteria induce root hair curling and infection thread formation in epidermal cells (blue). Concomitantly, the inner cell layers are activated. Pericycle cells opposite a proto-xyleme pole express the ENOD40 gene and eventually will undergo a limited number of cell divisions (yellow). Cells in the cortex will loose their cell identity and enter the cell cycle. This results in the formation of a nodule primordium in the inner cortex (dark green). In these cells, ENOD12 and ENOD40 are expressed. Outer cortical cells also enter the cell cycle, but are arrested (orange) and will form preinfection threads. (B) Root nodule differentiation. Cells of the nodule primordium obtain their final identity after rhizobial infection. At the base of the primordium, a radial pattern of a central tissue (pink) surrounded by peripheral tissues (red) is established. Concomitantly, cells at the apex of the primordium form a meristem (light green). These cells differ in their identity compared with primordium cells, in that they do not express ENOD12. The central tissue contains the cells that host the rhizobia. Even before the infection thread has crossed the epidermis, cortical and pericycle cells respond in a local manner to the rhizobia. In pericycle cells, this is reflected by the rapid induction of ENOD40 in a zone opposite a protoxylem pole and by rearrangements of the microtubles (Yang et al., 1993; Timmers et al., 1999; Compaan et al., 2001). Eventually, these cells will undergo a limited number of cell divisions (Timmers et al., 1999). Following the activation of the pericycle, cells in the inner cortex dedifferentiate by entering the cell cycle. The group of dividing cortical cells is named the nodule primordium (Figure 1A). Outer cortical cells, through which the infection threads will grow, form radially oriented, conical cytoplasmic columns. This organization of the cytoplasm takes place before the infection thread enters these cells; these therefore are named pre–infection threads (Van Brussel et al., 1992; Timmers et al., 1999; Van Spronsen et al., 2001). The pre–infection thread forming outer cortical cells also enter the cell cycle but are arrested before they can enter the M phase (Yang et al., 1994; Figure 1A). Therefore, it is assumed that pre–infection threads are in some way related to phargmoplasts (Van Brussel et al., 1992; Yang et al., 1994). The pre–infection threads will facilitate infection thread growth and direct it toward the nodule primordium. There the infection thread ramifies, followed by the release of bacteria into the primordial cells. Upon release, the bacteria remain surrounded by a membrane of plant origin and subsequently will differentiate into their symbiotic form and will start to fix nitrogen (for review, see Mylona et al., 1995). In general, the transition from nodule primordium to young developing nodule occurs after infection of primordial cells. During this transition, cells at the base of the primordium establish a radial pattern consisting of a central tissue surrounded by peripheral tissues (Pawlowski and Bisseling, 1996). Concomitantly, cells at the apex of the primordium form a meristem that, by division, maintains itself and adds new cells to the different tissues according to the pattern established at the base of the primordium (Figure 1B). The identity of nodule primordium cells and nodule meristematic cell is different. For example, a meristematic cell is never infected by rhizobia, and genes that are activated in the primordium, e.g., ENOD12, are not transcribed in the nodule meristem (Scheres et al., 1990). Specific signal molecules secreted by Rhizobium, named Nod factors, play a pivotal role in the induction of all early responses. For example, they are required for gene activation in the epidermis and pericycle cells, for the mitotic reactivation of the cortical cells, and for the formation of pre–infection threads. Proteins encoded by the rhizobial nodulation genes (nod, nol, and noe genes) are involved in the synthesis and secretion of Nod factors. The expression of these genes is activated when the bacteria perceive specific molecules, in general flavonoids that are secreted by the plant root (Zuanazzi et al., 1998). Flavonoids activate the bacterial transcriptional regulator NodD that in turn induces the transcription of the other bacterial nodulation genes involved in the synthesis of Nod factors. The Major Nod Factor Produced by Sinorhizobium meliloti. The major Nod factor produced by Sinorhizobium meliloti contains four glucosamine units, an acyl chain of 16 C-atoms in length with two unsaturated bonds (determined by NodE and NodF), an acetyl group at the non-reducing terminal sugar residue (determined by NodL), and a sulfate group at the reducing terminal sugar residue (determined by NodH, NodP and NodQ) (Lerouge et al., 1990). The vast majority of the Nod factors produced by S. meliloti are tetrameric and contain an acyl chain of 16 carbon atoms in length with two unsaturated bonds (C16:2). The terminal reducing glucosamine residue of this Nod factor is O-sulfated, whereas the other terminal glucosamine contains an O-acetyl group (Figure 2). In addition, low quantities of Nod factors containing C18-C26 (ω-1)-hydroxylated acyl chains and molecules that lack the O-acetyl group are formed (Lerouge et al., 1990; Roche et al., 1991; Schultze et al., 1992; Demont et al., 1993). The differences in structure of Nod factors made by different rhizobial species are determined by the presence of species-specific nodulation genes or are due to allelic variation resulting in a different activity of the encoded enzymes. In general, the substitutions at the terminal residues and the structure of the acyl chain play a role in the ability of the bacterium to interact with its host plant. For example, the sulfate decoration of the S. meliloti Nod factor is a major determinant of host specificity because it is required for the induction of almost all symbiotic responses. In contrast, the O-acetate group as well as the structure of the acyl chain is especially required for efficient infection. In the following section of this review, Nod factor perception and induced signal transduction events will be the central themes. Nod factors induce responses in their hosts at picomolar concentrations. Therefore, it is often suggested that Nod factors are recognized by a high affinity receptor (e.g., Dénarié and Cullimore, 1993; Heidstra and Bisseling, 1996). Further, the amphiphylic nature of Nod factors, with their hydrophobic lipid tail and -hydrophilic sugar backbone, suggests that Nod factor receptors are located in the plasma membrane. The latter is supported by in vitro studies showing that Nod factors rapidly insert into membranes (Goedhart et al., 1999). To identify putative Nod factor receptors, two approaches have been used: a direct approach to identify Nod factor binding sites in protein extracts, and a “candidate gene” approach to determine whether proteins encoded by known genes are able to bind Nod factors. Both approaches have led to the identification of Nod factor binding proteins. Two Nod factor binding proteins, NFBS1 and NFBS2, have been identified using binding studies with protein extracts (Bono et al., 1995; Niebel et al., 1997). NFBS1 is found in a root extract of M. truncatula and has an affinity of 86 nM for Nod factors. However, it also binds with about the same affinity to the nonsulfated Nod factor, which is biologically inactive in Medicago species. Furthermore, a similar binding site occurs in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum). Both observations make it unlikely that NFBS1 functions as a specific Nod factor receptor. NFSB2 has been identified in a M. varia cell suspension and is probably a plasma membrane–associated protein (Niebel et al., 1997). It has a higher affinity (K d: 4 nM) for Nod factors than does NFBS1, but it also does not discriminate between sulfated and nonsulfated Nod factors. The lack of host-specific binding properties makes it unlikely that these Nod factor binding sites by themselves can function as a specific Nod factor receptor. Further, it remains to be demonstrated that NFBS2 occurs in roots. If it does, it might be part of a Nod factor binding complex, in combination with other components by which only Nod factors with a host-specific structure are recognized (Cullimore et al., 2001). By using a “candidate gene” approach, it was shown that Nod factors bind to a lectin–nucleotide phosphohydrolase (LNP) named Db-LNP isolated from the roots of the legume Dolichos biflorus (Etzler et al., 1999). LNPs are members of the eukaryotic ATPase superfamily and catalyze the hydrolyses of the four nucleotide triphosphates as well as the nucleotide diphosphate ADP, which is a characteristic of Apyrases. It was shown that the ATPase activity of Db-LNP increases upon Nod factor binding to the lectin domain of the protein (Etzler et al., 1999). Db-LNP, as well as its soybean (Glycin soja) ortholog GS52, is extracellular protein present at the surface of young root hairs. Upon inoculation of D. biflorus with Bradyrhizobium, the protein accumulates at the tip of the root hairs; this is not the case when non-host rhizobia are used. Furthermore, specific antibodies against the LNPs block root hair deformation as well as nodulation (Etzler et al., 1999; Day et al., 2000; Kalsi and Etzler, This suggests that LNPs play a role in the early steps of nodulation. However, it function as a receptor in the Nod factor and the ATPase activity is remain Two other have been shown to play a role in the early steps of nodulation. These are lectin and of When these genes are in the host of these plants is but they also more to their host rhizobial species. However, it is unlikely that the of of these on Nod factor binding et al., 1995; Van et al., 2001). In studies on the of Nod factors in roots have Nod factor Nod factor on the root surface was by using biologically Nod factors, in combination with (Goedhart et al., This is a very at the that can be used to molecular and to determine the of In a focused a and the number of molecules that through this as well as the required for this are This a of the as well as the the latter is related to the of the it can be determined whether the a with other components (for review, see et al., studies that Nod factors, in an in the cell of root and of to higher than in the that was (Goedhart et al., Furthermore, Nod factors that they bind to cell The of Nod factors in the cell as well as their is Nod factor structure and not host plant Therefore, it is unlikely that this is by binding to a Nod factor receptor. However, rhizobia might the of Nod factors in the cell to to the root Nod factors in cell at higher than in the This suggests that Nod factors at picomolar induce it is that a putative Nod factor receptor is to higher concentrations. that in Nod factors are also present at a higher than picomolar For example, the formed by a root hair to bacteria are present and the is than and If only a Nod factor present in the of the the be higher than M. If the bacteria Nod factor molecules the local be the it unlikely that a putative Nod factor receptor have such a high affinity for Nod factors as was demonstrated by studies Nod factors in the plant cell Therefore, it that secreted Nod factors will be present in the of the bacterial that The resulting local of Nod factors to the host about the of the bacteria that might be used to root hair This is supported by the that local of Nod factors at the root hair surface with a a of growth toward the et al., Nod factors have a as a for a Nod factor receptor signal transduction and as a to root hair The molecular of the of root hair growth is not but probably will be is the M. truncatula that has the ability to form a in which root in a other responses are induced Therefore, it has been that the protein is required to the by the rhizobia et al., 2001). The induction of early the activation of the inner cell and the of root hair deformation and curling do not a high of specificity to Nod factor In Medicago species, all of these responses can be by S. meliloti that have a in the specific structure of the acyl chain the at the terminal sugar residue are (Figure 2). In contrast, are for the formation of infection threads et al., 1994; et al., 2001). rhizobia will or of infection sites in the of which the majority will and only a limited number will infect a nodule primordium. S. meliloti and respectively, induce infection the number of nodules that is formed is about the same as in S. meliloti et al., 1994). the S. meliloti has its ability to infection thread that the Nod factor is to the formation of an infection This has led to the that two Nod factor perception mechanisms are in the a involved in the bacterial that has a high for the Nod factor and a perception with a involved in the induction of the other epidermal responses et al., 1994; et al., 2001). host gene that is involved in infection thread formation in to Nod factor structure is et al., 1997). was identified in the it infection by Rhizobium Nod factors at the reducing terminal sugar residue et al., which does not a specific in the of et al., the activity of on the structure of the Nod factors secreted by the rhizobia, and it in the that the of the The of and M. truncatula are and in M. truncatula, the region has been identified et al., However, whether a ortholog occurs in M. truncatula is and cell approaches as well as studies with specific have into the signal transduction that are activated in the root epidermis by Nod factors. of the responses is plasma membrane which is after Nod factor This is by a very rapid induced of Nod factor addition, followed by a Upon of the an of is by which the membrane can The is for Nod membrane because the as well as this Nod membrane whereas the is able to this et al., 1992; et al., 1995; et al., after Nod factor in the region of the root and radially through the cell et al., 1996). Although the role of the induced changes in remains to be they have been as for the of Nod factor In is a Nod factor that occurs in legume species, which adds to its as an for Nod factor et al., et al., 2000; et al., into Nod factor has been by using specific that or with certain Nod responses. such a gene by the of the early-nodulin gene ENOD12 or ENOD11, has been a Upon inoculation with rhizobia or with Nod factors, ENOD12 is induced in the root epidermis to et al., 1992; et al., 1998). To determine whether binding protein are part of a Nod the of has been have named and respectively, and are with receptors that belong to the group of receptors containing is a of and in it has been shown to the activated domain of to the activation of and 1994; and 1994). a and activation of in the root epidermis of M. truncatula that is to the induction by Nod factors et al., 1998). Furthermore, induces root hair deformation in et al., 2001). that plant it that a Nod a et al., et al., 2001). However, the to which plants and on in their signal is different. In of genes encoding and of genes for the of the have been In contrast, in and are For example, in the only putative and and two putative and very putative have been identified and 2001). in M. truncatula, a similar low number of genes encoding putative and in This the whether plant responses are by the activation of a and it remains whether Nod factors activate such Nod factor as well as an in the of and in the of other such as not et al., 2001). is probably a signal in and it is to by The Nod of the was by the activation of as well as The activation of was shown to be for the induction of root hair activation was also shown to be for ENOD12 but whether is involved is not known et al., 1998). have been used in studies for and especially for a of symbiotic has been et al., This has been for that are in the early steps of the (for an of in this review, see of the in this able to establish a and not able to establish a for at an early of nodulation. For see of the in this able to establish a and not able to establish a for at an early of nodulation. For see The and M. truncatula are in Nod responses in the epidermis as well as in inner cell the root do not or cortical cell divisions are not and the early-nodulin genes ENOD12 and ENOD40 are not induced in the epidermis and pericycle, and 1992; et al., et al., 1999; et al., 2000; et al., In the only upon of Nod factors is the of the root hair of the three M. truncatula et al., of Nod Factor in and of and and of M. truncatula block Nod as well as whereas the Therefore, it is that of and and probably is involved in a specific Nod factor perception et al., 2000; et al., is by as well as by et al., and of function of but it was not whether they have a function et al., It is known that some nodulation are also in their ability to interact with et al., et al., 1999). the are in interaction et al., et al., 2000; et al., the group of in can be in two which is and all which are the morphological responses induced by and rhizobia are different, it that the structure of the signal molecules from that of rhizobial Nod factors. This is supported by the that is very and occurs in the vast majority of plant species, that will also a putative whereas they do not respond to rhizobial Nod factors. it is that Nod factors and are different, different receptors are For these it that is of the steps of the and and that therefore it is a to a protein that is involved in Nod factor In M. truncatula as well as L. of symbiotic genes has been The of M. truncatula, and M. are and on their and their and are probably of in M. and et al., 1991; et al., et al., 1999; et al., 2000; et al., This was and shown to a with in a putative extracellular domain et al., The function of this in Nod factor can be If is involved in Nod factor it probably part of a in which e.g., the specificity for Nod factors. Nod factor is using epidermal responses that are induced to after Nod factor In some cases, it is shown that these responses are induced in a the inner cell layers respond to Nod factors For example, ENOD40 gene expression is induced in the pericycle after of Nod factors et al., 2001). The remains whether Nod factors are to these cells or whether plant signal molecules formed as a to Nod factors induce the responses in the inner cell that this in an way led to and Bisseling, et al., 1997). into the mechanisms to the activation of the inner cell layers be using symbiotic have been identified that are in Nod responses in the inner cell whereas most responses in the epidermis are not For example, the of M. truncatula and the in L. japonicus are in the mitotic activation of the cortex, whereas epidermal responses are not et al., 1999; et al., has been and a putative transcription factor with a domain in the of the protein et al., 1999). of and other will most into the for the activation of the cortical and pericycle cells of the plant In general, are by Two in mechanisms Nod factor have been identified by using the These are and the have an to Nod factors, because can be induced in these by a Nod factor than to induce in plants et al., is for Nod factor of it is also involved in a of this (Figure it has been known for a that it has a on nodule formation (e.g., et al., and and and the suggests that is a regulator of Nod factor This is supported by studies in which is to the plant resulting in of the et al., in the can also block showing that and be part of two different (Figure et al., Nod responses in the inner cell layers are also by is most produced in the pericycle cells opposite the because the gene encoding which the in is in these cells et al., 1997). studies that the as well as the number of nodule is by local because the more nodule than do plants and 1997). Furthermore, these nodule are formed also opposite results by plant roots with that with either or the perception of et al., 1997). not only is a regulator of Nod factor in the epidermis, but also the local of this regulator in the cortex nodule are formed. In of signal transduction events in nodule formation has a in nodulation These studies have been focused on M. truncatula and L. Both legumes have model as by the of the and the of new These will make it to legume genes with two genes involved in Nod factor of L. japonicus and of M. It is that in the more genes will be It is to be that of these genes will major new for cell and approaches to to but mechanisms that a for to Figure
Source: The Plant Cell
DOI: 10.1105/tpc.002451
Authors: René Geurts, Ton Bisseling
Institution: Wageningen University & Research
Language: English
Subfield: Plant Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2096550240
