Work

Bird origins anew

Year: 2013
Type: article
Abstract: THE PAST THREE decades have witnessed a crescendo to one of the most intense and polemical debates in vertebrate evolution, the question of avian origins. Now the theory that “birds are living dinosaurs,” specifically “birds are maniraptoran theropods” (the “BMT hypothesis”), predominates, and advocates of alternatives have largely been silenced, despite their growing numbers. Richard Prum has argued that ornithology be subsumed as a subfield of dinosaur paleontology and that textbooks be rewritten to conform to the BMT hypothesis (Prum 2002, 2003; James and Pourtless 2009). Perhaps The Auk could be renamed The Raptor, an appellation co-opted from ornithology, now the moniker for the dromaeosaurs like Velociraptor, star of Jurassic Park. Thomas Henry Huxley is attributed with popularizing the earliest view that birds evolved from dinosaurs in the 1860s, but with little distinction between the flesh-eating theropods and herbivorous ornithischians. Although Huxley's views on bird origins were more complex than most modern authors appreciate (Switek 2010), “Darwin's Bulldog” viewed modern Aves as “dinosaur” descendants via the flightless ratites (Ostrich and allies) that never passed through a flight stage, a view later disproven, and the earliest then known bird, the Urvogel Archaeopteryx, was considered an intercalary bird and thus not part of the actual dino-bird transition. Huxley's view was supplanted in 1926 when the Dane Gerard Heilmann wrote the influential The Origin of Birds, in which he linked avian flight from the trees down with an early avian origin, from small tree-dwelling archosaurs (then, pseudosuchian thecodonts). He viewed birds and dinosaurs as derived from common archosaurian ancestry, a dominant view until Yale's John Ostrom discovered the birdlike Early Cretaceous dromaeosaur Deinonychus in the 1960s, reestablishing a direct dinosaurian genesis of birds, from already highly derived dromaeosaurs, relatively late in time. All this was accomplished without any use of phylogenetic systematics, with which he found fault, but cladistics would later claim to codify Ostrom's theory into solid fact, as it stands today. Ostrom realized, however, that an earthbound theropod close to the ancestry of birds required a coupling to a “ground—up” flight origin, with myriad inherent problems and a high level of biophysical improbability. Interestingly, in the early 1980s, when the debate on bird origins was raging, most paleontologists favored a dinosaurian origin of birds, but paradoxically a trees—down flight scenario, at the time an incompatible pairing. An upheaval in our knowledge occurred in the 1990s, when the remarkable period of discovery in China of the Jehol Biota revealed the most vivid and complete picture of the Early Cretaceous to date, with thousands of complete specimens emerging from lacustrine deposits in northeastern Liaoning province, many relevant to early bird evolution, and casting light on their actual origin (Feduccia 2012a, b). Unfortunately, most of these remarkable finds, largely inaccessible in China, have been published as preliminary or highly superficial reports primarily in the U.K. journal Nature, but also in Science and other prestigious journals, and the authors often received monetary awards in addition to much coveted recognition. Too, most specimens were interpreted within the context of the current mantra of the field, which has become an unchallengeable orthodoxy: birds are living maniraptoran theropods. At the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology's fall 1996 meeting at the American Museum of Natural History, a small black-andwhite photograph of a newly discovered specimen purported to be a feathered dinosaur was pinned on a bulletin board, just months following discovery. With no light or scanning electron microscopy or other biological assay, a pen-and-ink of the specimen appeared on the front page of the New York Times as important new support for the theory that birds are derived from dinosaurs. Following the current paleontological thought, a filamentous line along the back of the small compsognathid dinosaur Sinosauropteryx (“Chinese reptile wing”) was described by a Chinese invertebrate paleontologist as representing protofeathers, with no evidence to support the supposition. Although John Ostrom, upon viewing the new “feathered dinosaur” in China, “literally got weak in the knees,” there was never any evidence that these filaments represented anything other than a skeletal meshwork of collagen fibers supporting a lizard-like frill, scalloped along the tail as in the modern Central American basilisk lizards (Feduccia et al. 2005, Lingham-Soliar et al. 2007), and a clearly marked body outline on all specimens demonstrates that the fibers are internal, not to mention the presence of scales on the parts of the body (Martin and Czerkas 2000, Lingham-Soliar 2013; Fig. 1). Supposed evidence of melanosomes in Sinosauropteryx filaments (Zhang et al. 2010) cannot be substantiated and has been firmly refuted (Lingham-Soliar 2011). Other specimens, ranging from small theropods to ornithischians, and even pterosaurs, have emerged with halos exhibiting similar structures, leading to the current paleontological view that feathers at all stages of evolutionary development were widespread across the Dinosauria and perhaps even all archosaurs (Feduccia 2012b:120–136). The halos with fibers are invariably interpreted as protofeathers, but these are extraordinarily complex structures and may include a great variety of structures, some macerated and degenerate, and some representing bizarre preservational phenomena. The most recent is a late Cretaceous ornithomimosaur reported not only with body feathers, but with wing feathers that were used only for display (Zelenitsky et al. 2012). First, no convincing evidence is presented that the “fibers” on the matrix represent feathers, and the carbonaceous markings on the ulna thought to be some form of ulnar quill nodes appear almost randomly ordered and do not remotely resemble those of modern birds. Considering that advanced avian wings were present in the Jurassic, trying to understand the origin of avian wings and remiges by studying Late Cretaceous theropod dinosaurs seems to stretch credulity. Too, if their interpretation is true, it would be the only known case of such a phenomenon, therefore demanding the highest level of evidence, which is simply not available. In another case, McKellar and colleagues recently reported a variety of feather material in Late Cretaceous Canadian amber as being of dinosaur origin (McKellar et al. 2011, 2012), but careful critique of their microscopic techniques, morphological comparisons, and potentially incomplete analysis of other biological materials by Smithsonian feather expert Carla Dove and colleague Lorian Straker suggested that there was nothing from the amber specimens that did not conform nicely to modern avian feathers or their component parts and that the authors did not convincingly rule out other biological materials or microscopic artifacts (Dove and Straker 2012). Arguments on dinosaur feather origins from this material are highly inadvisable, particularly in light of there being no actual animal identified and the temporal occurrence in the Late Cretaceous, probably ∼100 million years beyond actual feather origins. It should be noted here that a popular misconception is that ulnar quill nodes are directly correlated with flight ability, and their absence in Archaeopteryx has been used as evidence that the Urvogel could not of the quill nodes are found in and are only present in most and but in Too, quill nodes are in the with the of a of these structures on an ulna of Velociraptor, and a other highly and of the Late Cretaceous and found no evidence of the presence of any quill structures have not been reported from the of avian and from the Chinese of the reptile or Sinosauropteryx with no evidence, as a of small compsognathid is of theropods in the of the as as other theropod In all specimens there is a clearly marked outline of the body with line in the specimen and of that the filamentous is not but the most a of collagen supporting a (Lingham-Soliar et al. of John or collagen collagen in the of a of some of the fibers along the of the of fibers have of that to the of the fibers and to of component fibers the filaments and from et al. Lingham-Soliar was viewed back in the as a hypothesis of bird origins has now been as the of the of vertebrate paleontology of the are now considered living and was a hypothesis has to an unchallengeable that those evidence are of and no considered the has a from a to that are for a maniraptoran avian origin, on the of to support and Pourtless are no to but evidence is to or is already thought to be from James and Pourtless is that only supporting evidence be evidence is or The of the down to the of the of the field, cladistics or phylogenetic systematics, to with the biological of is a of of often skeletal that are ordered in to a the or until a the a from the of myriad such a to the complex of phylogenetic is in view of many morphological being by (Feduccia The of the to with common of vertebrate of at in and in in flightless the the The evolutionary of is biological often in that is not and in Thomas Huxley not to with view of evolution, as not and evidence of the of or the of or in the of to have a not only in vertebrate origins but also in the of birds, and in to with by the current The case of and is The are close an in a noted the between and all one in are that have become theory of origins was only a to the to much more than to the of the a to be a of recent that the with the or as the most evolved into a via the through a of more important here is that the of flightless birds, the ratites all evolved from through the are all their and thus the theropod dinosaurs. from these is the of phylogenetic are a from morphological comparisons, of and may Thomas Huxley viewed the ratites as dinosaur not passed through a flight stage, and modern birds as being derived from was by a similar view in the by an at the Museum of Natural History, but this line of was to a by another in that ratites were all derived from that and that there are no flightless birds that did not from similar no flightless bird has to a it is a this evolutionary to a in the from other common are also to through and evolution, the revealed by Archaeopteryx as an The of a of are He not only a in but the and early and published in our in the of evolutionary known as Although great was highly in the and with the discovery of the birdlike or dromaeosaurs, the of a flight from theropod dinosaurs the more biological of by has been largely in recent decades by the paleontological and has into a of light on avian evolution, the of avian seems clearly back in line with the Thomas Huxley and of thought, Interestingly, Huxley the view of flightless birds as dinosaurian Richard largely of was on the flightless birds, and in the a origin of flightless birds. theory emerged from the early discovery of in New that evolved by the by which were in the In a to Huxley and a for advocates of unchallengeable of bird the view of the as a Dove than as an advanced would later that flightless is a animal a animal it is the of evolutionary The is in the dinosaurian Vertebrate is with of evolution, the of similar in of birds in exhibiting on a case the and which by most out as a now support a almost all other that could not be of a and that their is The and in and in are for in the that and along with the Cretaceous in much to be a All birds have a of the to the In this is by a in by of the and and in by the of the in to the with their the without with or scalloped on the through a the to the the of the has or but has the as in the and therefore and all be their through thus recent could not the like most and and by the analysis of phylogenetic to in the the of origins is in a of all are on the that “birds are living are thus Archaeopteryx is an earthbound flight from the birds that resemble but with avian feathers, are feathered any filamentous structures in the dinosaurian are and the with avian wings be feathered dinosaurs. of this thought paleontological have emerged as to the current unchallengeable of the and be with Archaeopteryx is a feathered and the early has been to the Urvogel or even Huxley in the known bird a to the than any modern The and the the and the those of to Huxley were the Archaeopteryx has for and for and it has flight feathers, with an found only in it has an wing more than in modern et al. 2012), and wing in similar to that of a modern bird, for flight in it has a and like that of modern birds, and in it is a for a or a Archaeopteryx was in the when it was considered an earthbound dinosaur that could not with feathers for and has from time to time been from but seems to avian and 2012). John Ostrom was of the by an earthbound feathered with avian flight that of and he to for early avian the theory to have a most Chinese are as flight from the all their flight in a have from the from earthbound dinosaurs. the of the flight origin, small and high by the by all that have into the with to the lizards and with of with wing and of and modern and a flight origin, for have one in development of flight with small feathers or would not the and high of by flight from earthbound dinosaurs with with and already to or the of the is the body for flight and such flight if not are popular birds are living dinosaurs and a a of the flight for has been (Feduccia the and is now even to despite a of evidence to the Cretaceous with avian feathers and an advanced avian wing are feathered dinosaurs. has advanced avian and avian at the or it is a the avian are a birdlike with a an avian and a flight wing with and an advanced avian avian feathers to the as in birds, avian feathers, and in some an avian In and other nicely the for flightless birds, is that flightless birds and are as and in all flightless birds resemble other of the cannot be with current phylogenetic is that a analysis by the highly paleontologist et al. also et al. in which clearly as is largely by paleontologists and not even in a recent on bird origins in modern birds is a phenomenon, through in a that may resemble theropod and the nicely that The evidence that represent a of birds no be of the the living avian most Archaeopteryx in superficial and by of of the Urvogel in of from by in the of of to the flight with wings in a to Jurassic Archaeopteryx, Jurassic Cretaceous Cretaceous In Archaeopteryx was a and were and and were most flightless wings would be in a from never in recent paleontological is and the Origin of Birds, by James and John Pourtless and Pourtless in which present new as as an of all current of bird origins. that the that birds are maniraptoran theropods are not was for the to be of has become a common but of (Feduccia and in addition to the no in of the on flight origins by supporting the origin of flight and by and or the to the of dinosaurian by Lingham-Soliar (Lingham-Soliar 2011, 2013; Lingham-Soliar et al. Lingham-Soliar and Lingham-Soliar and Lingham-Soliar and The filamentous down the on the small compsognathid dinosaur and on other ornithischians, and are no biological were to these structures, not even that are a for feather In fact, the for many of these structures is that represent a matrix of collagen fibers supporting a lizard-like as in Sinosauropteryx (Lingham-Soliar et al. Lingham-Soliar et al. 2007), or other in the preservational halos these may be extraordinarily complex and may myriad structures, and even macerated feathers that may be as were would be or birds and the as as the wing or and the of problems the of protofeathers, these structures are now with avian feathers in and other birdlike which have avian feathers an were from the Chinese Early Cretaceous it would no be interpreted as of representing stages of feather The and the feathered Jurassic with are all considered dinosaurs. the have advanced avian wings with a of and feathers, and other avian an avian and avian and of avian advanced that represent than being the early avian with at all stages of flight and are with avian but these are in by the of with and a Interestingly, the as an earthbound flight feathers, which would have and a and a for support of feathers than that of Archaeopteryx of a and a the of flightless for supporting feathers than was the of The of is like close also a and have been in the with by which it was described in et al. and a dinosaurian or by which it is with the the of in other like a The of is that there is no the could not have been as is the case in and even Too, the in et al. 2010), most specimens are with a and the wing are for et al. 2011). In it would be to could flight remiges by the most current paleontological in which the are in flight the body in with wing feathers simply through the 2012). as an early flight stage, by to for flight origin in birds It is as these out of the of Although a of paleontologists have used to an flight origin into the BMT and are on the the recently it to on of the of 2011, 2012). of feathered Jurassic as the and the without wing and and skeletal are interpreted as early birds at a stage, with or and without a dinosaurian with a which the Although there is no morphological of one for dinosaur in is the presence of a with the of in and by which a more is with a to back is in archosaurs and is of the and Jurassic feathered such as described as Aves by et al. recently similar is the Jurassic described by et al. in an analysis in which Archaeopteryx was from Aves and with no but analysis by and and et al. the Urvogel to that most by a and if one were to the and the avian of and Jurassic and as as the a would avian noted years in the of the hypothesis being of morphological of the small dromaeosaur by the of on an actual which to alternatives in highly for the preservational of the of most specimens of from Museum of Nature, The in the of flight by in of by from The would not be or to such a animal as from much of time from the or even back into the of actual filamentous of wing feathers, of of with and Czerkas and of with The question that is just the are considered theropods. from the phylogenetic the of these as is clearly all have flight feathers that would have been a in and were of more than evidence that these early birds were and et al. et al. 2011). the of the theropod origin of birds is that all avian from the there is any other for this most of an period in avian flight evolution, from to and are as earthbound theropods to from the with as to Ostrom's for the origin of avian wings as for were with but of any theropod The are of Although described as this is and have little to with as or The by Czerkas and no that would with the but have that as or perhaps more with to use the and 2002, is remarkable that should have which not only it as a but also as even a dinosaur” only been discovered back in the of he would have the evidence to the that birds evolved from which were not and Czerkas Czerkas has recently discovered of at an and across the and evidence that these were also Czerkas close Jurassic tail feathers but is of wing feathers and was thus interpreted as evidence that feathers have evolved not in an but for in absence of evidence is not evidence of and that a variety of in the Too, birds be with feathers but of wing feathers, as by a specimen of the Cretaceous Other specimens of avian be in these birds, and may that of this may a great more the early of birds. to the popular paleontological view with the of and avian on most all the extraordinarily flight of modern wings and and and have evolved in a in earthbound as the most birdlike maniraptoran within those for the origin of flight feathers, are and Pourtless The current of flight biological and is to any to the current unchallengeable are in the of of views (Feduccia and polemical and that are for evidence have many of other views is nothing The the stages through which all it is it is and it is as being this new view of bird origins is now between stages and with only to The and that the of the no from other and to many important biological phenomena. almost on of skeletal the with which are is and are often the of of with a of is and the of a recent and the important and complex which are often derived from and the of (Feduccia have the current it the of the and which largely on of not (Feduccia has is that much of in it to the of as as or any other should not become a convincing the case for he the of than only on a of should as convincing a of analysis that for all other than do and many the view are in of not of not being do understand the of the and that is the by the which the and of and colleagues et al. material from the small dromaeosaur from the Late Cretaceous of that it the within and that small for and that flight the evidence from the matrix and the late occurrence of the any from these and this be considered highly a of the a question a for a or is on a specimen of a complete and tail is also on some and parts of the and this matrix would it to this and would be that such a could be published in however, out the with the just some of the do not to is than morphological skeletal cladistics should be considered only as a for that be and other of evidence, and not as the as is often the current the great in to and and that phylogenetic should be as an phylogenetic to and that and potentially Other that cladistics as an include and of the Cretaceous a for a that wing remiges are were present in as by skeletal flight but also the discovery of other complete wing The specimen that some feathers be without of the In the case of the Jurassic body feathers and tail feathers were but no wing feathers it was thus in as feathers for of but of this the the and in the current unchallengeable on bird origins and have into the like in a this of one noted following a of an the discovery of dinosaur in purported to be to even is It is to that the may be the to our It is time for from to the of a more careful of these highly this to in a of a to It is time to beyond the unchallengeable the of bird origins to the of the are the “feathered of China in of with avian ancestry, the current of bird as interpreted by an from but would In some of the time is is the feathered Cretaceous compsognathid with protofeathers, most collagen fibers supporting a lizard-like like early such as the Late and it the for avian flight origins. Sinosauropteryx is with a of that of be is the Late Cretaceous Velociraptor, a dromaeosaur with a birdlike and ulnar quill The Early Cretaceous have avian a bird and avian flight feathers, and are more than Archaeopteryx, that are not to birds, but of the early avian like Velociraptor, flightless of this Following are Cretaceous and with avian feathers and birdlike many of which of flight than being bird these are from but were on the of as of flight as at the Late Jurassic Archaeopteryx, the Urvogel or early bird, which that it is by an Early Cretaceous which the earliest known and is by a modern and from by of the of the The view here may appear but it is only new in back to the view of avian origins that the until the that birds and dinosaurs common archosaurian ancestry and that flight from and It also biological of the of and and a by that largely on skeletal In viewing all flightless as from it is a of biological to a new of the birds are by of avian flight and modern it has a flight wing and avian feathers a and and
Source: The Auk
Language: English
Subfield: Paleontology
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W2097073649
FWCI: 4.749
Cites: 62
Cited by: 47
Related to: 10