Kanonizing Katz| Commuting and Co-Authoring: How To Be in More Than One Place at the Same Time
Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: The dean and Deb Williams can testify that I tried coaxing them into making this event a modest one-but, as you see, it was to little avail.So let me welcome everybody from far and near, and proceed with the immodesty that the occasion seems to require.Communicating, commuting, and collaborating each provide opportunities to be here and elsewhere simultaneously.The nightly news, for example, can transport viewers from their couch to London or Teheran, and media events can take one to the moon or the Super Bowl.Even if Freud or Bakhtin or Goffman suggests that we talk to ourselves, in the plural, I think it's fair to say that communication is mostly about reaching out to another, often over great distances, via virtual transportation.Using his cell phone, one of our students in Jerusalem demonstrated how he could lull his baby to sleep even while on reserve duty in the army.This further develops James Carey's (1988) point that the telegraph made it possible to place a remote order on Wall Street at the same moment as somebody else who is on the market floor.So students of communication make this journey regularly.Commuting not only shares five letters with communication: it also shares the idea of exchange.Even when physical movement is involved, its aim is to get from one place to the other as speedily as possible.Some of you have heard me tell the famous Hebrew University joke about two planes that crashed in midair and Professor X was on both of them.It originated with a professor of comparative religion who visited every ashram and signed on for every haj.Later, the joke was bestowed on members of other disciplines, but was bested by the joke about ubiquitous Isaiah Berlin, who headed an Oxford college."What's the difference between God and Isaiah Berlin?" is the question.And the answer is that "God is everywhere, but Isaiah Berlin is everywhere except Oxford." 1 Logistically, I must reveal, this feat can be accomplished thanks to the different academic calendars of different universities.(But I hasten to add that I have not been guilty of this crime during my affiliation with Penn.Moreover the mandatory retirement age in Jerusalem is 68, and, somehow, Kathleen Jamieson knew that when she invited me to join the Annenberg team.) 1 Our local contender is Monroe Price, who in addition to being ubiquitous, is alleged to be able to be in more than one place at the same time-and take somebody along!International Journal of Communication 8 (2014) In More Than One Place at the Same Time 2166 Some of you may be thinking of The Captain's Paradise, but that's just a fantasy.Ruth and I have been together for 62 years without ever changing pictures midstream.We began by commuting while Ruth was completing her dissertation at Columbia and I had begun my first job at Chicago.Then we were invited to visiting stints in Jerusalem and later began the reverse commute from Jerusalem to Chicago.I commuted from Jerusalem to London for a while, and then Jerusalem-USC until I was traded-I like to say-from one Annenberg to the other in 1993.I then began 20 years of commuting from Jerusalem to Philadelphia, ending today.And then there's a third "c"-collaborating or coauthoring.I haven't counted lately, but I daresay that well over half of my publications are coauthored.I regret that collaboration does not augur well for longevity, or maybe my partners just wished to avoid this celebration, and I mourn them.But some are here, and I wish to salute them.They are living proof of how one enters a coauthor's mind, not only emerging mutually enriched, but emerging unsure of who proposed which idea, when, and where.
Author: Elihu Katz
Institution: University of Pennsylvania
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W2099057120
