Work

Evolutionary psychiatry and the triune brain

Year: 1985
Type: article
Abstract: Evolutionary psychiatry and the triune brain 1Some physicians are concerned that, because of the present emphasis on molecular and genetic biology and the Paracelsan drive to find a chemical to cure every condition, there is a tendency to treat patients as though they could be manipulated impersonally like machines.They point out that, fruitful as developments in chemotherapy have been, it is naive to believe that anything as complicated as the human brain can be made to dance to any tune by the administration of a single drug or combination of drugs.Evolutionary psychiatry provides counteractive leaven for reductionistic views inherent in the molecular approach.Psychiatry means, literally, 'mind healing'.Evolutionary psychiatry would therefore apply to potentially salutary insights, derived from a better understanding of how the psychencephalon (MacLean, 1982 a) has evolved and how it functions.Starting with the subjective self as its province (its territory), the domain of evolutionary psychiatry encompasses both the microscopic and macroscopic aspects of all the underlying phenomena as they seem to unfold in past-present-future and relate to the cosmos.In a provocative essay on 'Evolution and tinkering', Jacob (1977) has provided a relevant commentary: 'If molecular biology, which presents a strong reductionist attitude, yielded such a successful analysis of heredity, it was mainly because, at every step, the analysis was carried out simultaneously at the level of the molecules and at the level of ... the bacterial cell.' 'And it seems likely', he continues, 'that such a convergence of analysis will play an important role in the study of human beings and their societies.'Jacob (1977) emphasizes the molecular commonalities in animals and the similarities with respect to genetic coding, enzymatic reactions, and so forth.Commenting on the value of evolutionary studies, Darlington (1978) has said: 'Viruses and bacteria are not the precise ancestors of our nuclear and cellular organisms, but they show us how our ancestors must have worked ' Not only are all vertebrates composed of similar cellular types, but they, also show many striking commonalities of complex cellular assemblies constituting various organs of the body.Nowhere is the uniformity of vastly complex assemblies more striking than in the cerebral evolution of vertebrates, both as it applies to similarities within classes and to certain commonalities across classes.Such considerations provide the rationale for evolutionary psychiatry and make it inter alia imperative to conduct comparative neurobehavioural studies in an attempt to identify commonalities and differences in the way animals derive information and behave.Comparative neuroanatomical findings, together with studies of ontogeny, phylogeny, and paleontology, indicate that the human forebrain has evolved and expanded to its great size, while retaining commonalities of three neural assemblies that reflect an ancestral relationship to reptiles, early mammals, and late mammals.Radically different in their chemistry and structure, and in an evolutionary sense aeons apart, the three assemblies constitute an amalgamation of three brains in one, a triune brain (MacLean, 1970(MacLean, , 1973)).In terrestrial vertebrates the forebrain contained in the cerebral hemispheres is essential for giving direction to the activities of the rest of the nervous system which might be regarded as the neural chassis.In such vehicular terms it was as though the cerebral hemispheres constituting the psychencephalon had gradually acquired a complement of three drivers or, as stated in computer language, three central processing assemblies.In the case of human beings there is the major complication for intercommunication that the two 'older' assemblies are not 'wired' and 'programmed' for the transmission of symbolic language.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2103427161
FWCI: 1.477
Cites: 13
Cited by: 147
Related to: 10