Work

The Regulatory RAB and ARF GTPases for Vesicular Trafficking

Year: 2008
Type: review
Abstract: While highly conserved in structure and in fundamental regulatory aspects for their activities, the RAS superfamily of monomeric GTP-binding proteins, or small GTPases, comprise a large family of regulatory molecules that collectively regulate diverse and critical cellular processes in eukaryotes. The RAB and ARF GTPases are members of two of the RAS-related subfamilies that function in regulating vesicle trafficking, starting from regulating the formation of vesicles on donor membranes and directing trafficking specificity to and facilitating vesicle docking on target membranes (Zerial and McBride, 2001; Gillingham and Munro, 2007). Studies in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and mammalian systems have shown that successive steps in endomembrane trafficking, from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the Golgi, intra-Golgi, post-Golgi, and endocytic trafficking, are mediated by subfamilies of RAB and ARF GTPases. The fundamental roles that these small GTPases play in membrane trafficking are indicated by their conservation throughout eukaryotes and their proliferation in the more complex animal and plant systems. Structural conservation among these GTPases has facilitated a rather comprehensive identification of the corresponding gene families in plants with complete genome information, in particular those for the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) RABs and ARFs (Pereira-Leal and Seabra, 2001; Rutherford and Moore, 2002; Vernoud et al., 2003; Zhang et al., 2007). In most cases examined, sequence conservation among yeast, mammalian, and plant RAB GTPases has correlated with similar localization on discrete subcellular compartments of the endomembrane trafficking systems in these diverse organisms. However, while the most closely related RAB GTPases from diverse organisms appear to hold analogous positions within the endomembrane system, it is clear that experimental strategies directly targeted at examining the specific functions of these small GTPases in plants will be required to determine distinctions in how various membrane compartments are utilized and how plant-specific cargos are sorted and trafficked through these compartments. We refer readers to earlier reviews (Rutherford and Moore, 2002; Vernoud et al., 2003) and focus our discussion here on recent studies that examine the biological role for these small GTPases in specific cellular context as well as emerging studies that explore their broader regulatory networks. A comprehensive gene/protein nomenclature system that accurately reflects phylogenetic relationships as well as functional specialization is a moving target, as genomic sequences and functional information are continuously being added and refined. This is particularly the case for the plant RAB GTPases, which, like their yeast and mammalian counterparts, constitute the largest of the RAS-related superfamilies of small GTPases. Based on sequence similarity among themselves, and with their yeast and mammalian orthologs, a nomenclature system for the 57 Arabidopsis RABs that places them into eight distinct subfamilies (A to H, corresponding to the mammalian RAB GTPase classes of 11, 2, 18, 1, 8, 5, 7, and 6, respectively), each regulating distinct paths in the membrane trafficking systems, has been proposed (Pereira-Leal and Seabra, 2001). The use of numerical designation to reflect closest analogy with mammalian orthologs, e.g. RAB2 and RAB11, has been adopted for some of the studies, especially for RABs from plants other than Arabidopsis. This has the clear advantage for cross-referencing but runs the risk of obscuring aspects of these plant RAB GTPases that have evolved to best serve vesicular trafficking needs in plant cells. Development of a nomenclature system that incorporates the numbering system of the closest mammalian orthologs and at the same time preserves the designation of the eight distinct subgroups previously defined for the Arabidopsis RABs is currently under way (I. Moore, personal communication). We will use both systems, e.g. RAB11/RABA, for general discussions and retain use of the original nomenclature in most of our discussions of specific studies. We opt to test the use, however, of the system under development in the section where we discuss the RAB5/RABF and RAB7/RABG class of GTPases. Perhaps response from readers will help guide the development of a system that best serves this complex protein family. The small GTPase regulatory cycle. RAS-related GTPases cycle between an active GTP-bound and an inactive GDP-bound state. GEFs activate these small GTPases, which in turn interact with specific effectors to mediate downstream pathways. GAPs stimulate the inherent GTPase activity of these small G proteins, accelerating the inactivation of their regulatory activity. A schematic illustration for the RAB- and ARF-mediated pathways in plant cells known to date. Phragmoplast and polarized outgrowth are depicted as examples of cellular structures that require high levels of polarized secretory activities for their formation. SV, Secretory vesicles; MVE/PVC, multivesiculated endosome/prevacuolar compartment; RE, recycling endosome. Additional important biological roles for RAB- and ARF-regulated pathways have emerged recently from studies in knockout plants defective in proteins that regulate the RAB and ARF GTPase cycle. In particular, knockouts of RAB and ARF guanine exchange factors (GEFs) that stimulate exchange of GDP for GTP, and thereby “turn on” the GTPase by allowing progression into the GTP-bound conformation (Fig. 1), have resulted in observable defects in plant growth and development (Steinmann et al., 1999; Goh et al., 2007; Teh and Moore, 2007). Another class of regulators for these small GTPases are GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs), which stimulate hydrolysis of the GTP bound in the RAB or ARF GTPases and thus “turn off” the GTPase by returning it to its GDP-bound conformation. Mutations in ARF GAP have been shown to result in abnormal vein pattern formation in Arabidopsis (Koizumi et al., 2005; Sieburth et al., 2006). Finally, some success has been gained by analysis of knockouts of downstream effector proteins that are recruited to the GTP-bound, active GTPases and are responsible for carrying out the various biological functions that these small GTPases regulate (Preuss et al., 2006; Stefano et al., 2006). Some model cell systems for the studies of regulatory small GTPases for vesicular trafficking. A, Localization of various GFP-labeled RAB GTPases in transiently transformed Arabidopsis protoplasts. B and C, Localization of NtRAB5 to endosomal compartments in tobacco epidermal cells. B, GFP-NtRAB5 (green) colocalizes on yellow punctate structures with the endocytic marker FM4-64 (red) in epidermal cells of CaMV35S-GFP-NtRab5 transformed tobacco seedlings. C, CFP-NtRAB5 (red) colocalizes with a GFP-labeled auxin efflux protein AtPIN1 (green) known to be recycled through the endosomes (see Geldner and Jürgens, 2006) on yellow punctate structures. The insets in B and C are enlarged from the structures indicated by arrows and arrowheads. The tobacco epidermal cell was transiently cotransformed by agroinfiltration (see Batoko et al., 2000). D, Colocalization of a GFP-NtRAB5 (green) with a CFP-labeled NtRAB11b (red) in an elongating pollen tube showing the polarized concentration of Rab11-labeled transport vesicles in the apex and the localization of Rab5-labeled endosomes in the subtending cytoplasm (B–D; T. Andreyeva and A.Y. Cheung, unpublished data). In mammalian cells, the early secretory pathway of ER to Golgi trafficking and intra-Golgi trafficking are mediated by RAB1 and RAB2 (Zerial and McBride, 2001). Whereas mammalian RAB1 regulates anterograde ER to Golgi trafficking, RAB2 may be more important in intra-Golgi and retrograde Golgi to ER trafficking. While homologs of both RAB1 and RAB2 are found in plants, RAB2 homologs are not found in yeast, where RAB1 alone sufficiently supports the early secretory pathway (Segev et al., 1988). Similar to mammalian RAB1 (Haubruck et al., 1989), plant RAB1/RABDs are able to complement the yeast ypt1 mutation. On the other hand, a RAB2 from soybean (Glycine max) failed to complement ypt1 (Kim et al., 1996; Park et al., 1997). The functional divergence between RAB1D and RAB2B implicated by these studies remains to be vigorously examined in plant cells. In Arabidopsis, the RAB1/RABD family is comprised of five subspecies (Pereira-Leal and Seabra, 2001; Rutherford and Moore, 2002; Vernoud et al., 2003). One of these, RAB1b, has been localized to the ER and Golgi in transiently transformed epidermal cells expressing the GFP-labeled protein (Batoko et al., 2000). Expression of a DN RAB1b induced the accumulation of a secreted form of GFP and a Golgi-targeted N-glycosylated GFP variant in a membrane reticulate reminiscent of the ER. This and the accumulation of an endoglycosidase H-sensitive population of the Golgi-targeted GFP confirmed that trafficking from ER to the Golgi was inhibited in cells compromised in their RAB1-regulated trafficking activity as a result of DN RAB1b overexpression. Developmentally, a recent study in maritime pine (Pinus pinaster) revealed high levels of expression of a RAB1, PpRAB1, in early zygotic development followed by decline as embryos matured, suggesting a role for this small GTPase in early embryogenesis (Goncalves et al., 2007). The RAB2/RABB GTPase family is relatively small, represented by two to four members in Arabidopsis, maize (Zea mays), and rice (Oryza sativa; Pereira-Leal and Seabra, 2001; Rutherford and Moore, 2002; Vernoud et al., 2003; Zhang et al., 2007). The functional significance of the RAB2/RABB-regulated pathway has been examined in pollen tubes, which represent one of the most dramatic polar growth cell types in nature (Cheung et al., 2002). In addition to an extensive ER system that spans the entire pollen tube cytoplasm except at the extreme apex, pollen tubes maintain a highly polarized organelle distribution pattern with an extremely high density of transport vesicles segregated to the while the Golgi and the are to the and of the tube (Cheung and a of the secreted proteins that have been examined, vesicles with these proteins in the in to with the membrane or as recycled vesicles et al., 2001). with of the polarized distribution in particular of the of In tobacco pollen tubes, with Golgi Expression of DN the of GFP-labeled proteins to their while and a membrane a role for in the early secretory While not cell membrane protein their was compromised as the accumulation of vesicles with these molecules in the tube apex and pollen tube growth both In in one of its structures on suggesting a role in cell in cells et al., 2007). In both yeast and animal systems, the of GTPases are relatively small in to the entire RAB GTPase family of in and two of in yeast (Pereira-Leal and Seabra, 2001; and 2001). In of the 57 RAB GTPases in Arabidopsis are GTPases. the large of GTPases to be a conserved in most plants, as large of this class of proteins have been in and et al., Zhang et al., 2007). In members of the family have been found to regulate trafficking through endosomal compartments recycling endosomes et al., while in yeast, regulate of secretory and endocytic from the et al., 1996; et al., et al., roles for these RAB GTPases in aspects of yeast and animal cell have been as well et al., 2003; et al., 2003; and 2006). role GTPases play in growth and development of of that at some members of this RAB GTPase family play important roles in recycling of cell in GTPases have been localized as proteins or by cell and appear to to compartments that with and endosomal compartments et al., 2002; et al., et al., 2005; et al., of GTPases in in complex and which be to cell et al., 2001). In Arabidopsis, polarized distribution to membrane compartments that at the of cells (Preuss et al., through its with a of regulates growth (Preuss et al., 2006). in tobacco NtRAB11b to vesicular while in and out of the of pollen tubes, at the of these polar growth cells of DN and of this RAB GTPase with pollen tube in particular with growth at the et al., a role for members of the GTPases in the of through polarized of cell or through of polar recycling pollen tube and of the subcellular distribution of two other Arabidopsis RAB11/RABA, and has shown that these GTPases to membranes that the of the membrane compartments to which these two family members localized be with the endocytic that at some members of the compartments are by endocytic membrane in this expression of a DN form of resulted in formation of cells and cell with a role in polarized of to of cell et al., these a role for members of the GTPase family in trafficking between the plant and the in the study of these membrane compartments will be to determine the to which this large family of GTPases on similar or distinct compartments and to determine to these compartments are in trafficking of secretory or endocytic The yeast and mammalian homologs functional with polarized of proteins from the Golgi to the as regulating polarized the in yeast and et al., and membrane trafficking in mammalian cells et al., activity in resulted in cellular and of to membrane and of proteins et al., 1996; et al., 2006; et al., 2007). In and polarized in to and anterograde trafficking in these et al., vesicle trafficking is critical for membrane in the a organelle with function on the of most cells et al., 2007). The Arabidopsis family is comprised of five closely related members (Rutherford and Moore, 2002; Vernoud et al., 2003). functional studies have been for in transiently transformed epidermal cells. Studies on a DN form of in with similar in the and class of GTPases, and and a large of marker proteins or that the Arabidopsis is and that DN anterograde trafficking to the membrane and secretory activity to the pathway et al., In a GTPase has been as with the from the and this was on the of the cell a role in vesicular activity with the of a response and 2000). has been from suggesting a role in cell processes that are on of proteins et al., 2003). will be important to how the and pathways and in the steps of membrane trafficking. The RAB GTPase in is which was to regulate early endosomal and between endocytic vesicles and early endosomes et al., et al., this small GTPase was shown to be in a of endocytic et al., 1999; et al., of membrane on endosomes through the of et al., 1999; and and between the endosomes and et al., In the significance of members in plants was not the plant was et al., This be to the the of in plant cells and however, recycling and or of membrane proteins and have been in plant cells is as an of plant and Jürgens, which to the are homologs in the Arabidopsis and et al., 2001; and The two to be to animal GTPases with high similarity to animal In as of a This particular has not been in organisms other than plants, its one of the more of the of plant RAB GTPases in addition to an extremely family. of that plant function in the endocytic Arabidopsis proteins on punctate which are by the FM4-64 et al., et al., 2005; et al., The of FM4-64 was inhibited by DN and a from the membrane is induced by an through the endosomes to the et al., the of an endosomal for was recently that the plant endosomal and compartments are by FM4-64 this endosomes or et al., compartments with which are by FM4-64 a of than endosomes et al., 2006). that compartments function as earlier endosomes than it is not clear however, and compartments function in the same endocytic in a or are on pathways. localization of proteins as and be or inhibited by its or et al., 2005; et al., 2005; et al., 2006) on distinct will be to be more On the other hand, are that critical roles in the transport proteins with marker molecules known to be on the or multivesiculated endosomes and et al., 2003; et al., et al., et al., and of DN the transport of proteins to et al., 2003; et al., proteins be in both endocytic and transport suggesting that these two transport pathways at in plant cells. and on of multivesiculated compartments with et al., et al., suggesting that these two have This is by with the gene their et al., studies are The is found in plant which that the critical roles of in vesicular trafficking are well conserved in The known is a with a small which not a sequence et al., is of to out how it is is known to regulate membrane at the and its yeast the of to however, have not been The Arabidopsis genome eight proteins, of which to the membrane et al., 2002; T. unpublished The functions of the proteins to be highly and not abnormal unpublished data). On the other hand, the in which a of a downstream effector complex of was et al., suggesting the of function in plant be in the as indicated by the of and et al., and as well as studies, will the function of this more The formation of transport vesicles on donor membranes with the of of protein mediated by a class of small GTPases, the family. studies in and mammalian cells have revealed that this class of GTPase regulates steps in the formation of transport of and transport transport to specific of proteins and regulatory for and in transport from the ER to the Golgi, and in transport from the Golgi to the ER or intra-Golgi and and ARFs in steps in or endocytic pathways Gillingham and Munro, 2007; and 2007). proteins and GTPases are well conserved in plants, the with and to be in the ARF was as a of in was found to be an for and and directly to the a of and which the of facilitating the of molecules into plant the function of yeast et al., et al., the function of be conserved in plants, the distribution and of plant ER where is to are in a distinct from or et al., 2006). In plants, of membrane trafficking pathways between the ER and Golgi compartments important from animal and yeast systems. not Golgi membranes into (Preuss et al., and while in Golgi are in large the plants large of that et al., et al., The distinctions with to of ER and Golgi membranes in these systems have to the roles and of of the and trafficking In plants, proteins with ER membranes as well as at and with activity in defects in trafficking from the ER to the Golgi and et al., et al., On the other hand, some plant on ER other systems, protein of of the proteins and have been found localized at in the of Golgi et al., 2005; et al., 2006; Stefano et al., 2006; et al., while is the ER et al., et al., This that of the vesicle may be on of the ER the at the et al., ARF was as a required in the of by and and but the not to be in cellular activity. The mammalian ARF family of ARF and ARF proteins are into on and functional ARF are to the of and to play a role in However, the of vesicle formation and have not been to vesicles to the of an in system for this GTPases but not related to ARF proteins are as and are in various cellular In plants, has been shown to to Golgi and and with this protein various plant as cell cell cell and et al., 2005; and which to mammalian to the membrane et al., a conserved family of ARF proteins of ARF and subgroups et al., 2003). ARFs to have critical roles in steps of the membrane retrograde and anterograde trafficking and transport et al., 2002; et al., 2002; et al., 2003). studies recently on the ARF GEFs that and of ARF is critical for both transport through the Golgi and endosomal recycling et al., 2007; Teh and Moore, 2007). for proteins, a that this is in various cellular functions et al., et al., 2002; Stefano et al., but the and significance of most members is to be the function of a small GTPase is out by between its active GTP-bound form and the inactive GDP-bound form (Fig. from the inactive to active is by bound GDP with GTP, which of the for the yeast are conserved in and ARF GEFs are by a conserved ARF GEFs are into eight Arabidopsis two of and proteins, suggesting that was of plant ARF In recent studies revealed that two ARF and which are to have from the ARF are a function in endosomal recycling in addition to the function on the Golgi et al., 2007; Teh and Moore, 2007). of the RAB in plants is but from Arabidopsis was recently found to be a specific for et al., 2007). to be the that both and in Arabidopsis. In GEFs with structures have been shown to activate at distinct steps in the endocytic pathway in animal cells et al., 2006). that RAB GEFs have evolved from the animal functions in their active GTPases are by GTP to which is by the GAP (Fig. GTP hydrolysis on the yeast is facilitated by which has a in Arabidopsis. are ARF GAPs in Arabidopsis, some of which have been and as with abnormal vein in an and are of an ARF GAP (Koizumi et al., 2005; Sieburth et al., 2006). The previously was as a gene responsible for a vein (Koizumi et al., 2000). this that a ARF GTPase which is for auxin is critical for vein Another ARF GTPase activity of are defective in that ARF an important role in growth et al., 2006). RAB activity in plant cells was earlier et al., and a rice has been et al., is currently information on its small GTPases from the membrane and are in the GDP-bound inactive the of the GTPase cycle (Fig. While members not require specific factors for this of most RAB GTPases from membranes is mediated by a conserved protein the RAB GDP The to this is which is recycled from membranes of RAB et al., 2001). RAB to GDP-bound RABs and them in the GDP-bound by GDP conserved RAB with specificity et al., 1996; et al., et al., in to GEFs and which interact with specific RAB A of the GTPase cycle with from the and to the which is mediated by The family of proteins, homologs are found in plants, is proposed to this function et al., 2003) but has not been in While GTP-binding and hydrolysis are to RAB GTPase regulatory it is the and of the RAB GTPases with effector proteins that these RAB GTPases to out their regulatory functions in membrane trafficking. In animal and yeast systems, has been in RAB effector proteins (Zerial and McBride, 2001; et al., 2006; 2007). of RAB GTPase function indicated that these small GTPases an role in of membrane to membrane and and However, as identification of RAB effector proteins has the functions of these effectors have roles for RAB GTPases in a of RAB GTPase function roles in diverse aspects of membrane trafficking, as vesicle formation et al., of proteins et al., et al., et al., 1999; et al., 2002; et al., and vesicle and et al., 1999; et al., 1999; et al., 1999; et al., et al., 2001). In plants, RAB effector proteins have been and The of RAB effectors it that plant RAB effectors be by sequence similarity alone (Zerial and McBride, 2001). However, some RAB as et al., are in Arabidopsis. One has been shown to be an effector of and important roles in of polarized in plants (Preuss et al., 2006). specific are with RAB effector protein functions et al., et al., and have been shown to be recruited to endosomal compartments et al., that plant endosomes identification of plant RAB effector proteins is to our of RAB GTPase functions membrane trafficking in plants and will be required to the roles of plant RAB GTPase and their functions in plant-specific membrane trafficking. the for fundamental of the regulatory small GTPases for vesicular trafficking is well in a of how these plant RABs and ARFs on the cellular and how the processes mediate plant and response to the the functions of members within each of the RAB are conserved or have and to members from may in their functional pathways in On the cell biological and identification of effectors is to be an to functional divergence among related small GTPases and how specificity between these small GTPases and the trafficking pathway mediate is that (see e.g. et al., between these small GTPases with their and their target membrane compartments regulatory and functional that are most to be important aspects of how vesicular trafficking pathways are While of the functional significance of RAB- and ARF-regulated vesicular trafficking in cell growth and plant development is how plants on a system to specific and as in response to and remains to be will RABs and ARFs as fundamental regulators of vesicular trafficking in plant cells to the roles that these small GTPases have evolved to needs that are to the growth and strategies in The are in the of this of vesicular in elongating tobacco pollen tubes showing the of vesicular trafficking in these polar growth cell types and localization of the vesicular structures to the from and
Language: English
Subfield: Cell Biology
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2103936125
FWCI: 0.949
Cites: 124
Cited by: 213
Related to: 9